The God Committee
The 2021 drama The God Committee is a compelling story centered around an emotionally charged subject; unfortunately budget limitations really keep this film from being the truly important cinematic experience it should have been.

A teenager is hit by a car and dies. He's revealed to be an organ donor and we see his heart being transported to a large metropolitan hospital but the intended recipient of the heart dies before the heart arrives, leaving the heart available for three other possible recipients. The decision of which recipient should get the heart falls on the hospital's transplant committee. It's revealed that one of the possible recipients is not really interested in a new heart. The other two are an overweight man who should have lost weight, making the transplant a risk and the other is a drug addict with a pregnant girlfriend who he has been abusing. Normally, anyone use drugs is instantly ineligible for a transplant, but the father of this addict is a billionaire who has offered the hospital $25 million dollars if his son receives the heart.

Director and screenwriter Austin Stark has created a squirm-worthy story, based on a play by Mark St German, which I suspect stretches the story beyond the limits of a proscenium stage by having the story move back and forth through time, including showing us the first day that some of the committee members joined this important part of medical administration. Further layers are added to the story with the reveal that one member of the committee has a personal agenda regarding the recipient and that he also has a personal relationship with another member of the committee. The story even leaps into the future long after the decision is made, revealing the consequences of the committee's decision.

This film reminded me a lot of a Woody Harrelson film called The Messenger, which had nothing to do with medicine, but conveyed the same kind of sacred and life-altering duty it is serving on this committee, the same way it was a sacred duty in The Messenger to inform loved ones when the soldier in their lives had passed away. This is the primary reason this film actually had this reviewer talking back at the screen due to the possibility of this sacred duty being desecrated by the power of the almighty dollar.

Unfortunately, this indie project's low budget really dilutes the power of the piece because throughout the entire running time, all I kept thinking was how amazing this film would have been with actors like Cate Blanchett, Christoph Waltz, and Don Cheadle playing the roles played here by Janeane Garafolo, Kelsey Grammer (in a bad hair piece), and Colman Domingo. These actors work very hard to be convincing in their roles, but this story is just a little above their pay grade. It would have been nice to see this film made with A list actors, but as is, still worth a look for the fascinating subject matter.
The 2021 drama The God Committee is a compelling story centered around an emotionally charged subject; unfortunately budget limitations really keep this film from being the truly important cinematic experience it should have been.

A teenager is hit by a car and dies. He's revealed to be an organ donor and we see his heart being transported to a large metropolitan hospital but the intended recipient of the heart dies before the heart arrives, leaving the heart available for three other possible recipients. The decision of which recipient should get the heart falls on the hospital's transplant committee. It's revealed that one of the possible recipients is not really interested in a new heart. The other two are an overweight man who should have lost weight, making the transplant a risk and the other is a drug addict with a pregnant girlfriend who he has been abusing. Normally, anyone use drugs is instantly ineligible for a transplant, but the father of this addict is a billionaire who has offered the hospital $25 million dollars if his son receives the heart.

Director and screenwriter Austin Stark has created a squirm-worthy story, based on a play by Mark St German, which I suspect stretches the story beyond the limits of a proscenium stage by having the story move back and forth through time, including showing us the first day that some of the committee members joined this important part of medical administration. Further layers are added to the story with the reveal that one member of the committee has a personal agenda regarding the recipient and that he also has a personal relationship with another member of the committee. The story even leaps into the future long after the decision is made, revealing the consequences of the committee's decision.

This film reminded me a lot of a Woody Harrelson film called The Messenger, which had nothing to do with medicine, but conveyed the same kind of sacred and life-altering duty it is serving on this committee, the same way it was a sacred duty in The Messenger to inform loved ones when the soldier in their lives had passed away. This is the primary reason this film actually had this reviewer talking back at the screen due to the possibility of this sacred duty being desecrated by the power of the almighty dollar.

Unfortunately, this indie project's low budget really dilutes the power of the piece because throughout the entire running time, all I kept thinking was how amazing this film would have been with actors like Cate Blanchett, Christoph Waltz, and Don Cheadle playing the roles played here by Janeane Garafolo, Kelsey Grammer (in a bad hair piece), and Colman Domingo. These actors work very hard to be convincing in their roles, but this story is just a little above their pay grade. It would have been nice to see this film made with A list actors, but as is, still worth a look for the fascinating subject matter.
Last edited by Gideon58; 06-18-24 at 04:17 PM.