I thought the Favorite Movie Star List had a lot of potential, but several people, including myself, have expressed that they were upset that the list was rushed, and they left people off of their lists, or in some cases, they didn't even get to submit. Several people, including myself, missed most, or all, of the results as well, so we didn't get the comments and discussion that we would have liked.
I was thinking about rerunning the same list that SC just ran, (the movie stars list), but giving people until about Jan 1st to submit their lists. That would give people time to think about their lists, and get them the way they want them. Then I would calculate the results, and rerun the same list, but with the results revealed at a normal pace, of only one or two results per day, so people would have time to discuss them this time around.
I thought it would be interesting to see how different the results would be if people had time to think about their lists, and people would enjoy the time to make comments and discuss the results. They could even use his original thread as a reference to make sure that they don't leave anyone off of their lists this time.
What do you think about this idea?
I was thinking about rerunning the same list that SC just ran, (the movie stars list), but giving people until about Jan 1st to submit their lists. That would give people time to think about their lists, and get them the way they want them. Then I would calculate the results, and rerun the same list, but with the results revealed at a normal pace, of only one or two results per day, so people would have time to discuss them this time around.
I thought it would be interesting to see how different the results would be if people had time to think about their lists, and people would enjoy the time to make comments and discuss the results. They could even use his original thread as a reference to make sure that they don't leave anyone off of their lists this time.
What do you think about this idea?