I'm not particularly sure on ratings, but these two left me dissapointed...
Spotlight (Tom McCarthy, 2015)
Nothing here really impressed me that much. Everything just seemed so standard, like a made for TV documentary but with big movie stars playing the parts. Nothing cinematic in the way the story is told, no through dialogue or visually. I felt like there were a lot of missed opportunities to go beyond what turned out to be a really simple plot. There were scenes, moments which seemed to be begging to explore in greater depth - the church and why the scandal occurred and why it was covered up, the priests who committed the abuse (a scene about halfway through is one of the most memorable relating to this, and is never again revisted), the victims and their story, or those who perhaps could have acted earlier. I'm not sure why everyone is raving about this, an easy comparison to make given the setting but it really is a poor man's
All The President's Men. I saw too that Rachel McAdams got nominated for an Oscar for her performance... really really lazy nomination, not that she's bad, but she doesn't really have that much acting to do here.
Room (Lenny Abrahamson, 2015)
Unlike
Spotlight,
Room at least made some effort to tell its story in a cinematic way. I found myself very interested in the first hour, the scenes with Tremblay and Larson in "room" were very good, the world and characters were developed well, I felt emotional at times, I was on the edge of my seat as to what would happen next. Then in the second half the film goes massively downhill. It's like they had the first hour, the concept of this room, but beyond that had no idea where to take the film. Again, it touches on various different issues, but never really explores or justifies their inclusion in a satisfying way for me.