Movie Forums (http://www.movieforums.com/community/index.php)
-   Ongoing Tournaments & Brackets (http://www.movieforums.com/community/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Horror Hall of Fame II (http://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?t=58329)

pahaK 12-02-18 02:36 AM

Horror Hall of Fame II
 
Horror Hall of Fame II

https://media.giphy.com/media/dapqHgVKA6YuY/giphy.gif

Welcome to the Horror Hall of Fame II!

Registration has ended!

All ballots must be received by 12:00 midnight (Pacific Time) the night of
Saturday, February 16th 2019.

(If people want to get this over faster all you need to do is send your votes in earlier. I'll wrap things up immediately everyone has voted :D)

Participants (9):
pahaK - 9/9 VOTED
Siddon - 9/9 VOTED
cricket - 9/9 VOTED
Derek Vinyard - 9/9 VOTED
Nostromo87 - 9/9 VOTED
TheUsualSuspect - 9/9 VOTED
the samoan lawyer - 9/9 VOTED
Pussy Galore - 7/8
CiCi - DISQUALIFIED

Rules of Participation  

pahaK 12-02-18 02:36 AM

https://i.imgur.com/Ysw73NY.jpg
Vargtimmen aka. Hour of the Wolf
(Ingmar Bergman, 1968)
Nominated by the samoan lawyer
90 min, IMDb
Write-ups for Hour of the Wolf  


https://i.imgur.com/syh14YO.jpg
Profondo Rosso aka. Deep Red
(Dario Argento, 1975)
Nominated by Siddon
127 min, IMDb


https://i.imgur.com/KVK5Zec.jpg
The Amityville Horror
(Stuart Rosenberg, 1979)
Nominated by Nostromo87
117 min, IMDb
Write-ups for The Amityville Horror  


https://i.imgur.com/ZrQPOZg.jpg
eXistenZ
(David Cronenberg)
Nominated by Pussy Galore
97 min, IMDb


https://i.imgur.com/hzs0RQl.jpg
Ginger Snaps
(John Fawcett)
Nominated by TheUsualSuspect
108 min, IMDb
Write-ups for Ginger Snaps  


https://i.imgur.com/kiWpbOB.jpg
Kairo aka. Pulse
(Kiyoshi Kurosawa, 2001)
Nominated by pahaK
119 min, IMDb


https://i.imgur.com/ylWqaFs.jpg
Macabre
(The Mo Brothers, 2009)
Nominated by cricket
95 min, IMDb


https://i.imgur.com/QX85YLi.jpg
The Autopsy of Jane Doe
(André Řvredal, 2016)
Nominated by Derek Vinyard
86 min, IMDb


DISQUALIFIED
The Descent  

pahaK 12-02-18 02:37 AM

Results

1st Place
https://i.imgur.com/EfyyCtB.jpg
Profondo Rosso aka. Deep Red
(Dario Argento, 1975)
Nominated by Siddon
127 min, IMDb
Score: 43 pts (1, 1, 2, 3, 3, 5, 6, 8)

--

2nd Place
https://i.imgur.com/MtgZfTr.jpg
Vargtimmen aka. Hour of the Wolf
(Ingmar Bergman, 1968)
Nominated by the samoan lawyer
90 min, IMDb
Score: 40 pts (1, 2, 2, 3, 4, 4, 8, 8)

--

3rd Place (tied)
https://i.imgur.com/4Y939Au.jpg
The Amityville Horror
(Stuart Rosenberg, 1979)
Nominated by Nostromo87
117 min, IMDb
Score: 38 pts (1, 2, 4, 5, 5, 5, 6, 6)

--

3rd Place (tied)
https://i.imgur.com/A9EMNUj.jpg
Ginger Snaps
(John Fawcett, 2000)
Nominated by TheUsualSuspect
108 min, IMDb
Score: 38 pts (1, 2, 3, 3, 4, 7, 7, 7)

--

5th Place
https://i.imgur.com/5zOVrS7.jpg
The Autopsy of Jane Doe
(André Řvredal, 2016)
Nominated by Derek Vinyard
86 min, IMDb
Score: 36 pts (2, 2, 3, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8)

--

6th Place (tied)
https://i.imgur.com/hbHhmzU.jpg
eXistenZ
(David Cronenberg, 1999)
Nominated by Pussy Galore
97 min, IMDb
Score: 33 pts (1, 1, 5, 5, 6, 7, 7, 7)

--

6th Place (tied)
https://i.imgur.com/BBqCXuS.jpg
Kairo aka. Pulse
(Kiyoshi Kurosawa, 2001)
Nominated by pahaK
119 min, IMDb
Score: 33 pts (1, 3, 4, 4, 6, 6, 7, 8)

--

8th Place
https://i.imgur.com/jCIyPA5.jpg
Macabre
(The Mo Brothers, 2009)
Nominated by cricket
95 min, IMDb
Score: 27 pts (2, 4, 4, 5, 6, 8, 8, 8)

Citizen Rules 12-02-18 02:38 AM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
Cool! Glad to see you do this.

pahaK 12-02-18 02:39 AM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
I was asked to run this so here it is :D If someone wants to make fancy graphics for this they're welcome. I can't do that myself so without help it'll just look like this.

