Congratulations to Neiba! It is a very good film that does deserve to earn a title as a Hall of Fame winner.
Thanks to Friendly Mushroom for hosting this. But how many months did this take? I swear it was like it was never-ending.
That is why I should drag out my movie-watching in these things rather than watch every nomination as soon as one of these begins. It wouldn't seem like it takes as long then.
Sorry if I offended you, it wasn't my intention. I was just saying that I think people should try to nominate films others haven't seen. I enjoyed revisiting the film, and was glad it was nominated. Sorry if I accidentally insulted your intelligence.
Thank you for the apology. I appreciate it, but I don't see what harm there is to nominating a film that a lot of people have see before. Truthfully, I didn't even assume that everyone had seen something that I was going to nominate. Not only that, I know not everyone had seen it before (i.e. Friendly Mushroom).
Besides, what about the HoF that had "Psycho" in it. I almost figure more people would've seen that movie than "Goodfellas". And that one won it. "The Shawshank Redemption" is another one that I think I could put in that category. That won, too.
My list (excluding the disqualified nominations):
1. Goodfellas
2. Anatomy Of a Murder
3. The Shop Around the Corner
4. Paths of Glory
5. Coming Home
6. The Gold Rush
7. Spirited Away
8. A Man For All Seasons
9. Lady Killer
10. The Road Warrior
11. Patlabor 2
12. My Life As a Dog
13. Head-On
Yes, I had "Goodfellas" at number one. Not because it was my nomination, but because I think it is, by far, the best out of these films this time. I thought "Anatomy Of a Murder" was a very close second, though.
Did I "nominate" it, or did I "nomiante" it?