Dixie Chicks

Tools    





Well, the Dixie Chicks have returned from the dead with a new video and a new CD to be released in May. For anyone in a coma prior to 2003, the Dixie Chicks were the hottest country act on the planet. Maybe any genre, not just country. It seemed like every other video and every other song on the radio was the Chicks.

Well, that all changed on March 10, 2003 when lead singer Natalie Maines said while performing in London "Just so you know, we're ashamed the President of the United States is from Texas." Not long after that, the Chicks virtually disappeared from radio. Fans called stations, threatening to boycott if the Chicks were played. Radio stations (unlike Natalie Maines) knew who their customers were and quit playing the Chicks. During all this, a feud erupted between country star, Toby Keith (who found gold in waving the flag and putting his boot up various asses). Picture Jimmy Cagney singing Yankee Doodle Dandy, then add a foot and 100 pounds and you have Toby singing American Soldier.

I give Maines credit for saying what she thought. But I wonder if she stopped to consider who her fans were and the ramifications. The Chicks, realizing that their millions would soon be reduced to thousands, offered an apology just a few days after "the comment." It didn't work. We have virtually been Chickless for three years.

Now that the sentiment for the war is changing, will the Chicks be welcomed back to the fold? Do they care? Will they try some kind of crossover to pop...folk...rap?
__________________
My name is Maximus Decimus Meridius, commander of the Armies of the North, General of the Felix Legions, loyal servant to the true emperor, Marcus Aurelius. Father to a murdered son, husband to a murdered wife. And I will have my vengeance, in this life or the next.




i'm SUPER GOOD at Jewel karaoke
Dixie Chicks are the only new country I can really stand...especially their last CD with the roots of their bluegrass on it...I absolutely love Natalies voice and can't wait til their next CD comes out. Go Dixie Chicks
__________________
letterboxd



Lets put a smile on that block
Im not a a fan of Country, but i reeeeeally like the Dixie Chicks. Theyre funky ladeeeeees. I'll have a listen to their new stuff.
__________________
Pumpkins scream in the DEAD of night!



Im a fan of some types of country music, Tim Mcgraw, Deirks Bentley and Craig Morgan being some of my favorites.

The Dixie chicks I can do without. Either way, good luck to them, maybe they will leave the politics up to other people, and play music this time around- the reason people used to pay to see them anyway.
__________________
Some people are like Slinkies . . . not really good for anything, but
you still can't help but smile when you see one tumble down the stairs

www.panicattic.com - Check out the Q&A from Ethan Dettenmaier , director of Sin-Jin Smyth



i'm SUPER GOOD at Jewel karaoke
Originally Posted by nyabzns
The Dixie chicks I can do without. Either way, good luck to them, maybe they will leave the politics up to other people, and play music this time around- the reason people used to pay to see them anyway.
she was voicing her opinion, which, as a star, she should have known such a comment would backfire onto her, but also has that right just like everyone else. would you like it if you weren't able to voice your opinion on such a thing? hell no...

her voicing her opinion did not get in the way of her performing and making music...she did a brilliant job of both, and i among many others look forward to seeing more from her, even though she was shunned by a high number of people...its cool if you don't dig her music, but i can't help but see your comments as a little biased...

but then again so are mine, to a degree.



The People's Republic of Clogher
Politics and pop music (for that's what ver Chicks perform, innit? Twangsome pop music) have long been intermixed, whether it be Billy Bragg recording Socialist anthems to Bono's slightly cringeworthy attempts at changing the planet.

Give a guy an audience and he's also got a platform.....for better or worse.
__________________
"Critics are like eunuchs in a harem; they know how the Tatty 100 is done, they've seen it done every day, but they're unable to do it themselves." - Brendan Behan



i'm SUPER GOOD at Jewel karaoke
Originally Posted by Tacitus
Politics and pop music (for that's what ver Chicks perform, innit? Twangsome pop music) have long been intermixed, whether it be Billy Bragg recording Socialist anthems to Bono's slightly cringeworthy attempts at changing the planet.

Give a guy an audience and he's also got a platform.....for better or worse.
no one tells Toby Keith or Alan Jackson to butt out. thats interesting, innit



They'll be right back on top. How many people would say the same thing about the president now? Natalie was just the first. She had every right to say what she did, that's what being an American is all about. After that brief period where they were off the radio, they filtered back on. Songs like "Travelling Soldier" brought them back. They're too good to not be on the radio.