CosmicRunaway 12-02-18 07:20 AM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
I think the large title text and animated gif look good as they are. :up:

cricket 12-02-18 08:04 AM

I'll send my nom after I get an idea of who's joining but I'm pretty sure of my pick.

Nathaniel 12-02-18 12:19 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
I'm in too. Will send a nomination in the next couple of days.

Citizen Rules 12-02-18 12:29 PM

Originally Posted by CosmicRunaway (Post 1971919)
I think the large title text and animated gif look good as they are. :up:
I'll second that...As soon as I seen the 1st post I thought it looked pretty cool. Good use of spacial harmonies, and very organized. I suspected you'd make a good HoF host:)

Derek Vinyard 12-02-18 04:59 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
I'm down honestly !

Will send my nom today of tomorrow

Nostromo87 12-02-18 11:02 PM

I'm certainly in.

Had an active last Day-plus watching my Georgia Bulldogs FACEPLANT against Alabama in the SEC Championship game (Football), followed by an overnight work shift.

Gladly await all your viewing choices. :up:

TheUsualSuspect 12-03-18 03:13 AM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
Count me in.

the samoan lawyer 12-03-18 09:36 AM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
Aye, go ahead then. Count me in. I'll get my nomination in asap.

Pussy Galore 12-03-18 04:04 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
I'm in, I'll send a nom soon!

pahaK 12-03-18 04:49 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
Six nominations received (including mine) and we have four decades presented. Only two films I haven't seen this far.

I just rewatched the film I was going to nominate and now I'm considering to change it (it was good but I'd like to nominate something great). Fortunately there's still time and as a host that's easy :)

cricket 12-03-18 05:06 PM

Originally Posted by pahaK (Post 1972229)
Six nominations received (including mine) and we have four decades presented. Only two films I haven't seen this far.

I just rewatched the film I was going to nominate and now I'm considering to change it (it was good but I'd like to nominate something great). Fortunately there's still time and as a host that's easy :)
Have you seen my nomination?

What were you going to nominate?

pahaK 12-03-18 05:12 PM

Originally Posted by cricket (Post 1972234)
Have you seen my nomination?

What were you going to nominate?
I've seen it but it was a long time ago. I'm not 100% sure if I change yet so I'm not answering the second question ;)

cricket 12-03-18 05:13 PM

Originally Posted by pahaK (Post 1972236)
I've seen it but it was a long time ago. I'm not 100% sure if I change yet so I'm not answering the second question ;)
You don't have it crossed off your list;)

pahaK 12-03-18 05:17 PM

Originally Posted by cricket (Post 1972237)
You don't have it crossed off your list;)
Yeah, it's been like 15 years since I saw it so it doesn't exactly qualify for that but I was planning to rewatch it anyway for my personal top-50 (or something) horror list preparations.

CiCi 12-03-18 10:01 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
Tossing between a few noms, but I'm definitely interested. I'll be home for Christmas for a while so I'll have the time to pound through them all!

TheUsualSuspect 12-04-18 10:06 AM

Looking at previous HoF's to not nominate a repeat film.

Siddon 12-04-18 11:12 AM

I think this Hall should be more about recommendations rather than winning, my nom is recent and fairly popular amongst horror fans but didn't even get a major release

pahaK 12-04-18 11:27 AM

Originally Posted by Siddon (Post 1972361)
I think this Hall should be more about recommendations rather than winning, my nom is recent and fairly popular amongst horror fans but didn't even get a major release
That's my idea as well. I'm definitely nominating a film that I consider a worthy candidate for that top-100 horror list but might not be popular enough to have been seen by the majority. Most certainly I don't want to nominate a major classic that everyone has already seen.

TheUsualSuspect 12-04-18 02:27 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
I'm torn between two movies....argh.

Screw it, flipped a coin.

pahaK 12-04-18 03:01 PM

Originally Posted by TheUsualSuspect (Post 1972398)
I'm torn between two movies....argh.

Screw it, flipped a coin.
Maybe try the other one ;)

cricket 12-04-18 03:24 PM

Originally Posted by Siddon (Post 1972361)
I think this Hall should be more about recommendations rather than winning, my nom is recent and fairly popular amongst horror fans but didn't even get a major release
I always try to do that but I find it most difficult to nominate something that you in particular haven't already seen.

