Here's some quick predix on the 4 major categories.
Best Picture
1. Roma
2. Green Book
3. A Star is Born
4. BlackKKlansman
5. The Favourite
6. Black Panther
7. If Beale Street Could Talk
8. Vice
9. Bohemian Rhapsody
Okay, this is the biggie.
This season got so wild, so quickly. There are several contenders for the win at this point, and none of them really feel right. I think there’s a very good chance whoever wins this, much like last year, won’t be nominated for, or even win the SAG ensemble. That stat is destroyed.
Unless the guilds pull a surprise: Actor, Actress, and Director are all off the table for ‘A Star is Born’. Bradley Cooper’s Musical Drama has pretty much been dethroned, leaving an open spot for another film to come in. The Globes have shown there’s absolutely no path for it to win.
On the surface, it may seem like Green Book is the winner here. It's already being touted to take Supporting Actor, and Original Screenplay (I suppose both hinge on whether they win their respective guilds; SGA and WGA). That’s been an incredibly common path to winning. However, Peter Farrelly has recently being outed for having a history of exposing himself to people as a joke (namely Cameron Diaz), etc. The Academy is certainly not going reward a producer who’s had such a questionable past of piggish behavior in this era of #MeToo (also, writer Nick Vallelonga’s tweets about Muslims). I think that it’s safely out of contention for the win now. Not to mention that the screenplay winners usually battle it out for the top award, unless the directing winner takes it.
Which also got me thinking how conveniently Roma's win would mirror The Shape of Water's. It's a very different situation in many ways, but the similarities are tough to ignore. Golden Lion winner from a Mexican director, that misses SAG Ensemble, and is expected to win Director, but not any acting or screenplay Oscars. The former was the first movie since Braveheart to pull off the win without SAG ensemble, and anything else above-the-line except Director. So, could it really happen two years in a row? We recently had the back-to-back years of PGA/DGA winners failing to win Picture (2016, 2017), so it's not like these weird occurrences don't repeat. With every day that goes by, I have a harder time seeing Roma lose BP at this point, even when Green Book wins PGA.
Also: Reverse Driving Ms. Daisy… I mean... come on. It's been 30 years. And they're going to reward Reverse Driving Ms. Daisy/Driving Ms. Daisy 2.0, after Spike Lee gets nominated for director the first time ever, as his film is also nominated for Best Picture? Nearly 30 years after ‘Do The Right Thing’ was snubbed across the board in favor of ? Come on, man!
Director
1. Alfonso Cuarón, Roma
2. Bradley Cooper, A Star Is Born
3. Spike Lee, BlacKkKlansman
4. Adam McKay, Vice
5. Yorgos Lanthimos, The Favourite
Alfonso Cuarón has this in the bag. There’s a tiny, very tiny chance Cooper could come in at the last minute to win DGA, and go on from there. But I highly doubt that. It's Cuarón’s to lose.
The question is, who is coming in at N.4 and N.5? Especially N. 5 - that seems like anyone’s ballgame. And as I was typing this, the recent news just broke out. Peter Farrelly seems done.
So, firstly, Pawlikowski has surprisingly garnered a recent surge after his BAFTA nom. His film hasn’t garnered the attention that others here have, but he’s currently being touted as a surprise passion pick; it would make sense. However, that might just end up being wishful thinking from others.
Yorgos Lanthimos seemed like a sure-fire contender before the season even started. It seemed like that was the case until he missed the Globe and the DGA. Now he’s stuck only with a BAFTA nom; the same organization that gave his film the most nominations. But, again, this could also be just wishful thinking from others.
So, who’s left? Well, Adam McKay’s film ‘Vice’, despite not performing at the level everyone expected it to - critically or commercially - still managed to either campaign hard enough before the reception came in, or just survived enough-in general to hit every box (Globe, SAG, DGA, WGA, PGA, and BAFTA). Not to mention that the fall of Farelly leaves an even bigger spot for him to enter. So I think it's pretty safe to assume he’s in.
That just leaves leftover contenders that could make a resurgence and show up as PTA-style passion pick: Jenkins, Chazelle, Coogler, and McQueen. Let’s not forget: this is the directors' branch. They eat “locked” contenders for breakfast. But If you had to put a gun to my head: my money would probably be on Yorgos Lanthimos. DGA won’t be matching up 5/5, and at least one BAFTA nominee has to be left out on the cutting room floor. u
Lead Actor
1. Rami Malek, Bohemian Rhapsody
2. Bradley Cooper, A Star is Born
3. Christian Bale, Vice
4. Viggo Mortensen, Green Book
5. John David Washington, BlacKkKlansman
Unfortunately, Malek will probably take this rather easily. Cooper obviously made a big mistake prioritizing his Director FYC campaign, over his Lead Actor one. And now, if he plans to win, he’s going to have to pivot to this quick since Cuarón is clearly gonna sweep. I only hope he prays to god that Twitter users and Journalists will burn Bohemian Rhapsody to the ground ("straight washing", the fact that a pedo originally directed it, how people just don't like the film in general, etc.)
It's clear Cooper does not have a DiCaprio type rep with the HFPA (lost for Silver Linings, snubbed for Sniper). Though, I think there's a chance he can still recover from this, and who knows how the industry is going to react to his film and his performance. Don't get me wrong, I'm still confident in Raimi taking this, if you had me predict right now. But, looking at the overall picture, it seems very 50/50. Have to see SAG just to be 100% sure, I suppose. And this isn't just about Rami Malek, it's about the huge amount of love for Freddie Mercury. Given the choice between Freddie Mercury, Dick Cheney, and a fictional down-on-his-luck rockstar: Hollywood's going with Mercury.
As for the rest, I'd say it's a very sure thing that Bale and Viggo will get nominated, but John David Washington seems like a coin toss. Anyone else could surprise and show up in that slot come nomination day. Critics have been pushing hard for Ethan Hawke (already has LA, NY, Gotham; the trifecta). Though, Washington does already have SAG and Globe noms to his name. Plus, his film already has great support from the guilds; particularly the acting branch. I think It's safe say he’s pretty secure.
Best Actress
1. Glenn Close, The Wife
2. Olivia Colman, The Favourite
3. Lady Gaga, A Star Is Born
4. Melissa McCarthy, Can You Ever Forgive Me?
5. A toss up between Emily Blunt and Yalitza Aparicio
It seems as if Glenn Close is finally winning, folks.
Gaga losing the Globe is a BIG deal, and 'A Star is Born' feels like it’s underperforming a bit (critics’ groups kinda gave a preview, and then the HFPA chimed in). Also, Lady Gaga, pop star; she’s not a film star (not yet, at least), and it’s her first film role. Feels like a “nomination is the reward” type of situation - I mean, would she really beat soon-to-be-7x Oscar nominee Glenn Close? As for anyone else winning: Colman has the best reviews of any of the nominees in this category, along with the showiest role, while stilling have a decent shot at winning the SAG, etc. It might be too early to say Close has this locked, or anything like that. But if Close doesn’t win, I think it’s gonna have to be Colman. Gaga is nearly finished.
Last edited by Cynema De Bergerac; 01-29-19 at 01:59 AM.