BTTF is really more of an adventure film. Anyway, more evidence that a MoFo Comedy list is necessary.
Suggestions for future countdowns
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
I think "funniest" might help a bit, simply because if you say "comedy" some people will take it to mean "best overall film that still qualifies as a comedy." Obviously "funniest" is still remarkably subjective and plenty of fights will still happen, but I do think it at least rules out those films with significant elements of humor, but who aren't explicitly adored for that humor because they're also great dramas/sci-fi/whatever.
I think it's a very marginal improvement, though. It'll just be fraught no matter what.
I think it's a very marginal improvement, though. It'll just be fraught no matter what.
X
Favorite Movies
BTTF is a sci fi comedy, and I’ll grant you the adventure elements of it. Hybrids do exist, and shouldn’t necessarily exclude one or the other
X
Favorite Movies
It's definitely got a comic sensibility, no argument there, I guess I think more of the adventure and scifi than the comedy, but its fuzzy
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
I feel like 2010s should be an obvious choice for the next one
__________________
Yeah, there's no body mutilation in it
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
I feel like 2010s should be an obvious choice for the next one
If we want to do a non decade though I would truly consider Foreign because it seemed to be grossly underrepresented in the Mofo Top 100 for the most part.
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
Was checking out Holden's thread the other day, my 2010's ballot is pretty far from ready.. 2000's is getting there, could complete it within a couple of months. Same goes for Noir.
War ballot is almost ready, 80's, Sci-Fi, Thriller, Comedy ballots are always ready.
War ballot is almost ready, 80's, Sci-Fi, Thriller, Comedy ballots are always ready.
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
Again and still I vote for a proper 2000-2009 list before embarking on a 2010-2019 list. That also gives that much extra time for movies from the last couple years of the last decade to filter to television or your local library or however people catch movies.
__________________
"Film is a disease. When it infects your bloodstream it takes over as the number one hormone. It bosses the enzymes, directs the pineal gland, plays Iago to your psyche. As with heroin, the antidote to Film is more Film." - Frank Capra
"Film is a disease. When it infects your bloodstream it takes over as the number one hormone. It bosses the enzymes, directs the pineal gland, plays Iago to your psyche. As with heroin, the antidote to Film is more Film." - Frank Capra
X
Favorite Movies
I'd agree with that, more distance, less likely to fluctuate, etc. And it makes sense to do them "in order" somewhat.
(Standard caveat that my opinions on list things are just one person's opinion, they do not--or at least should not--have any extra weight. The lists are community-led and I'm here to support them, not direct them. )
(Standard caveat that my opinions on list things are just one person's opinion, they do not--or at least should not--have any extra weight. The lists are community-led and I'm here to support them, not direct them. )
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
I love Film Noir but doing even a top fifty is problematic much less getting enough participation for a top hundred. I belong to a few different Noir Facebook groups and they spend much more than half the time fighting about what does and doesn't constitute Noir. Even if you cut it off at the classic Noir period (about 1958 or so) you will have trouble finding more than ten or twenty MoFos who are going to watch fifty or sixty titles from the '40s and '50s to make a list. When you start including Neo Noir, or whatever other label you give to it, then not only do you include obvious things like Chinatown but you have to have a zillion arguments over every single thriller with scenes set at night.
Since there is no real consensus about what exactly constitutes the genre, even among Film Noir aficionados, opening it up to more casual viewers or trying to be inclusive enough that sixty or eighty MoFos might participate and turn in ballots...that is going to be very, very tough. You can call it "Crime Films" instead of Film Noir, but then you are going so broad you are getting away from genre and even the biggest actual Noirs will be crowded out by the likes of Silence of the Lambs so why even bother? Personally I can make a list of a hundred great to good classic Film Noirs, but I am insane and it is a genre I have done deep dives on for decades. I believe Film Noir is better left to the Hall of Fames where small groups can give a sampling the proper attention.
War Films are a little more clear cut a genre than Film Noir but are also problematic. Most think of "war film" as those narratives about soldiers in combat. All Quiet On the Western Front and Platoon and Glory are obviously war films. But what about Schindler's List and The Pianist and other Holocaust films which do not cover combat? What about films like Coming Home and The Best Years of Our Lives that cover the effects of war on veterans and survivors? What about Henry V or 300 or Troy that are set during more ancient wars? What about The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers or Starship Troopers and other fantasy wars? What about films set during real wars that are complete fictions like Casablanca, Inglourious Basterds, The Dirty Dozen, or Kelly's Heroes? What about Fail-Safe or Bridge of Spies and other films dealing with the 20th Century Cold War? What about comedies, be they Dr. Strangelove, Duck Soup, or Stripes?
