Greatest decade in film?

Tools    


What's the greatest decade in film?
8.57%
6 votes
2000's (Lord of the Rings Trilogy, The Dark Knight)
20.00%
14 votes
1990's (Pulp Fiction, Shawshank Redemption)
12.86%
9 votes
1980's (Star Wars Part V and VI, Raging Bull)
28.57%
20 votes
1970's (The Godfather Parts 1 and 2, Apocalypse Now)
15.71%
11 votes
1960's (Lawrence of Arabia, 2001: A Space Odyssey)
4.29%
3 votes
1950's (Seven Samurai, 12 Angry Men)
4.29%
3 votes
1940's (Citizen Kane, Casablanca)
0%
0 votes
1930's (The Wizard of Oz, Gone with the Wind)
2.86%
2 votes
1920's (The Battleship Potempkin, The Gold Rush)
2.86%
2 votes
1910's (Intolerance, The Birth of a Nation)
70 votes. You may not vote on this poll




After starting the thread about the best movies of the first half of the 2010's it got me thinking about what the best decade ever was for film.

What do you think, in your own opinion, is the best decade in terms of the greatest films coming out in that time frame? I added a poll starting with the 1910's (when feature films really started to be made) up until the 2000's.

For me, I would say the 70's. It seems to me like that was the decade where the potential of film reached its apex, and lots of really great ones were being cranked out; the greatest one, of course, being The Godfather.

What say you?



i'll go with what Mark F says, he's probably the only one really qualified to say



Master of My Domain
I don't think there is a certain 'greatest' decade in film. All decades have had amazing films and directors that have contributed to cinema.

If I were to choose one though, that would be the 1910s where the basic rules of cinema were written by the people who were active at that time. Without them, there would be no favorite film of yours and mine.



The 1970s. Italian splatter movies, the rise of porn (uh..pun not intended) and of course Roger Corman at his sleaziest.



Lord High Filmquisitor
I find that decades clump easiest in pairs. These are kind of what I see them playing out as:

WARNING: "Generalization of Film History, as I See It" spoilers below
The 1920's and (early) 1930's were a matter of style over substance. The combined lack and newness of sound lead to distinctly visual aesthetics, best exemplified in German Expressionism. Everything had to be conveyed (and understood) without dialog and only sparingly used intertitles, which largely carried over into early sound films like M.

The 1940's and 1950's were largely defined by the yoke of the Film Production Code. Prievously outrageous content had to be parsed down into subtext, if allowed to remain at all. Subversive intonations and implications abounded, and the slick Hollywood Studio machine was strong enough to push out incredibly polished, high-quality films of concentrated entertainment. Combined with one another, the productions were generally better than they were interesting.

With the weakening, and then ultimate abandonment, of the Production Code and desperate to compete with television, the films of the 1960s and 1970s were generally the opposite of the previous too decades. Young, energetic talent emerged in contrast to the old guard of Hollywood. The productions, although often more cheaply made and experimental, were generally more interesting than they were well made.

The 1980s and 1990s, in my mind, brought together the aesthetics of the preceding four decades into a sort of compromise. Films were being produced with large budgets and huge wells of talent, but still were given some (although often not much) room to "find themselves." The productions were not quite as good as the 40s/50s and not quite as interesting as the 60s/70s, but equal parts of both.

Although not yet complete, the 2000s and 2010s seem to be coninuing the trends set in the last two decades of the twentieth century. Studio films are increasingly concentrated on a small number of highly profitable films, which means that blockbusters have the most money and high-end talent thrown at them as the studios can manage (or afford). In turn, this results in a superior quality blockbuster. At the same time, however, increasingly segmented viewing demographics (through the democratization of information, the rise of the internet and the general segmentation of interests from a singular mainstream) has lead to numerous projects tailored toward these viably profitable demographics. So while the overall films are still as good as they are interesting (in the sense of the 80s and 90s), they are more staunchly divided into one or the other.


