JayDee's Movie Musings

→ in
Tools    





Ba dum tish.

I much prefer the original Cape Fear to its so-so remake. Mitchum rocks!
__________________
#31 on SC's Top 100 Mofos list!!



"Hey Look it's Masterman"
Great reviews. I actually enjoyed them shorter. Anyway, Cape Fear is fantastic. I actually find it very frightening. One of my favourites.
__________________
--I Find Your Lack Of Faith Disturbing.



I loved The Departed after recently rewatching it. Years ago, after it first came out, I tried watching it and I hated it, but I liked it the last time.

Cape Fear had a stupid ending and it wasn't that great, but there were parts that I liked (Robert De Niro's character) and it was okay. I have it. Honeykid and I should do a commentary.

Haven't seen After Hours. Not sure if I'd like it... the cast looks good, but I've got this feeling that I wouldn't like it. Too many people from this website love it and that gives off a bad vibe with me.



Miss Vicky's Loyal and Willing Slave
Great review of BOTD, man. I'd have rated it higher myself but your criticisms are very fair.
Thanks Deadite. Nice to see you back in the thread

How many of Scorsese's movies have you seen now?
Well I've got a little wrap-up coming soon of the season. It's only a handful of his films that I've not seen now.


So all the effort and time I've put into crafting my reviews and this is the kind of thanks I get? Basically just being told that people prefer my reviews when I don't talk as much -

I wish you kept them at that length more often--- they're still detailed and insightful, but without being so long-winded.
I actually enjoyed them shorter.
Nice reviews. I prefer the shorter format.
Well F*CK the lot of you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!






You ungrateful sumbitches!!!

(I'm really enjoying the multi-gifs today. )



Miss Vicky's Loyal and Willing Slave
JayDee Does Marty - A Wrap Up

Well there we have it, that's my season of Scorsese films wrapped up for the time being. I've gone from having only seen 4 of his films to having seen all but 4 of his films, well not including his documentaries. The only films I've still not seen are Boxcar Bertha, Who's That Knocking at My Door?, Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore and New York, New York.

And now that I have had substantial exposure to Scorsese and his work I can see why he is so highly lauded and loved by critics and audiences alike. That said there are a number of his films, especially amongst his most beloved, that just aren't for me. And in general I'm sure my scores are too low in the eyes of most people. However I have come away with a few films that I really liked and could one day love (Aviator, Hugo and After Hours), a large number that I enjoyed, a few that surprised me by how much I liked them (Departed, King of Comedy etc) and a couple that I could see perhaps growing on me in the future (Bringing out the Dead, Shutter Island, Age of Innocence).

I also watched a few more of his films that for one reason or another I just didn't get round to writing about. I watched Mean Streets, and it's another of Marty's gangster films that just don't do it for me. Although this time it wasn't just the genre that worked against it, I actually didn't think it was a very good film. Harvey Keitel's fiery performance aside I didn't find anything to really interest me at all. It was made on a shoestring budget, which sometimes a filmmaker can get around. Mean Streets however both felt and looked cheap to me. But maybe that's just me. Around about a
+ perhaps. I watched and really rather enjoyed The Color of Money. As Scorsese films go it was actually quite a small, simple story but my interest was held by a couple of captivating turns from Paul Newman and Tom Cruise. Scorsese's direction and camerawork were very helpful at maintaining the excitement of the pool matches which in themselves are not the most dynamic exercises to watch. Probably about a
. I watched what is generally considered to be Marty's companion piece to Goodfellas, Casino. And I was quite surprised by how much I enjoyed it considering its similarities to Goodfellas which I'm not overly enamoured with. While it's generally seen as the inferior film of the two I actually enjoyed Casino more, perhaps because it wasn't quite as mired in the gangster world as Goodfellas was and was quite flashy and glamorous. That said I still don't see it being one I will be all that desperate to ever revisit. Perhaps about a
-. Of all Scorsese's films perhaps the one I was most reluctant to view was The Last Temptation of Christ. As someone who is not at all religious I would generally avoid it like the plague, only watching it because it was another Scorsese film. Initially I was unable to get past my pre-conceived notions and prejudices but as time wore on I found myself more intrigued than I had expected, even if I still didn't come close to greatly liking it. This was largely down to Scorsese's direction and Dafoe's terrific performance. In the end perhaps
++ which is considerably more than I expected. The biggest disappointment of my Scorsese season was definitely Kundun. As someone with a passing interest in Eastern culture I was quite intrigued to see it but it did not work for me whatsoever. I just could not get into it, finding it extremely dull. As a result it was one of the toughest viewing experiences I've had in quite some time. Just rating on my personal enjoyment/investment would be lucky to get


Anyway here is how I would currently rank Scorsese's films, based on my enjoyment and not necessarily their quality which is why many of his films that are considered the best are down at the bottom. I'm aware that it's quite a unique ranking of his films, probably upside down to what many people would have. And it is definitely subject to change as they're based almost exclusively on single watches.

