All about the upcoming Live Action Musical Hall of Fame

There is no difference in how they go about being musicals, though.

Not in terms of their qualifications as musicals, no.

__________________

But musical is pretty specific, we don't need always need them to be more specific than that.

This isn't the equivalent of having Slasher as opposed to Horror. That's pretty specific, no?

__________________
Letterboxd

That is pretty specific, but we did run a regular horror hall of fame first. And I think that the horror genre is much larger than the musical genre. And I think that the slasher genre is larger than the animated musical genre, and probably the live-action musical genre too. Plus I didn't start a slasher hall of fame and then limit it to some arbitrary qualifications.

I know how that feels, man! It ain't good.

__________________

Can we have an anime musical hall of fame?

By the way, I sent in my nomination to Citizen Rules. I think we are in the habit of sharing nominations when Citizen runs these, so I'll share mine:

The Umbrellas of Cherbourg

How about everyone here humor me for a second. Let us pretend that we are doing a flat out Musical Hall of Fame. It has to be a musical, not about music, but it can be animated.

What would each of you honestly choose as your nomination?

Everybody on this forum speaks english no? haha

__________________
I do not speak english perfectly so expect some mistakes here and there in my messages

Yes! Now go run off and play with Guap.

I probably still would have gone with The Umbrellas of Cherbourg. It was between that and Popeye once I found out that Camo would have joined with South Park, which was another option I was weighing.

My nomination would either be Les Miserables or Alice in Wonderland.

Honestly I wouldn't participate in it at all, but if I had to choose one it would be Hedwig and the Angry Inch, obviously. But the point is that a true Musical Hall of Fame would allow people the option to nominate animated musicals or musicals with marionettes if they wanted to.

The only reason why I'm participating in the Animated Musical Hall of Fame is because it feels wrong for me not to participate in an animation specific HOF.

Yes, I know. I am curious how many would even do that. If it ends up being two or three out of several, it seems like a waste of time for animation. So if everyone will tell me that yes, they would be in the BIG Musical Hall of Fame, and tell me an honest nomination, we can judge it better from there. I truly don't want to make a poll, though.

Uno, babydoll! Give me one.

I may or not join this.

That looks very good!

I was considering nominating Bedknobs and Broomsticks, but it's a live action/animation hybrid. Could someone please direct me to the proper thread?

You'll have to wait for our Live-Action Animation Hybrid Disney Musical Hall of Fame.

Yawn! For the love of God, answer my question, people. Sh!!!!!!!!!!!t!