Violation, 2020
Miriam (Madeleine Sims-Fewer) has a fraught relationship with her sister, Greta (Anna Maguire), something that really comes to a boiling point when the two of them plus Miriam's boyfriend Caleb (Obi Abili) and Greta's husband Dylan (Jesse LaVercombe) spend a weekend together at a cabin. Things get out of hand between Miriam and Dylan after a night of drinking, and Miriam sets out for revenge.
I had started watching this film and then bailed because it was too uncomfortable, but I'm glad I went back to finish it. I think that it takes the horror/thriller trope of the rape-revenge film and does some really interesting, challenging things with it.
The main strength of the film, in my opinion, rests in the lead performances from Simes-Frewer (who also directs) and LaVercombe. It is their chemistry and dynamic that is most at the center of the story for much of the film, and they pull off something really special in the way that these two flawed characters collide and damage each other. What's amazing is that at different points, often simultaneously, you feel empathy and loathing for both of them.
In horror movies, there exists a kind of demented sense of proportionality. We often accept, or even celebrate, acts of violence that are not to scale with the original offense. For example, a character who is a bully might shove our protagonist into a locker, and we later are given permission to cheer as that bully is impaled or otherwise violently dispatched.
Violation sets its sights squarely on that idea of proportional revenge, directly confronting what it means to go too far from the point of view of a character who seems to live in that more theatrical sense of justice.
The set up for all of this is a sequence of sexual assault that occurs between Miriam and Dylan. Now, a lot of sexual assault in horror movies (and there is a
lot of sexual assault in horror movies!) is of the stranger danger variety. These sequence usually have almost no nuance to them, and the attackers are rarely given any dimension. The assault sequence in
Violation is, to say the least, incredibly complicated. Miriam and Dylan have an obvious sexual chemistry, and we see them have several intimate conversations. Further, at one point Miriam kisses Dylan, though she immediately regrets it and says that it was a mistake. The next morning, while Miriam is asleep, Dylan pulls her clothes down and has sex with her. She tells him to stop, he doesn't.
So is it a sexual assault? Absolutely. But is it a lot more complicated than what we usually get in a horror film? Absolutely. One of the best sequences occurs when Miriam confronts Dylan about what he did. "I was asleep and you f*cked me!" she accuses. The look on Dylan's face is really something. Up to this point, he's repeatedly said "
We messed up" and "
We made a mistake." Does his expression mean that he genuinely thought she'd be okay with it? Is he upset that his pushing the whole "we" aspect isn't working on Miriam? When Miriam makes it clear that she sees it as an assault, Dylan repeatedly references that she kissed him. When she says that she took it back and that she told him to stop, he goes back again to the fact that "we" messed up.
But there's another wrinkle to this situation, and that's how Miriam approaches conflict. As we learn from Greta, Miriam is somewhat fixated on retribution when she is wronged, to the point of not thinking about the consequences. One possible reading of the assault scene---where Miriam says "stop" once but then doesn't protest again---is that she somewhat "allows" it to happen because it gives her moral leverage against Dylan. (This is further complicated by the fact that we can't know what Dylan would have done if she protested more forcefully---would be have stopped or would he have continued to force himself on her?).
And so, finally, Miriam pursues her revenge against Dylan, an it is brutal. As gross as I found Dylan--and he is a rapist, even if he doesn't seem to think so--the movie pretty quickly establishes that Miriam's intentions are not proportional to the crime. And there's something incredibly chilling about the way that Miriam alternates calm and mania in her behavior. It's as if being wronged has given Miriam permission to unleash the beast, and something really cruel and cold was lurking under the surface just waiting to be turned loose.
One complaint that I read in another review was that the pace of the film is slow and has a lot of interludes of nature imagery. This is true, but since I like nature imagery, I didn't mind so much.
Worth it alone for the nuanced performance from LaVercombe and the chilling turn from Sims-Fewer, but I also happen to think that this is a really interesting take on the rape-revenge trope, and one that takes a more critical look at the character who would normally be the "hero" of such a story.