+9
It may be boring but I always vote for who I think deserves it.
TUS vs HK
If HK were invisible now then I would maybe go the other way. He's still active and he's one of the few whose body of work eclipses Suspect's.
cricket vs Raul
More posts and threads, longer tenured, and hosts countdowns and HoFs. Use my vote as a tiebreaker if it comes down to it.
Mark vs Cat
Cat is A+, now multiply that by however many years and you get Mark.
Captain Spaulding vs Joel
Joel sure is around more but Captain has time put in and nothing but great posts.