Siddon 12-04-18 05:06 PM

Originally Posted by cricket (Post 1972406)
I always try to do that but I find it most difficult to nominate something that you in particular haven't already seen.

I wasn't really speaking for me, because the chances are everything in this Hall is going to be a rewatch for me. I don't mind rewatching horror films

TheUsualSuspect 12-04-18 05:26 PM

Originally Posted by pahaK (Post 1972404)
Maybe try the other one ;)
Agh, who nominated my choice? This happened with the documentary HoF as well. Now I got to go with my second choice? :p

pahaK 12-04-18 05:45 PM

Originally Posted by TheUsualSuspect (Post 1972427)
Agh, who nominated my choice? This happened with the documentary HoF as well. Now I got to go with my second choice? :p
This far two films have been nominated by two people so you're not the only one who had to pick another :)

Siddon 12-05-18 09:17 AM

Originally Posted by pahaK (Post 1972432)
This far two films have been nominated by two people so you're not the only one who had to pick another :)

Was it an Argento film?

pahaK 12-05-18 10:42 AM

Originally Posted by Siddon (Post 1972512)
Was it an Argento film?
No. Neither of the "double nominations" are Italian.

MovieGal 12-05-18 01:55 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
I love horror but not sure about joining. Giallo films are more like thrillers to me and some horror is just plain stoopid like Jeepers Creepers...

Siddon 12-05-18 02:13 PM

Originally Posted by MovieGal (Post 1972570)
I love horror but not sure about joining. Giallo films are more like thrillers to me and some horror is just plain stoopid like Jeepers Creepers...

Apparently nobody picked a Giallo film so I decided to switch up my nom from a found footage that came out this decade to a Giallo one.

CiCi 12-05-18 02:14 PM

Originally Posted by MovieGal (Post 1972570)
I love horror but not sure about joining. Giallo films are more like thrillers to me and some horror is just plain stoopid like Jeepers Creepers...
My nom isn't a giallo either, as much as I was tempted :p

pahaK 12-05-18 02:16 PM

Originally Posted by Siddon (Post 1972579)
Apparently nobody picked a Giallo film so I decided to switch up my nom from a found footage that came out this decade to a Giallo one.
I'm going to watch your original nomination too as it was one of the two I hadn't seen before. Now there's only one.

cricket 12-05-18 02:42 PM

I don't seem to like Giallo very much but I still keep watching them.

pahaK 12-05-18 04:18 PM

Originally Posted by cricket (Post 1972586)
I don't seem to like Giallo very much but I still keep watching them.
They're not my absolute favorites but I've found quite a few of them enjoyable.

cricket 12-05-18 07:40 PM

Originally Posted by pahaK (Post 1972629)
They're not my absolute favorites but I've found quite a few of them enjoyable.
I've enjoyed a few too like Bay of Blood. I didn't like Deep Red or Suspiria which was nominated for a previous horror HoF.

MovieGal 12-05-18 08:52 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
My nominations never win anyway... either to obscure or some just find not that interesting.

pahaK 12-05-18 10:08 PM

Originally Posted by cricket (Post 1972666)
I've enjoyed a few too like Bay of Blood. I didn't like Deep Red or Suspiria which was nominated for a previous horror HoF.
Funnily enough Bay of Blood isn't (as far as I know) usually considered a giallo but slasher. Also I enjoyed the other two but didn't like Bay of Blood :D

cricket 12-06-18 08:07 AM

Originally Posted by pahaK (Post 1972712)
Funnily enough Bay of Blood isn't (as far as I know) usually considered a giallo but slasher
You're probably right and that's probably why I liked it.

the samoan lawyer 12-06-18 09:29 AM

Originally Posted by MovieGal (Post 1972672)
My nominations never win anyway... either to obscure or some just find not that interesting.

I doubt most people who enter are doing it just to win and also, I doubt you'll get many people finding your horror nomination too obscure. Just get a nomination in.

pahaK 12-06-18 11:34 AM

Originally Posted by MovieGal (Post 1972672)
My nominations never win anyway... either to obscure or some just find not that interesting.
Well, my noms have been last half the time and always in bottom three so at least the host isn't setting the bar too high when it comes to winning :D

MovieGal 12-06-18 01:52 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
Maybe I will do a classic

cricket 12-06-18 04:19 PM

I changed my nomination. I originally picked this-

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-b4EtgVq8WC...ibaba-1966.jpg

I went with something I think suits this HoF and it's participants better.

