Oh. When @
Torgo asked if we have nostalgia for "this genre," I assumed he meant, classic 50s sci-fi b-movie horror (not necessarily campy b-movie, but low budget films), and not horror as a whole.
I grew up watching censored and edited versions of the Nightmare on Elm Street and Friday the 13th movies in grade school - often on USA's "Up! All Night". I think part 4 and part 6 had came out when I first became cognizant of them.
I really remember really liking Critters as well.
Keep in mind, grade school spans 6 years of one's life and it's tough placing where it happened.
Despite not ever watching any of the universal horror movies as a child, I still read the grade school picture book... not exactly novelizations of them.
I can't really remember my mid-teen years. I seem to recall not really being into horror then and looking down on it. Some of it was likely that period where you want to be "serious" about "good movies" (which I have to really put in quote, because it's the age when I took the Oscars seriously), but it was also well into the 90s at that point and the quality of horror was legitimately fallow at the time.
And yet, in college, it wasn't like I wasn't watching The Blair Witch Project in theaters, and I was still tracking down stuff like Naked Lunch and Lost Highway to watch from the video store.
It gets complicated, but at around 30, I decided to dive back in deep because a local horror group was doing a screening at a local arthouse theater of some cult 80s films, and I remember going, "I'm not going out to movie theaters enough and if I only go for those Janus film screenings, then I'm only ever going to go if I'm feeling mentally alert, so I should start going to these as well." And the nostalgia bomb kind of went off for me, and I started diving into a lot more cult stuff that I was unaware of when I was a kid, but was coming out in that era (and before).