I'm hesitant to rate a film. Why? Because what criteria am I using?
Do I rate it on how much I personally like it?
Do I rate it on how close the film comes to delivering what it intended to do?
Do I rate it against some scale where the greatest movies of all time are a 5...and so a perfect score is darn near impossible?
On my movie review thread
http://www.movieforums.com/community...t=37050&page=3
I rated Inglorious Bastards a low
But that's a personal reaction to the choice of the music score which I hated.
If it wasn't for some post production stuff I might have scored it
and if I was a fan of that type of movie I might have gave it a
So who's to say what criteria we compare films too.
Do I rate it on how much I personally like it?
Do I rate it on how close the film comes to delivering what it intended to do?
Do I rate it against some scale where the greatest movies of all time are a 5...and so a perfect score is darn near impossible?
On my movie review thread
http://www.movieforums.com/community...t=37050&page=3
I rated Inglorious Bastards a low
But that's a personal reaction to the choice of the music score which I hated.
If it wasn't for some post production stuff I might have scored it
and if I was a fan of that type of movie I might have gave it a
So who's to say what criteria we compare films too.