CosmicRunaway 12-06-18 05:24 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
I've been meaning to watch Onibaba for years now but haven't gotten around to it. I'll make sure it's on my watch list for the Horror Countdown though.

cricket 12-06-18 05:28 PM

Originally Posted by CosmicRunaway (Post 1972858)
I've been meaning to watch Onibaba for years now but haven't gotten around to it. I'll make sure it's on my watch list for the Horror Countdown though.
There's a great link for it, Internet archive I believe.

TheUsualSuspect 12-06-18 05:51 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
@Nathaniel got a nom yet?

MovieGal 12-06-18 06:49 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
I hope ppl find mine as a fun watch. Both my first and second choice are ones I remember my parents watching and only hearing about them until I got to watch them.

cricket 12-06-18 06:50 PM

Originally Posted by MovieGal (Post 1972876)
I hope ppl find mine as a fun watch. Both my first and second choice are ones I remember my parents watching and only hearing about them until I got to watch them.
I'm sure it'll be good

MovieGal 12-06-18 07:05 PM

Originally Posted by cricket (Post 1972877)
I'm sure it'll be good
lol maybe I should go with my second choice.. :P

Nathaniel 12-06-18 07:08 PM

I'm going to have to drop out before this starts unfortunately. Just not confident I'll be able to commit to it right now. I'll be following along though.

My nom would have been a Giallo.

the samoan lawyer 12-07-18 08:55 AM

Originally Posted by CosmicRunaway (Post 1972858)
I've been meaning to watch Onibaba for years now but haven't gotten around to it. I'll make sure it's on my watch list for the Horror Countdown though.

I predict a top 15 finish for Onibaba. Higher if more were to see it.

TheUsualSuspect 12-07-18 09:00 AM

Originally Posted by the samoan lawyer (Post 1972942)
I predict a top 15 finish for Onibaba. Higher if more were to see it.
I'll try to remember to watch this one for the countdown.

the samoan lawyer 12-07-18 09:02 AM

Originally Posted by TheUsualSuspect (Post 1972944)
I'll try to remember to watch this one for the countdown.

Make sure you do TUS.

MovieGal 12-07-18 09:49 AM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
I won't be participating in the countdown...I can't just go through all the horror I have seen and pick a top 25. Hell my top 5 English speaking films are actually 6 films because 2 films hold my #1.

pahaK 12-07-18 09:53 AM

Originally Posted by the samoan lawyer (Post 1972942)
I predict a top 15 finish for Onibaba. Higher if more were to see it.
I was actually predicting it to win this before cricket decided to switch his nomination :D

pahaK 12-07-18 09:57 AM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
Also after latest nomination juggles there's now three films I haven't seen.

the samoan lawyer 12-07-18 09:59 AM

Originally Posted by pahaK (Post 1972950)
I was actually predicting it to win this before cricket decided to switch his nomination :D

What a swine

cricket 12-07-18 04:58 PM

Originally Posted by MovieGal (Post 1972949)
I won't be participating in the countdown...I can't just go through all the horror I have seen and pick a top 25. Hell my top 5 English speaking films are actually 6 films because 2 films hold my #1.
You're one of the biggest horror fans on the site. It would be a sin if you didn't.

Citizen Rules 12-07-18 05:35 PM

Originally Posted by MovieGal (Post 1972949)
I won't be participating in the countdown...I can't just go through all the horror I have seen and pick a top 25. Hell my top 5 English speaking films are actually 6 films because 2 films hold my #1.
I'm not joining but if you can't pick a horror movie, can I suggest a horror for you to nominate?

cricket 12-07-18 06:02 PM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1973098)
I'm not joining but if you can't pick a horror movie, can I suggest a horror for you to nominate?
She's talking about the countdown.

Citizen Rules 12-07-18 06:04 PM

Originally Posted by cricket (Post 1973113)
She's talking about the countdown.
Oh rats! I'm so clueless:p...But yeah MG should send in a list to the countdown, even I sent one.

MovieGal 12-07-18 07:30 PM

Originally Posted by cricket (Post 1973087)
You're one of the biggest horror fans on the site. It would be a sin if you didn't.
Maybe a big horror fan but again.. I cant think of every horror I have seen and figure out which is better than the other.. Im sure I would forget some that are great!

