Star Citizen: The Legal Summary No-one Deserves (Or Wants!)
I'm so far down the rabbit hole I'm constantly late.....
Why Are Crytek Suing Star Citizen?
This is stupidly involved. Here's the stupidly simple version:
The Biggest Claims:
That Star Citizen have tried to sell the 'Squadron 42' campaign mode as a separate game, and moved to other game engines, breaching their Crytek license.
(More detail in this half-decent
supporter summary).
Some Backdrop:
Crytek accepted upfront payments in 2012 rather than future royalties. (They only expected a boost to their brand and tech improvements as further payback, as I understand it). They must be pissed at not getting any cut of the 175m+ SC has gone on to raise, and at watching SC move to derivative versions of the Cryengine without tipping the hat in any way. (They're also pissed at a load of their staff decamping to SC both before and after the agreement, possibly weighting the license in SC's favour in the process). This is likely about both cash
& personality clashes...
The Moral Maze:
Crytek are amoral bastards these days who've mistreated their staff as part of their slow-motion collapse. Star Citizen is a satellite array of shell companies, that at a minimum plays dirty with its unloyal backers (by
hiding behind shell companies to refuse them refunds...). And probably has stiffed the weakened Crytek here, although possibly in legal grey-area ways.
Bottom Line:
I'd like to see Star Citizen as a working game (etc etc). I'd also like them to reach the Disclosure stage in a legal trial though, just to see if they've been knowingly deceptive along the way
. And I wouldn't mind them disintegrating if they'd been so excessively...
I can't help but think they've been scurrilous somewhere. Whether it be in their reported earnings being boosted to maintain backer morale & investment, or in their claims to have moved game engines [which sceptical devs claim they did suspiciously quickly], or just in the traditional sense of repeatedly, eternally promising the moon [step forward
Chris 'We can build a planet every two days' Roberts...
]
---
I Rest My Case:
In the meantime it's just all kinda funny
. From the alpha testers who've been
permanently turned into eyeballs, or left headless for weeks, or whose
ship spawned on fire. 5 years+ down the line, this game is amazing