The 6th Hall Of Fame

Good, I was hoping that wasn't the case.

Mostly agree on this list. Fully agree on the live action stuff on it (expect that I found Man From Earth to be very good in fact), in fact I added the winner into my top 50 movies of all time list. Really amazing movie and I am happy that friendly mushroom nominated it. It was the best movie that I discovered in these competitions so far.

Though I obviously liked my nomination more than most it is still something that I knew there was a very high probability of people hating it here, still it was an experiment worth undertaking and part of my program on the forum's education on animation and contemporary popular culture. I am glad Neiba liked it.

Wow Raul, I know you hated Sonatine but how dare you place it beneath K-On?

My list:

1. Brokeback Mountain
2. Das Boot
3. Sonatine
4. Raise the Red Lantern
5. Woman in the Dunes
6. All Quiet on the Western Front
7. This Boy’s Life
8. Late Spring
9. A Perfect World
10. The Sweet Hereafter
11. Fail-Safe
12. Rushmore
13. Pierrot Le Fou
14. Before the Devil Knows You’re Dead
15. Foreign Correspondent
16. K-On
17. Ten
18. The Man From Earth

(Didn't see Blue Car)

I had a hard time ordering, especially around the middle of the list. Top 6 were easy.

I can't help but wonder what the list would have looked like if all the films had stayed in. I think Das Boot would have been a worthy winner.

But I'm fine with All Quiet on the Western Front. It's a good film, it got mostly positive reactions, and it's nice to see some interest in a 30s film. I'm quite looking forward to when we eventually get round to the MoFo Top 100 of the 1930s, so I have an excuse to watch some more films from that decade.

This was a fun hall of fame, thanks for hosting it. I was glad to finally watch Raise the Red Lantern and Woman in the Dunes particularly.

Congrats Mushroom, I feel that your nomination is a truly great movie and a worthy winner. I loved participating in this HoF; although I didn't especially like every movie, they all had their positives and none were difficult to watch.

My list-

6th Hall of Fame

1. All Quiet on the Western Front
2. Before the Devil Knows You're Dead
3. Late Spring
4. Woman in the Dunes
5. Fail Safe
6. Raise the Red Lantern
7. A Perfect World
8. Brokeback Mountain
9. The Sweet Hereafter
10. Rushmore
11. Das Boot
12. Foreign Correspondent
13. This Boy's Life
14. Sonatine
15. The Man From Earth
16. Blue Car
17. Pierrot Le Fou
18. Ten
19. K-On!

Thank you Sean, you did a fantastic job as expected!

Wow! I'm so happy about the winner! Congrats Mushroom, great nomination and the only movie that placed higher than my own nomination on my own list.
And Fail-Safe ranked pretty high too! I like to think that I'm a bit responsible if it appears on the 60s list, and that was my goal when I nominated it!

It was a great HoF, congrats to everyone for a lot of amazing nominations and to sean for being such a great host!

My list:

1. all quiet on the western front
2. fail safe
3. the man from earth
4. pierrot le fou
5. raise the red lantern
6. the sweet hereafter
7. sonatine
8. brokeback mountain
9. before the devil knows your dead
10. rushmore
11. foreign correspondent
12. late spring
13. woman in the dunes (edit)
14. k-on
15. a perfect world
16. this boy's life
17. ten
18. blue car

Onibaba? That would've been my number 1. Hopefully you're thinking of your 60's list.

Ya, I noticed the mistake! I wrote Onibaba instead of Suna no onna (Swan's nomination). I sent a message to sean. If he didn't notice the mistake, it probably means that Swan won this HoF!

Please say it isn't so Sean

I don't seem to have my list saved on my computer or in my sent items anymore.

__________________

I noticed. Woman In The Dunes received the correct score. I thought that was going to be the winner. It had a very low placing that probably kept it from winning.

__________________
Letterboxd

I didn't mind Dunes, but I think AQOTWF is most worthy.

I already deleted the lists but I think I was the person who put All Quiet lowest on their list. Just didn't grab me.

Thanks for all of the support here. I had a lot of fun with this HoF. I love All Quiet.

Here's my list.

1. All Quiet on the Western Front
(Das Boot)
2. Woman in the Dunes
3. A Perfect World
4. Before the Devil Knows Your Dead
5. This Boy’s Life
6. Fail Safe
7. Late Spring
8. Brokeback Mountain
9. The Man From Earth
10. Raise The Red Lantern
(The Sweet Hereafter) (Poor Godoggo )
11. Sonatine
12. Foreign Correspondent
13. K-ON
14. Blue Car
15. Ten
16. Pierrot le Fou
17. Rushmore

Congrats FM, you nominated a worthy winner

Found it:

1. A Perfect World
2. Before the Devil Knows You’re Dead
3. This Boy’s Life
4. Woman in the Dunes
5. Raise the Red Lantern
6. The Sweet Hereafter
7. Blue Car
8. Brokeback Mountain
9. Fail Safe
10. Das Boot
11. Sonatine
12. All Quiet On the Western Front
13. Late Spring
14. The Man From Earth
15. Pierrot le Fou
16. Ten
17. Rushmore
18. Foreign Correspondent
19. K-On!

You guys really don't like Foreign Correspondent. I should have joined, I would have most likely ranked it high.

Question: in a nut shell what are people not liking about Foreign Correspondent?

The discussion thread for it is here.

I took a gamble and it definitely didn't pay off.