When all is said and done, I prefer either the 1920s or the 2000s for the particular trends and specific films that they produced. If I had to choose one over the other, however, I would side with the 1920s.
__________________
Filmquisition: Raking Modern Entertainment Over the Coals Daily
Unrealitymag.com: New Articles Contributed Every Friday
Arcanis' 100 Favorite Films: 2015 Edition



Because I have too much time on my hands ...

I've taken the 10 best films from each decade and averaged my ratings. My expectation was that the 70s (thanks to Hollywood and Europe) and the 2000s (thanks to Asia) would be the best:

1920s: 83.1%
1930s: 84.8%
1940s: 89.1%
1950s: 93.2%
1960s: 95.6%
1970s: 93.4%
1980s: 93.0%
1990s: 94.5%
2000s: 97.5%
2010s: 95.3%

So, based on this completely un-scientific method, the correct answer is:

1. 2000s
2. 1960s
3. 2010s
4. 1990s
5. 1970s
6. 1950s
7. 1980s
8. 1940s
9. 1930s
10. 1920s

Kind of surprised by some of those but I guess it is heavily influenced by how many of the best films from each decade I've actually rated.



Not currently on fire...
60s for me. Best years of classic Hammer Horror, Spaghetti Westerns, Karl May Westerns, Roger Corman gothic horrors etc etc.



We've gone on holiday by mistake
I voted 90s but there wasn't much in it between, 70s, 80s and 90s. Maybe cause I grew up in the 90s a lot of those films hold a special place for me, my fav Director Micheal Mann made 3 masterpieces in Last of the Mohicans, Heat and The Insider. Plenty of other favourites, Shawshank, Seven, Fight Club, Matrix, Jurassic Park, Saving Private Ryan, Leon.Just a great decade for me.
__________________



I voted 90s but there wasn't much in it between, 70s, 80s and 90s. Maybe cause I grew up in the 90s a lot of those films hold a special place for me, my fav Director Micheal Mann made 3 masterpieces in Last of the Mohicans, Heat and The Insider. Plenty of other favourites, Shawshank, Seven, Fight Club, Matrix, Jurassic Park, Saving Private Ryan, Leon.Just a great decade for me.
Yeah nostalgia can make you bias, I would put the 90's maybe second or third best. A ton of great movies came out but imo the decade lacked that one special film that was on the level of Godfather, Casablanca etc.



Not quite sure. 1941-60... that 20 period is probably the best. Which one to pick...!!! I picked 40's
__________________
My Favorite Films



I am the Watcher in the Night
It's very difficult to objectively make a decision here as that would require me to study all the very best movies in every decade, rank them, wonder if they stand the test of time, look at the film makers and actors involved etc.

But in terms of personal taste, some of my favourite films originate from the 70s, 80s and 90s, with Once Upon a time in America, The Godfather 1/2, Se7en, Rocky, T1/2 and so on falling into that category.

If I really had to push for it, I might just opt for the 90s, a time in which big budget special effect extravanganzas were coupled with soul, good writing, acting and weren't just "blockbusters" they were damn good films in their own right. Something this decade to learn from.
__________________
"Frankly, my dear, I don't give a damn"

"I need your clothes, your boots and your motorcycle"



i'll go with what Mark F says, he's probably the only one really qualified to say
This. I'd love to have seen enough from each decade to answer this question, but i haven't which is why i enjoy this site so much it entices you to watch films you would never have went near; sometimes it results in a favourite and sometimes it results in a dissapointment but one thing you can always count on is that interesting conversations will arise about the film. Mark F, Holden and a few others are the only members i've seen show a great enough knowledge of film to present an accurate enough answer on their preferences.

From the little i've seen from each Decade, te 70s is my favourite.



70's has a good lead. Other notable films: Taxi Driver, One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, Star Wars: A New Hope, The Deer Hunter, Straw Dogs, A Cockwork Orange, Jaws, The French Connection.



is thouroughly embarrassed of this old username.
I want to say 60's because of how gosh-darn good the French and Japanese new-wave scene was but if I'm looking at my favourite films list the 2000's clearly have the most. Since the term is "greatest" and not "favourite" I'll lean towards the 60's.