Rate that Movie: Mulholland Dr

__________________

0

__________________
Mubi

clowns! not counting 0 votes unless you make a compelling case for it

I give it a 0

You're counting 10s automatically.

__________________
It's what you learn after you know it all that counts. - John Wooden
My IMDb page

Bluedeed, do you really not like that film? I thought it would be one you'd like.

Just split the difference and count 0s as 10s.

__________________
#31 on SC's Top 100 Mofos list!!

said the same thing to ashdoc on the Matrix thread, not gonna change now

to give something a zero is to say it is nothing

basically i just think it's lazy

i'll count it if the person is willing to go to the effort to make a genuinely interesting post illuminating us as to why the movie is a total failure and deserves nothing at all

I think he's joking around. I know he really likes Lynch, or at least he used to.

Anyway I think this is a great film, but there's a number of Lynch films I would put ahead of it unlike a lot of you here, would be interesting to see one of these threads for Inland Empire, now that would be interesting

Big Inland Empire fan, as well...

__________________

8/10

I legitimately think this movie is terrible. Two scenes keep it from getting a 0 for me. The dIner and the concert. People tell me its dream like and campy. To me it has nothing close to an engaging narrative, is poorly written, and poorly acted.

__________________
Letterboxd

Poorly acted? It's Watts' best performance by far.... Also, narrative? It's surrealist film...

Alas: Each, to his own!

Lynch is cool with me. I was using a relative rating system

Although it's your opinion I don't agree, definitely not poorly written, just because it's not written in a linear structure, it's meant to be deliberately confusing, and definitely not poorly acted, Watts and Harring (sp?) are brilliant, the concert scene proves this.

How does this relative system work then for it to be a 0? Unless your just using the angry IMDB voter system to balance out the high score

AIVS is almost as good a rating system as AIDS

21 Grams is her best performance.

The problem I have with the film is that even Lynch himself barely knows what this film is about.