That's a BS statement. What about Nemo's mother? How about Ellie in Up? Kids today are still exposed to death and loss in animated films. In fact, having orphaned protagonists is still a very common shortcut to gaining audience sympathy in animated films.
On the other hand, what you're proposing is that we have the kids witness a bunch of deaths all at once. You're also proposing that the adults in the audience watch as characters that they've loved for 15 years perish in a fire. You might have liked to see that, but there's no way that would've gone over well with most audiences.
On the other hand, what you're proposing is that we have the kids witness a bunch of deaths all at once. You're also proposing that the adults in the audience watch as characters that they've loved for 15 years perish in a fire. You might have liked to see that, but there's no way that would've gone over well with most audiences.
The way the things were going, a ending like the one Arcanis was proposing seems great to me! Specially if the alternative is a predictable last second save from the one character that was not about to die at the time! But I agree with you, it would not go well with most audiences...