MovieGal 12-07-18 07:31 PM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1973098)
I'm not joining but if you can't pick a horror movie, can I suggest a horror for you to nominate?
Yeah I picked one already ... and I'm sure you wouldn't watch it.. but that's ok!

cricket 12-07-18 07:35 PM

Originally Posted by MovieGal (Post 1973132)
Maybe a big horror fan but again.. I cant think of every horror I have seen and figure out which is better than the other.. Im sure I would forget some that are great!
Do your best:)

honeykid 12-08-18 09:01 AM

Originally Posted by MovieGal (Post 1973132)
Im sure I would forget some that are great!
Yeah, probably. But we all do that. How many posts have you seen in a countdown where someone posts "Oh God, I completely forgot about that!" You won't be perfect, none of us are. It's ok though. :)

pahaK 12-09-18 03:32 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
Less than a day to send nominations (like 15 - 16 hours or until I wake up tomorrow, whichever comes later). At the moment we only have 9 participants so if anyone is still considering there's plenty of room :D

the samoan lawyer 12-10-18 09:07 AM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
When's the grand reveal?

pahaK 12-10-18 09:49 AM

Originally Posted by the samoan lawyer (Post 1973518)
When's the grand reveal?
I don't know. Do people prefer a fixed time (preferably a bit later so that more people are online) or should I just make the reveal right now and let everyone comment when they come around?

the samoan lawyer 12-10-18 10:13 AM

Originally Posted by pahaK (Post 1973525)
I don't know. Do people prefer a fixed time (preferably a bit later so that more people are online) or should I just make the reveal right now and let everyone comment when they come around?

I was just being impatient as I cant wait to see what everyone has picked. :D
Being selfish, I would say make the reveal now but no sweat if you would rather make an arranged time.

pahaK 12-10-18 10:16 AM

Originally Posted by the samoan lawyer (Post 1973528)
I was just being impatient as I cant wait to see what everyone has picked. :D
Being selfish, I would say make the reveal now but no sweat if you would rather make an arranged time.
Personally I've never got what's so grand about the reveals :D Just wondering what people in general want. I'd rather just post them up now, actually. Maybe I just do it now. Then it's done and no need to sweat about timezones and punctuality.

pahaK 12-10-18 10:19 AM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
The not-so-grand reveal has been done. Nominations are in the second post.

pahaK 12-10-18 10:32 AM

And my personal initial comments about the nominations.

I have already reviewed in very recent history three of the films. The Amityville Horror I don't like and it was just barely above bad. Ginger Snaps is excellent and is potential top-10 horror film for me. My own nomination Pulse is also excellent and very likely top-10 horror as well. I'll use my previous reviews for these.

It's been about six months since I saw Deep Red and I was planning to just use my old review but after rewatching The Descent yesterday I realized I need to see that one again to be able to put them in order. Both are good films. Other films needing a rewatch are eXistenZ (last watch was about a year ago and I consider it one of the weaker Cronenbergs) and The Autopsy of Jane Doe (saw it when it was new and remember it hovering somewhere between OK and good).

I haven't seen Hour of the Wolf but I've been planning to see more Bergman so it'll be a good start on that. Macabre is completely unknown film to me so there's at least one surprise for me.

Nostromo87 12-10-18 10:37 AM

Originally Posted by pahaK (Post 1971897)
https://i.imgur.com/ylWqaFs.jpg
Macabre
(The Mo Brothers, 2009)
Nominated by cricket
95 min, IMDb
-

Originally Posted by Sexy Celebrity (Post 1355395)

Siddon 12-10-18 10:43 AM

Happy to rewatch Hour of the Wolf, and Existenz two films I didn't care for when I saw them but I knew they were worth a revisit. I saw Pulse for one of the Halloween countdowns I think I needed three tries because it kept putting me to sleep

Autopsy of Jane Doe and Ginger Snaps are both pretty good, happy to watch them again.

I own Amityville Horror, Descent, and Deep Red so those reviews will come quickly at some point.

Macabre is one new one for me but it's a cricket nom which means I'm either going to love it or hate it.

the samoan lawyer 12-10-18 10:58 AM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
Interesting mix! Never seen eXistenZ although I own the dvd but never occurred to me that it was a horror. Most looking forward to is a first watch of Macabre.
Apart from Pulse as well, I've seen the rest but don't mind watching any again.

TheUsualSuspect 12-10-18 11:02 AM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
I wouldn't of considered eXistenZ horror, but the IMDB tag strikes again.


My initial nomination was The Autopsy of Jane Doe....I guess Canadians really like that movie.

I've seen The Amityville Horror and The Descent. I'm a big fan of the latter and thought the former was decent enough. Look forward to seeing the others.

I've seen the American remake of Pulse, hope the original is better.

cricket 12-10-18 11:04 AM

I liked Hour of the Wolf a lot when I watched it about 3 years ago.

I did not like Deep Red when I saw it a couple years ago.

It's been an eternity since I saw The Amityville Horror and I was planning on watching it again for the countdown anyway.

I saw eXistenZ but it didn't make an impression on me since I hardly remember it.

Saw Ginger Snaps once and thought it was terrific. I think I'll get the DVD so my wife can watch it.

