Good point. Hadn't thought about that. Do you get my point though? When a movie is aiming to be style more than anything, and doesn't pretend to be profound storytelling (think Amer), I don't think "style over substance" is really a valid criticism.
I agree with that... unless it's something like Luhrman's Gatsby, that turns an amazing book into something mediocre.
I also just watched The Guest recently, a few days ago to be specific. I also really enjoyed it and would rate it about the same probably. And you're right about the fantastic soundtrack.
Watched this today with a horror buddy of mine, who had never seen it. Great movie, one of my favorites. Don't know what to say. It's great horror cinema. I just noticed a lot of brilliance in it this time around. Not that I didn't in past viewings, but from the opening, scene after scene is just so exciting, engaging and fun to watch. Wes Craven might have some duds, but I don't think he's a fluke director personally, and this movie is good proof of that - it's very solidly crafted.
My favorite Craven is Red Eye. I know I'm in the minority with that.
Yup, I do think you are. I watched it because it got Cillian Murphy in it, and I have watched it twice, and wouldn't mind watching it again. But it will never be a favorite of mine.