You can deal with all of that, but as I say it is problematic.
Last edited by Holden Pike; 01-22-21 at 03:27 PM.
X
Favorite Movies
Film Noir, Comedy, War countdowns or most any other genre countdown CAN be done simply by using IMDBs genre tags. Not perfect but no countdown ever is...AND at least it's fair as a movie is eligible for the countdown if it's IMDB genre tag matches the genre countdown being done. If it doesn't have a tag it's not allowed.
That is by far the most fair way for a genre countdown to be done.
That is by far the most fair way for a genre countdown to be done.
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
Yeah, but then Jaws doesn't qualify again.
__________________
It's what you learn after you know it all that counts. - John Wooden
My IMDb page
It's what you learn after you know it all that counts. - John Wooden
My IMDb page
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
Can we do a list of 'Really Good bad movies'?
The great thing about the decade lists is there is a defined, simple criteria. Was it made during this ten year span? It was? Then it is eligible, end of debate. Once you get away from that...it gets messy.
X
Favorite Movies
Film Noir, Comedy, War countdowns or most any other genre countdown CAN be done simply by using IMDBs genre tags. Not perfect but no countdown ever is...AND at least it's fair as a movie is eligible for the countdown if it's IMDB genre tag matches the genre countdown being done. If it doesn't have a tag it's not allowed.
That is by far the most fair way for a genre countdown to be done.
That is by far the most fair way for a genre countdown to be done.
Markf brought up Jaws again.
They have Jaws 2 as horror, what makes that more horror than the first?
I go over to Letterbox, they have Jaws listed as horror. I look at Rottentomatoes and they list it as Horror. I look at MetaCritic and they list it as horror.
Why are we picking IMDb when every other site seems to be in agreement? It just feels....odd to me. Maybe pick 3 sites to reference and if 2/3 of them are in agreement, use that consensus? I don't know. I don't want to get into another debate about this but it always seems to raise issues.
__________________
"A laugh can be a very powerful thing. Why, sometimes in life, it's the only weapon we have."
Suspect's Reviews
"A laugh can be a very powerful thing. Why, sometimes in life, it's the only weapon we have."
Suspect's Reviews
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
Any genre countdown could be done and we've already have done many. Whatever countdown we do next, needs to be put up to a vote with a poll, the most popular choice wins...If there's more than one person who wishes to host, we need to put that up to vote too. That's fair.
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
Personally I like the idea of only doing non-decades if there's a pretty clear consensus. If you have seven options and one of them wins by a single vote, and with like 35% of the vote because the vote is so split, then two-thirds of the voters will be disappointed. I think genre lists work better when there's a lot of demand for them, so maybe there should be a clear genre choice to overcome the default position of doing the next decade in line. What does everyone think about that?
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
Also, I will preemptively volunteer myself as a human sacrifice to make genre qualification choices if the Curator does not want to deal with the headache. I'll be the bad guy. Only if they don't want to, that is.
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
Personally I like the idea of only doing non-decades if there's a pretty clear consensus. If you have seven options and one of them wins by a single vote, and with like 35% of the vote because the vote is so split, then two-thirds of the voters will be disappointed. I think genre lists work better when there's a lot of demand for them, so maybe there should be a clear genre choice to overcome the default position of doing the next decade in line. What does everyone think about that?
Also, I will preemptively volunteer myself as a human sacrifice to make genre qualification choices if the Curator does not want to deal with the headache. I'll be the bad guy. Only if they don't want to, that is.
There has been a lot of support for Foreign Language too.
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
A 'clear consensus'...but then shouldn't that also apply equally to decades? I believe the current countdown only won as a choice by a very narrow margin and yet it was wildly successfully. So I'm not so sure winning by a clear margin is all that important. Whatever is done it should be by a poll with MoFos deciding.
Anyway, I'll participate in any of them. Just noting that I think time-based lists are kind of "safe" relative to others.
X
Favorite Movies
X