I'm interested what do you say about https://www.afi.com/100years/movies10.aspx
Because this is the most referential and cannonical list, at least for usa movies. Who made it? People like famous directors? I get a feeling that Spielberg partially unfortunatelly had many of his fingers in it.
Here's my take. I'll examine it bit by bit, the old one and compare them.
1. Citizen Kane Well, this is no surpirse unfortunately.
2. The Godfather ok, driving force is Marlon and FFC, music, Mario, everything works. It's way too high, a slight favorite.
3. Casablanca WAY too high. Not even a fav. Rigid and cinical in a negative way.
4. Raging Bull just saw it recently again, insanely impressive. The scene when SRR beats him is transcendental.
5. Singin' in the rain cant fbelieve it! no 5?! I guess they had to have a musical intop 5!
6. Gone with the wind now were talkin. One of the most beautifull films ever.
7. Lawrence I'm sick of it. ok, it's fine, maybe the best directed movie, but an overblown spectacle. Hell, even Alec is pompous, my least fav performance
8. Shindlers list. Cant believe this is so high. Spielberg
9. Vertigo a master piece, but too high
10. Oz Rubbish.Should be on the worst list.
i've seen 89. How many have you?
Because this is the most referential and cannonical list, at least for usa movies. Who made it? People like famous directors? I get a feeling that Spielberg partially unfortunatelly had many of his fingers in it.
Here's my take. I'll examine it bit by bit, the old one and compare them.
1. Citizen Kane Well, this is no surpirse unfortunately.
2. The Godfather ok, driving force is Marlon and FFC, music, Mario, everything works. It's way too high, a slight favorite.
3. Casablanca WAY too high. Not even a fav. Rigid and cinical in a negative way.
4. Raging Bull just saw it recently again, insanely impressive. The scene when SRR beats him is transcendental.
5. Singin' in the rain cant fbelieve it! no 5?! I guess they had to have a musical intop 5!
6. Gone with the wind now were talkin. One of the most beautifull films ever.
7. Lawrence I'm sick of it. ok, it's fine, maybe the best directed movie, but an overblown spectacle. Hell, even Alec is pompous, my least fav performance
8. Shindlers list. Cant believe this is so high. Spielberg
9. Vertigo a master piece, but too high
10. Oz Rubbish.Should be on the worst list.
i've seen 89. How many have you?