I have not seen Pulse.

Saw The Descent a couple of times and it is excellent.

I have not seen The Autopsey of Jane Doe yet but was planning on it.

My nom, Macabre, is sort of on the same page as French new wave horror like Inside or Frontiers.

TheUsualSuspect 12-10-18 11:06 AM

Originally Posted by cricket (Post 1973545)

My nom, Macabre, is sort of on the same page as French new wave horror like Inside or Frontiers.
Just in time for the Holiday Season. :p

Citizen Rules 12-10-18 12:19 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
I've not seen a single one of the noms:p

Siddon 12-10-18 12:32 PM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1973572)
I've not seen a single one of the noms:p

So...make a nomination and join

pahaK 12-10-18 12:37 PM

Originally Posted by TheUsualSuspect (Post 1973542)
I've seen the American remake of Pulse, hope the original is better.
At least in my opinion it definitely is.

Citizen Rules 12-10-18 01:02 PM

Originally Posted by Siddon (Post 1973576)
So...make a nomination and join
Thanks...but I'll have to pass, most horror films are way too violent/graphic for me.

If I had joined I would have nominated Day of Wrath (1943) It's a Danish film that was nominated by Thursday Next in the 40s HoF Part 2. Very impressive film. Has anyone seen that?

cricket 12-10-18 01:19 PM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1973591)
Thanks...but I'll have to pass, most horror films are way too violent/graphic for me.

If I had joined I would have nominated Day of Wrath (1943) It's a Danish film that was nominated by Thursday Next in the 40s HoF Part 2. Very impressive film. Has anyone seen that?
I think the people in this HoF who haven't seen it wouldn't like it. It's not horror on IMDb anyway.

CiCi 12-10-18 01:37 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
When I messaged Paha saying I was tossing between three films, the other two were Ginger Snaps and Deep Red :lol: I'm a huge fan of both. Katharine Isabelle is a painfully underrated/underseen actress although that's somewhat through choice from what I understand about her. I like the connection between adolescence and body horror, it's not too heavy handed and is done really well. One of the very few horror films that pulls off humour decently too!

Deep Red is probably my favourite giallo film and the plot is engaging and well thought out without being too implausible. The music is astounding as always, Daria Nicolodi is completely charming. The death sequences are operatic without being too over the top (on the whole) and explores some really interesting themes like feminism and sexuality that were pretty ahead of its time for the mid 70s. Stunning.
I'll rewatch both though since it's felt like a long time since I reviewed them on here!

I haven't seen any of the other noms but I've heard about most of them, so yeah, feeling very excited on the whole :love:

Citizen Rules 12-10-18 01:43 PM

Originally Posted by cricket (Post 1973608)
I think the people in this HoF who haven't seen it wouldn't like it. It's not horror on IMDb anyway.
You're right it's not tagged horror, I hadn't noticed that. Would you personally consider it a horror film?

cricket 12-10-18 02:04 PM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1973618)
You're right it's not tagged horror, I hadn't noticed that. Would you personally consider it a horror film?
No but I seem to be on the picky side.

CosmicRunaway 12-10-18 02:33 PM

I was considering joining this HoF, but I honestly couldn't come up with a film to nominate. I wanted to go with something that was almost certainly going to make my ballot for the Horror Countdown, but wasn't on any of the current Lists. I didn't ultimately decide on anything.

All of the nominations that I've seen (The Amityville Horror, eXistenZ, Ginger Snaps, Pulse, and The Descent) I like well enough, though the last two are the only ones currently on my rewatch list for the Countdown. Some of Cronenberg's other films are in that pile, but not eXistenZ.

Captain Spaulding 12-10-18 04:34 PM

If nominations were revealed up front, instead of keeping them hush-hush for some reason, I'd be more likely to join these HOFs. I mainly worry about the availability of the films, since I try to avoid having to seek out films online, but I doubt I would've had a problem finding any of these nominations (except maybe Macabre). And it's a strong group of nominations too!

I was already planning to watch Pulse (2001) since I recently watched and loved the director's Cure. Was also planning to watch Deep Red for the countdown since I hear a lot of people cite it as one of Argento's best, alongside Suspiria, which I love.

The Descent is one of the best horror films of the 2000's. I don't think any film has ever made me feel so claustrophobic. The Autopsy of Jane Doe is pretty solid. I remember the build-up being very creepy, but the film faltered a bit down the stretch as it became perhaps a bit too ridiculous. Not sure how it would hold up on a re-watch since much of my initial enjoyment came from the intrigue of wondering what's up with this corpse. Now that the mystery has been solved, I'm skeptical that I'd be as into it.

eXistenZ was on my science-fiction ballot. I guess Cronenberg's trademark body horror is enough to warrant the horror tag on IMDb, but I think calling it a horror film is a stretch. Very good movie, though. Great ending. I've always enjoyed The Amityville Horror (possibly my favorite haunted-house movie), but it's been a long time since I last watched it. The whole lycanthropy-as-puberty metaphor in Ginger Snaps is a bit too blunt, but it's still one of the better werewolf movies I've seen. I think I prefer the sequel, though. For all the praise that Katharine Isabelle receives, I personally found Emily Perkins the more impressive of the two.

