Usually i'd have a problem with this guy acting like an a55hole, but he really shouldn't have to explain what he means here.
I disagree. I don't think his topic was clear at all.
His thread title is "
Top 5 movies you need to watch tonight!". Nowhere does he ask what movies we would
recommend for him to watch. He's asking what
we need to watch.
I
need to watch five movies from 1964 to finish my list for the 1964 Movies thread.
That's not the same as the five movies that I
want to watch. Those would be movies that are on my watchlist because they're movies that I heard about or saw the trailer, and they sounded like my kind of movies. Maybe even movies that were recommended to me by someone here on the boards.
Then in his actual post, he says "
I want more films to watch that possibly i haven't seen.". That's only telling us what movies
he wants to watch. It's still not asking us for recommendations. He's only answering his own title without actually listing any movies.
If he wants recommendations, he could have asked much clearer than the way he wrote his opening post. I have no way to recommend anything to him. He gives us no idea of what movies he's seen, what his favorite movies are, or even his favorite genres.
I could list five of my favorite musicals, only to find out that he hates musicals. Or someone else could list five of their favorite horror films, only to find out that he hates horror movies.
I think Citizen Rules was 100% right to ask for more details. IMO, the original post is as clear as mud.
After I get more info from the OP, I'll be happy to try to suggest some movies, but until then, I'm just spinning my wheels and going nowhere fast.