Connor Macgregor Reviews...Stand By The Closing Doors Autism in cinema is a very tough and touchy subject to tackle. Many films in the past have tackled the subject with a more humorous, light hearted tone (Adam, Rain Man etc). But with Stand By The Closing Doors, director Sam Fleischner opts for a more gritty, realistic take on how a lower class family deals with autism, as well as a small amount of insight into the eyes and mind of an autistic teenager.
Stand By The Closing Doors focuses on a dysfunctional, struggling Mexican family, who are thrown into crisis when Ricky, their autistic son, goes on the subway by himself following an intense day at school, without alerting his family. This sends his mother Mariana into a state of panic and anger, taking it out on her daughter Carla for not looking after him properly, as well as her husband Ricardo for leaving her to raise their children single. As these three flawed family members pull together to search for a confused and somewhat frightened Ricky, they must confront their problems and seek a resolution if they have any hope of reuniting their family.
What I like about this film is how its made. It’s a very grounded film with a story based on somewhat true events. Director Sam Fleischner is a filmmaker with a small budget, but with big bold ideas that he manages to create on camera. He combines his serious handheld camera style with flashing moments of surreal David Lynch style sequences which give us some idea of what is inside the autistic mind of Ricky as he is lost within the tunnels of the New York Subway.
The family in the picture are very well realised, and are incredibly believable on screen. None of these characters are completely perfect, but you still sympathise with them when events take a wrong turn. I also like the idea of combing the real life events, (presidential elections, major storm, etc) and making it clash with the fictional plotline. It’s quite a nice idea, and it makes you believe that this was something that really happened, or could easily happen in real life. It also shows you the truly frightening aspect of what comes with dealing a youth with autism; presenting the challenges as they are, as well as the strain and anger of the other family members.
There are some things in the film that can be problematic. The biggest concern is the fact that the film was a little too grim at points, whether it’s the mother Marianna unfairly laying into her daughter and husband continually for Ricky’s disappearance, or the amount of public abuse Ricky receives following an embarrassing situation on the subway. Most films seen depicting aspergers syndrome or autism spectrum disorder have showcased a more lighter tone when it comes to tackling the entirety of aspergers syndrome and autism spectrum disorder. Films such as Adam, Rain Man or the Swedish film Simple Simon, have all showcased these mental disabilities in a lighter and comedic tone, as well as educating audiences on these types of disorders and what the people possessing them have to go through on a day to day basis. In this film, there’s no light relief moments whatsoever, and it doesn’t allow the audience to relate to Ricky whatsoever.
Stand By The Closing Doors is a film that looks at autism and its struggles in a very different tone than before. It focuses on the families emotions, the daily struggles they take on and taps into the mind of an autistic teenager and what he sees, hears and thinks. Its not a perfect film, as it comes off at times soulless and harsh to its audience, but it’s a more truthful and honest insight of autism than ever before in cinema.
Rating - 73% - B+