I've been a fan for about two years now and, while I like them quite a bit, I'm still scratching my head over how inconsistent they are. It often feels like a coin flip as to whether or not I'll like a given song of theirs. Some of it is just noise.
Also, I was pretty shocked when I heard a re-written version of "Wraith Pinned To The Mist And Other Games" in an Outbeak Steakhouse commercial. I'm not the type to give bands grief for "selling out" -- I think endorsements and the like are a perfectly reasonable thing -- but Of Montreal is about the last band in the world I would have expected to do something like that.
Anyway, the album art is pretty, if nothing else, but they're not the type of band whose albums I'd listen to straight through. Prime pick-and-choose material.
Aye. I wouldn't exactly say they're inconsistent, that's just the type of music they make. The structure of the songs is almost progressive (as far as pop
can be anyway), it's completely non-linear, a lot of the times it feels like they mixed up 5-6 songs into one. On some cases they make perfect pop songs, on others they experiment. I've learned to like it all, I think it just takes a while to get used to it. For me, it's enough that a particular song has even a 10 second part that's good for me to love it. And they've managed to achieve that in every single song.
I think they're getting better with each album, quite a feat seeing as how they've been around quite a while. They struck a particular cord with me with the infusion of electro on the last two albums.
As far as selling out, I don't mind that at all. It's just another way of making their music more accessible to the masses (that aren't exactly into indie). You should've seen the crowd they were performing for in Croatia, there couldn't have been more than 150 people there. I was right next to the (improvised) dressing room the size of a medium bathroom where they prepared for the gig (and this band is considered one of the best indie-pop bands in the world). So yeah, I don't think they sold out...I just think they don't care much, as well they shouldn't.
Awesome, awesome band. The party's crashing us now is the best pop song I've heard...possibly ever....