
As a director, Danny DeVito has proven to have a real flair for bringing black comedy to the screen, evidenced in his films Throw Momma from the Train and The War of the Roses, but his 2003 film Duplex isn't quite as effective as the other two films, primarily due to a screenplay that provides unrealistic motivations for the central characters.

The film stars Ben Stiller and Drew Barrymore as Alex and Nancy, married upwardly mobiles who find a beautiful duplex in Brooklyn and plan to convert the second floor into a nursery, a plan halted by the fact that an old woman named Mrs. Connelly still resides on the second floor who refuses to move out. Things get complicated when Mrs. Connelly starts driving our young couple crazy with outrageous demands and behavior unbecoming a good tenant, forcing the couple to actually consider murdering the woman to get her out of their lives.

The film's primary problem lies with Larry Doyle's screenplay and his presentation of the character of Mrs. Connelly. The character is unbelievable because at one moment the character appears to be a sweet old lady who innocently causes problems for this couple and at other moments she appears to be this sneaky and manipulative woman determined to make these people miserable. If the character had just been a sweet old lady or a manipulative bitch, the story would have been more believable. Even if she started out as a sweet old lady and became a manipulative bitch, I might have believed that, but the character doesn't come off that way and the way her personality changes from one scene to the next, makes it hard to believe the character or have sympathy for her. If the character evoked some kind of sympathy, the whole story might have made more sense.
Stiller and Barrymore work well together, with a special nod to Stiller, underplaying effectively and displaying a genuine gift for physical comedy and Eileen Essell's sweet face works for the character of Mrs. Connelly, though the screenplay is fighting her all the way.

DeVito creates an atmosphere suited to what's going on here, utilizing some imaginative camerawork and employs some wonderful art direction/set direction, providing a wonderful setting for this story. It's a shame that the problematic screenplay takes away from the technical expertise that DeVito and company have employed here.
Last edited by Gideon58; 05-17-16 at 04:41 PM.