Sunshine...
Bleh....
I liked it to an extent, but I've seen it before when it was called....
"
EVERY OTHER SCI-FI MOVIE WHERE A TEAM VENTURES OFF IN SPACE TO SAVE EARTH!"
<sigh>
So, why did you go see it at all? You knew the premise going in, right? Also, what is this slew of other films you are referring to? There isn't a whole ton of films that follow this formula. At least not any of exceptional quality... NO film takes the angle that Sunshine does, tackling the philosophical questions it does in the way that it does. Also, who cares if the story has been told (which it hasn't, btw). I mean, why not just read The Odyssey over and over again?
The idea that a story can only be told once is silly, and is no argument on the quality of anything, as far as I am concerned.
Meanwhile, I don't buy the idea that the sci-fi genre has a ton of films that follow this model. Please, list this tremendous list we are inundated with.
Let's see what i can come up with...
Armageddon - This is the film that most closely fits what you are talking about, but it's TERRIBLE, poorly directed, poorly written garbage, so it has absolutely no bearing on whether of not Sunshine is a good film. Well, except that Sunshine is the antithesis of 'geddon, in that it does everything right, while 'geddon does everything wrong. No comparison.
Alien series? Nope - No saving the earth here.
Star Wars? Nope, it's fantasy anyway, not science fiction, and Earth doesn't exist.
Contact? Nope
12 Monkeys? Nope
Blade Runner? Nope
Star Trek? The fourth film sort of fits the bill, but alas, Star Trek isn't true science fiction, it's fantasy, and is nothing like Sunshine.
2001:A Space Odyssey? Nope
Solaris? Nope
The Fifth Element - Sort of fits the bill, with a BIG stretch, and, again, plays NOTHING like Sunshine. Love the flick, tho!
OK, I just ran this concept by a couple people at work and we brainstormed for a while to get another title:
Deep Impact - This fits the concept, but its quality is not anywhere near Sunshine, IMO.
So, I can't think of many films like Sunshine, and I can't think of ANY that come close in quality.
IMO,
Sunshine is one of the best true science-fiction films to come out in recent years. Bravo!