The Pale Blue Eye - There are a number of things to like about this movie despite it coming and going without much fanfare. Christian Bale inhabits his role as is usually the case. But it's Harry Melling that surprises you. Outside of his numerous appearances in the
Harry Potter films I've only ever seen him in this and in a much smaller role in
The Ballad of Buster Scruggs. But in both those instances he turned in quietly memorable performances. And any actor who can hold his own alongside Bale is someone to be reckoned with. I only hope he gets more chances at juicy roles like this one.
Bale plays Detective Augustus Landor who has been summoned by the commanding officer at West Point Academy to investigate the hanging death of a young cadet. Suicides don't usually necessitate far-reaching investigations but someone has crept in and removed the corpses heart. During his initial inquiries Landor happens across another young underclassman who makes quite an impression by presenting his own unique but fanciful take on the crime. The cadet turns out to be a young Edgar Allan Poe (Melling). I kept waiting for him to put his foot wrong or misstep but he showed remarkable restraint in his characterization.
There were also not one but two curveballs having to do with the casting when I failed to recognize an actress whose work I make a point of taking note of. And there was also my complete failure to realize that another supporting character was played by one of the most well known and legendary actors of all time. I won't give away who it was just in case anyone else should watch this in the future.
The cinematography and location shooting contribute mightily to the overall atmosphere. It put me in mind of
Sleepy Hollow even though neither project was actually filmed in the Hudson Valley. There are the usual third act hiccups and the viewer is asked to follow along unquestioningly while red herrings and a final twist is thrown at them. But all in all this is a story that more people should be made aware of. Recommended.
80/100