+1
So, interesting thing happened. I got the Orange Box for the PS3 (I know, I know, inferior version blah blah blah). There are 3 games on there, and I managed to take the time to play them for a while. Here's what I thought of them.
Portal - phenomenal game. Dark and twisted sense of humor, ingenious puzzle design, the most unique gameplay mechanics I've ever seen, and a well-crafted antagonist. Definitely a gaming masterpiece.
Team Fortress 2 - One of the single most fun FPS games I've ever played. Every character is well-balanced, the level design is top notch, the art style is nice to look at, and the gameplay is smooth and intense. I pick the Scout each time, and I can say I'm a mean one too.
Half-Life 2 - Yeah, this game didn't do much for me. It feels outdated to me. The characters are done well, as are the creatures and levels, but beyond that, nothing else works for me. The story's forgettable, the gameplay's average, and the puzzles are gimmicky at best. I know a bit about the first Half-Life game to know what's going on, but this series just doesn't interest me like I thought it would.