Has anyone ever come in here, made a thread so outlandish as this, get a tidalwave of argument against it, but the OP actually acknowledge the argument and change their mind? Ever?
In a general sense, I don't think people change their minds from online discussions.
Although, I will admit that my views on
some subjects have "evolved" after debates and reading the views of others.
This reminds me of a friend who told me, "
You just want to argue with everything I say," and I responded that at least it meant I was listening, and since I was listening then I would be ruminating on what they said later. And I would. For everyone I'd debate, I'd later reflect on their views and what they had to say ... and in some way, their views would have an impact. They may not make me change my mind, but they would enlighten me to consider the thoughts, positions & perspectives of others.
For forums like this - I think the arguing is part of the fun. I think people come here to express themselves, argue with the expressions of others, get feedback and socialize (it's so much easier in a virtual realm rather than with "real" people face to face - there's so much preparation involved.... bathing, shaving, dressing, making sure you smell nice, etc.)