Originally Posted by ash_is_the_gal
she was voicing her opinion, which, as a star, she should have known such a comment would backfire onto her, but also has that right just like everyone else. would you like it if you weren't able to voice your opinion on such a thing? hell no...

her voicing her opinion did not get in the way of her performing and making music...she did a brilliant job of both, and i among many others look forward to seeing more from her, even though she was shunned by a high number of people...its cool if you don't dig her music, but i can't help but see your comments as a little biased...

but then again so are mine, to a degree.
My comments are a little biased. I never liked the Dixie Chicks anyway. I happen to think everyones got the right to there opinion, but if your in the public eye with a following perhaps sometimes its best to stick to what you do best, and leave your opinions to yourself.. fan backlash can be brutal.

It wouldn't take a rocket scientist to know what sort of support George Busch had at the time of her comments from the demographics that encompass a lot of country music fans.


I actually like people that voice there opinions, One of my favorite live acts is Kid Rock ( don't throw stones, I know some people hate him ) , he seems to always offer an opinion, sometimes brutally, if you like it, fine, if you don't, you'll deal with it.



010011100110111101110100
Originally Posted by Ford
They're too good to not be on the radio.
Some of my favorite bands never get played on the radio. Therefore they must not be good enough. Nice to know my taste sucks.



What is the deal with everyone twisting around what I say and getting offended by it?

Lighten up. It's movieforums.com not cancerforums.com



Originally Posted by Ford
What is the deal with everyone twisting around what I say and getting offended by it?

Lighten up. It's movieforums.com not cancerforums.com
This is MOFO dangit, why are you saying we are just another site. We stand out in a crowd buddy and we dont have to lighten up if we do not want to. Get with the program and tighten it up!!!
.
.
.
.

.
.
.
.
.Okay sorry was kidding.
__________________
“The gladdest moment in human life, methinks, is a departure into unknown lands.” – Sir Richard Burton



Lets put a smile on that block
Originally Posted by Ford
Lighten up. It's movieforums.com not cancerforums.com
I have been to that forum. And ya know, it really isnt as fun as you think it would be.



010011100110111101110100
Originally Posted by Ford
What is the deal with everyone twisting around what I say and getting offended by it?

Lighten up. It's movieforums.com not cancerforums.com
No offense taken.



From what I remember, they were being heckled by "Golgot and company" (sorry ) in England when they said it… and I thought at the time and still do, they were only trying to cover their asses... in green backs... anyway, I've never bought one of their CD's and probably never will… even though I do think Goodbye Earl is funny…
__________________
You never know what is enough, until you know what is more than enough.
~William Blake ~

AiSv Nv wa do hi ya do...
(Walk in Peace)




i'm SUPER GOOD at Jewel karaoke
Originally Posted by Caitlyn
even though I do think Goodbye Earl is funny…
i loooooooooooove goodbye earl...its a karaoke favorite.

i have bought their cds and will continue to do so. even though i of course agree with what Maines said that got her into such deep doo-doo in the first place, it wasn't the wisest thing to say in a foreign land. but i fully support natalie and her awesome voice.



Originally Posted by ash_is_the_gal
even though i of course agree with what Maines said that got her into such deep doo-doo in the first place, it wasn't the wisest thing to say in a foreign land. but i fully support natalie and her awesome voice.
I'm curious about the politics of the other two Chicks. Natalie is probably left of center but are they? They might even be right of center but Natalie is the reason for their huge success so do they have to support her? Would they liked to have strangled her when she said what she did?



I don't know about other country stations across the country, but on the one here in Cleveland they still play the Dixie Chicks version of the National Anthem that they sang before a Super Bowl.



All good people are asleep and dreaming.
Originally Posted by ash_is_the_gal
but i fully support natalie and her awesome voice.
Natalie Maines voice is like nails on the chalkboard.


Originally Posted by Caitlyn
From what I remember, they were being heckled by "Golgot and company" (sorry ) in England when they said it… and I thought at the time and still do, they were only trying to cover their asses... in green backs... anyway, I've never bought one of their CD's and probably never will… even though I do think Goodbye Earl is funny…
I thought it was funny after it went down that they tried to appeal more to the Lilith Fair crowd and less to country fans.


Whether I agree or disagree with an entertainers politicals views or not, I don't want to here it from them!

I don't value their opinion more than anyone else.

Shut the hell up, or I should have the right for equal time for a rebuttal!

P.S. I think The Dixie Chicks are very talented, but really, their songs are just silly pop music, easily replacable.



i'm SUPER GOOD at Jewel karaoke
Originally Posted by Loner
Natalie Maines voice is like nails on the calkboard.
going out on a limb here and assuming you meant chalkboard.

im sorry to hear you think so. i love her voice. its absolutely gorgeous. and i love her music. their music. especially their last cd, which has more of a bluegrass sound. sorry, i guess im not as deep as some, cause people like the dixie chicks quench my taste.