The Captains (Shatner, 2011)
An odd film. Shatner can't help but make everything about him in some way, but that is actually OK here. Shatner's Captain Kirk IS iconic. This is a pretty personal exploration of the Star Trek captain characters throughout the years, with intimate chats between Bill and each of the other actors that have sat in the chair.
The odd thing is that, at first, Shatner sort of admits to having this odd rivalry with his screen persona. He dislikes being thought of as Captain Kirk, and feels the role has dominated his personal life no matter what he does. He felt that, from very early on, he would get derisive comments and attitudes about his work on Star Trek, and that the constant comments, such as "Beam me Up, Scotty", were a plague upon his existence.
As he chats with each captain, and some chats are better than others, he slowly comes around and recognizes, very genuinely I might add, that he HAS done good work, and that Kirk is something to be proud of, not ashamed. Patrick Stewart, who also had misgivings about "slumming" when he first got involved, has also come to respect and recognize his work as Picard as the defining role of his entire career, and he is just fine with that. In fact, Kirk had never seen any Star Trek:TNG before he did the film. I guess it makes sense, when considering the guy wanted to distance himself from the franchise.
The cool thing was listening to Shatner's comments on Stewart's turn as the captain. I got the idea that Shatner was blown away by the level of skill and seriousness Stewart reached when playing the part.
"I mean, Pat...this is really, really good stuff. I was stunned at how good! I mean, I always put the drama on, sometimes way over the top - too much confidence, too much gravitas. Why didn't I ever try to play Kirk as diffident? I think it could have worked. Your work inspired me to rethink my character and re-examine him. I like him more, now."
Great, great stuff. The Stewart/Shatner segments were all great, as were the Bacula/Shatner segments. Avery Brooks... is completely out of his mind, stoned, and lost in his music. He couldn't really do a good interview because he was constantly noodling on his piano and making up little songs to sing at Shatner instead of talking to him. It was fairly entertaining, but ultimately, a waste of everyone's time, including Shatner's. Kate Mulgrew... I don't know why, but I will just always like her. I know she is a self-righteous shrew, and I understand her ego is tremendous. She even says that, in so many words, during the interview. These are two actors with ridiculous ego issues, and they are quite frank about it. Still, I like Voyager and a big reason for that is Mulgrew's Janeway. Finally, Hemsworth is cool and slick, and clearly dedicated to his craft - a theater veteran since childhood, he is a consummate professional, and a fine choice for the next generation of Trek.
Overall, an entertaining watch, if a bit odd in places. If you like ol' Bill Shatner, check this one out!