Originally Posted by Sedai
Dark Water (Nakata, 2002) - I skipped the remake, and if this piece is the original, and supposedly better, I am glad I did! Not a great film. A few spooky scenes, but not much else...
Iku-Chan! Iku-Chan!
Gah, I thought it was scary as hell... The original, I mean. Haven't seen the remake.
Originally Posted by Sinny McGuffins
I don't quite understand why people rave about these Japanese horror films. They're not scary at all, they're just boring. And the American remakes are even worst (well, at least the ones I actually bothered to watch).
Scary or not, I think what fans of Asian horror appreciate, or at least many of them, is the tempo (which, yes, can be considered boring by some) and the fact that the films are often more complex than your traditional Hollywood horror flick. A lot of the times the Asian movies are traditional but updated ghost stories where it's not always clear who and what is good and/or evil. Often the ghosts have some kind of sympathetic feature or "are ghosts" because of ..ehrm.. understandable reasons.
I loved
Dark Water. I thought it was even better than
Ringu in some ways. Often when I watch an "ordinary" scary movie I tend to get numbed towards the end because the incredibly intense scare-the-audience factor. When watching, say,
Ringu you almost forget that you're watching a horror flick sometimes because the actual plot is allowed to take a lot of space while the horror parts arrive more seldomly and unannounced. I think the Asian horror tradition perhaps (I'm no expert) is more about creating a certain creepy mood than about to shock. Even if the one thing doesn't exclude the other.
What I am critical about though is the way some people hail ALL Asian horror. It's only natural that everyone wants to ride the wave so there are a lot of copycats out there and far from all the movies are as great as some say they are. I saw a Korean film called
The Ghost that did scare me, I must admit, but that owned a great deal to
Ringu, and it wasn't very good.