This was really good, not as good as the original but definitely not far off glad i gave it a chance, I never watch horror (or any really) remakes but JJ told me this was pretty solid and i have to agree. The original was better for several reasons so i won't bother comparing them, other than one place: casting, who the hell thought of Elijah Wood haha? He was great, the exact opposite of the big fat, sweaty, Joe Spinelli; i think the girl he meets at the starts line about thinking that he would look like that was probably a reference to it. The first murder scene is so messed up, partly because i adore the song that's played during it. The sclaping part no matter how obviously fake is still just nasty; it probably is much worse because of the following bathroom and redlucy86 scenes. Damn, even though it's mostly a voiceover i think Elijah did a great job here: weirdo haha. Anyway that's pretty much it, i thought Elijah pulled off a really weird, weirdo, really well. The music was fantastic although seriously unnerving since i had to come to terms with the fact that i usually listen to these songs in this serial killer film on my own sometimes like a serial killer.
Other than the point of view aspect and a few simple story points that you'd expect in all serial killer films, it felt like it's own film, Elijahs character didn't have much similarities to his 80s counterpart at all. If we are comparing it to the 80s one, then i think it falls short on, atmosphere, tension, weird(o)ness and most of all 'sweaty' Joe Spinellis amazing performance. All of this was pretty solid in the remake IMO, though, and it had better music.
I also want to add that i said Tobey Maguire instead of Elijah Wood at first