Haven't seen Macabre, but seeing that deranged bitch on the cover wield a chainsaw is enough to whet my appetite, and I love the French New Extremity films that cricket compared it to. Haven't seen Hour of the Wolf, either, but Bergman rarely fails to impress.

pahaK 12-10-18 05:39 PM

Originally Posted by Captain Spaulding (Post 1973683)
If nominations were revealed up front, instead of keeping them hush-hush for some reason, I'd be more likely to join these HOFs. I mainly worry about the availability of the films, since I try to avoid having to seek out films online, but I doubt I would've had a problem finding any of these nominations (except maybe Macabre). And it's a strong group of nominations too!
I kinda agree. I don't personally get much excitement from the "grand" reveals and I can totally see your point. I try to pick films that are quite easily available for that exact reason (in the end I was choosing between Pulse and In a Glass Cage but couldn't find the latter anywhere online). If I run another HoF in the future I'll probably go with open nominations.

cricket 12-10-18 05:44 PM

There's been a couple of specialty Hall of Fames in which I didn't rate the movies in the thread, and I'm not going to do it in this one either. I saw my nomination recently so I'm not going to watch it again.

Macabre

As I mentioned before, this movie reminds me of French new wave horror, except it's out of Indonesia. The story is really just an afterthought but suitable enough. The quality of the movie is very good and there's an excellent lead villain. The first half hour is the set up for the craziness of the last hour. It ends up being a pretty violent movie; some may call it extreme. I've never seen anyone else on the forum mention it before and that's one of the reasons I nominated it. If it's the kind of horror movie that you like, then you will like it. It's a hidden gem.

CosmicRunaway 12-10-18 06:08 PM

Originally Posted by Captain Spaulding (Post 1973683)
The whole lycanthropy-as-puberty metaphor in Ginger Snaps is a bit too blunt, but it's still one of the better werewolf movies I've seen. I think I prefer the sequel, though.
I'm not sure if I've seen the sequel or not. I do remember that a few friends of mine who loved the first Ginger Snaps did not like the second one though. Now I'm kind of curious.

Derek Vinyard 12-10-18 08:25 PM

Originally Posted by TheUsualSuspect (Post 1973542)
My initial nomination was The Autopsy of Jane Doe....I guess Canadians really like that movie.
Hell yeah! I love that movie

Swan 12-10-18 08:38 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
Macabre, Hour of the Wolf and Autopsy of Jane Doe are on my watchlist. Good noms.

pahaK 12-10-18 09:23 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
I'll spam the ones I won't be rewatching (again).

Originally Posted by pahaK (Post 1945108)
The Amityville Horror (1979) r

One more classic horror rewatched. I didn't remember much of this except that I didn't like it as a kid.



A blended family moves to a house that's been vacant since the oldest son of the previous occupants killed rest of his family about a year ago. Things don't go so well for the new owners either and especially the husband isn't feeling like himself but at least the young daughter finds herself an imaginary friend.

The Amityville Horror isn't anywhere near the quality of films like The Exorcist or The Omen. The showing of the house in the beginning immediately suggests that the direction is clumsy (the whole idea of mixing the past murders with the showing is stupid because we already had the intro about them). Fortunately it's pretty much the worst scene in the film but still the implication is more or less proven correct and the film constantly hovers somewhere between mediocre and bad.

For some reason the demonic presence in the house is behaving like a mischievous kid. For example why did it trap the nanny to closet or steal the money from wife's brother? Also why does it only wreak havoc in the house when it clearly can affect people around the city? I'd like some logic even in horror films especially when the suspense part is already lacking and there isn't much of a story either.

The house itself is pretty decent setting but it's not used very well. Acting is pretty so-so - it's fine in general but almost everyone showcases terrible overacting at least once (the priest probably being the worst example of this). I think it's worth a mention that Margot Kidder as the wife is pretty damn hot and thanks to her I won't give this a bad rating.


pahaK 12-10-18 09:27 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
I'll start a new review thread next year and will switch to full popcorn rating only so this is essentially 5/5 for this (will use the new as I'm not 100% sure I'll watch all of the this year).

