Saint Maud (2019) vs. The Witch (2015)

VS.

This is a difficult one. It’s like Sophie’s Choice!

I guess..The Witch…but mostly because of Anna.

Two brilliant debut films. I'd go The VVitch, but only just.

Likewise. The VVitch also just connected with me somehow on an emotional level. That ending.

The Witch in a walk.

__________________
Iro's Top 100 Movies v3.0

I think they are both overrated, but for me Saint Maud is the better film.

Eggers' research into his films is mightily impressive, from the olde English of the time used to the witchcraft scene at the end (which resembles Francisco Goya painting). He's a proper film-maker

Clearly, The Witch.


Saint Maude is good, but let's be real.

I haven't watched (or had even heard of) Saint Maude, but now will watch it.


I absolutely love The VVitch.

Of course weird shit will always connect with us Twin Peaks fans.

Yes, well, who could argue with that. God, I miss Twin Peaks. Owe it a rewatch but it’d have to be a controlled binging environment, no distractions etc.

Saint Maude has a great ending to a rather slow film.


The Witch wins for me.

This should have more votes.