Originally Posted by pahaK (Post 1970684)
Pulse (2001) R

A suicide, weird internet page and people missing or grown distant lead young Tokyo residents toward a mystery that has major consequences.


Pulse is pretty unique J-horror that is in some ways closer to the likes of Cronenberg and Carpenter than contemporary Japanese films. It's a strange hybrid of Prince of Darkness, Shivers (or Rabid) and typical J-horror ghost movie like Ringu. The result is a great movie that manages to blend all of its elements into highly emotional apocalyptic vision.

While Pulse is mostly considered a horror film it isn't very scary. It is very sad and depressing film though. Its main theme is loneliness and its depiction of it is devoid of hope; in life everyone is ultimately alone and death is no salvation but an eternity of cold and hopeless solitude. I often like sad films and Pulse surely delivers.

Technically the film is good: it's not visually flashy but its static or slowly moving camera fits the film's slow pace well, CGI is clearly dated but it still kinda works and soundtrack is really nice. Acting is OK too. Plot doesn't always make that much sense but like in Fulci's films it's more about the atmosphere anyway.

One of the best J-horrors (maybe even the best). It's not as scary as some others but it has almost unsurpassable feeling of loss and hopelessness.


pahaK 12-10-18 09:32 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
For the same reason as above this is essentially 5/5 for this.

Originally Posted by pahaK (Post 1913649)
Ginger Snaps (2000) r

A much needed rewatch for my potential top horror list. Another attempt to link puberty and its changes on (female) body with more profound transformation into a monster.

https://i.imgur.com/UejsCz0.jpg

Ginger and Brigitte are high school juniors (Brigitte is one year younger but she's skipped a class at some point). They're also (so-called) freaks and misanthropists of sort who mostly just hang together and have an obsession for morbid (they take pictures of their faked deaths and have a pact of dying together).

While out one night Ginger gets bitten by a werewolf that's been killing local dogs like no tomorrow. So in addition to having her first period (at 16) she also starts to grow some extra body hair, pointed teeth and a tail to boot. While Ginger succumbs deeper into bestiality Brigitte tries to find her a cure with some assistance by a young local drug dealer. Story ends with quite a bit of blood and sadness.

The basic story is nothing special but it works mostly because of very well written characters and kinda clever ways to transfer the old werewolf tropes into modern time. Katharine Isabelle and Emily Perkins are perfect in their portrayal of the sisters. It reminds me a little of Let the Right One In as both of them are primarily concerned of the characters while all the horror elements are secondary and only there to support the character based story.

Cinematography is fine but nothing really special. The monster effects haven't aged too well and I personally don't like how the werewolf looks (though I suppose Ginger's transformation is not finished). I'm also not exactly sure if I like the comedic elements (especially sisters' parents are really goofy).

A good character driven horror film and a good candidate for the best puberty mystification horror ever made.


pahaK 12-10-18 09:32 PM

Re: Horror Hall of Fame II
 
And finally a first real rewatch for the HoF.

Originally Posted by pahaK (Post 1973754)
The Descent (2005) R

One year after losing her husband and daughter in an accident Sarah goes to caving expedition with her friends. It's supposed to be an easy thing in a beginner friendly and safe cave but the woman responsible for the arrangements has little more ambitous goals in mind. It's not "Boredom" caves but previously uncharted one... and they're not alone.


Neil Marshall started his career with a bang. His debut, Dog Soldiers, is a good modern werewolf movie and the follow-up to that, The Descent, is one of the best claustrophobic horrors. It would be so easy to go wrong with the concept of six women lost in a pitch black cave but Marshall manages to weave legit story and enough characterization into the mix making The Descent a proper movie instead of boring display of dark and darker scenes.

I like the acting by pretty much everyone. The shift from awkward and fake reunion to battle for survival works. The crawlers look creepy and proper underground dwellers (as usual their abilities change from scene to scene and in general they have amazingly bad hearing for creatures that use sound to know their environment). Violence is rather bloody and it has certain 80s feel to it. The film also looks great and keeps the shots just above too dark.

The Descent is not a perfect horror film but it's damn good. It's a shame that Neil Marshall hasn't made more horror after it (though that's about to change in next year).


Citizen Rules 12-10-18 11:45 PM

Originally Posted by Captain Spaulding (Post 1973683)
If nominations were revealed up front, instead of keeping them hush-hush for some reason, I'd be more likely to join these HOFs...
I agree with that. In fact I've been the only host to list the movie noms as they come in. I did that in the Film Noir Part 1 and 2 Hofs. I think it encouraged more people to join and got people to nominate better stuff too. There's no real reason why the noms are kept private for a big reveal, other than just that's the way it was done in the past.


All times are GMT -3. The time now is 05:44 AM.

Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright, ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright © Movie Forums