1. The Aviator
2. After Hours
= Hugo
4. The King of Comedy
5. The Departed
6. Cape Fear
7. Color of Money
8. Wolf of Wall Street
9. Shutter Island
10. Casino
11. Age of Innocence
12. Bringing out the Dead
13. Goodfellas
14. Taxi Driver
15. Last Temptation of Christ
16. Mean Streets
17. Raging Bull
18. Kundun

I've also seen Gangs of New York but many years ago. I'll need to give it another go someday but just now I think it would probably be somewhere in the 13-15 range.



Hey at least you watched them so I applaud you for that. Do try to watch Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore if you get the chance. It's excellent.



Good whiskey make jackrabbit slap de bear.
Even though I don't agree with all of your rankings, I respect that you gave Marty a chance.


It's also cool to see another person who considers The Color Of Money one of his better films.
__________________
"George, this is a little too much for me. Escaped convicts, fugitive sex... I've got a cockfight to focus on."



Miss Vicky's Loyal and Willing Slave
Well before I return to my long-winded reviews that everyone apparently hates I'm going to clean out my backlog of micro musings. To start with I'm going to go with a few that I know aren't going to prove all that popular. However if I'm happy to post positive reviews for popular films that I know are going to get a lot of agreement and rep then it's only fair I post the opposite as well


Micro Musings : Woody Allen Hate-a-thon



mirror
mirror

Year of release
1985

Directed by
Woody Allen

Starring
Mia Farrow
Jeff Bridges
Danny Aiello
Edward Herrmann
John Wood


The Purple Rose of Cairo

+

Of all the Woody Allen films out there I felt this was the one that held the most promise for me. And while there were some things about it that I liked, the overall experience yet again came up short for me. The film's central idea of a movie character coming to life and jumping out of the screen is a nice idea but one that was never able to rise above being merely a gimmick for me; and one that I didn't feel sustained the whole film. It only runs for a little over 80 minutes but even then I felt it was running on steam with Allen attempting to pad it out. Though I think it did a decent job of realising the escapist nature of films and why in particular they were so appealing during the depression. And I enjoyed the performances of both Jeff Bridges and Mia Farrow, finding both of them quite charming and endearing. So all in all it's quite a sweet little film but not one that really stoked a passion in me. It is however the one Woody Allen film I could picture myself being most likely to revisit, and perhaps take to someday.


mirror
mirror

Year of release
2011

Directed by
Woody Allen

Starring
Owen Wilson
Rachel McAdams
Marion Cotillard
Michael Sheen
Kurt Fuller
Kathy Bates

Midnight in Paris


Alongside Purple Rose of Cairo this was the other film of Allen's that I felt was most likely to appeal. And like that film there are some positives. Midnight in Paris does look lovely and I found Owen Wilson to be a very likeable, charming presence in the lead role. And it is pleasant enough in a whimsical, frothy sort of way but in the end it all felt pretty pointless and flimsy. One of the biggest problems I had with the film which just sabotaged it right from the start was Allen's writing in terms of the relationship between Wilson and Rachel McAdams. At no point did I ever get any sense why they were together and about to be married. She was just constantly fawning over Michael Sheen, belittling him in front of others and moaning about him to her parents. So I didn't get that she loved him, or why Wilson would love someone who in my eyes anyway was so clearly a real bitch. With Allen's films I just find that the dialogue and characters feel so fake, unrealistic and pretentious. And I'm aware I'm being pretty hypocritical because I've been known to like, and sometimes even love the films of Wes Anderson who you could very easily level the same complaint at. One other thing I should say is that I really don't like Woody Allen all that much in real life. I find him to be really quite the sleezy, unsavoury character and as much as I try to not let it do so I imagine that it certainly does colour my opinion of him and his films. While I like to think I'm going into his films with an open mind and looking to enjoy them, perhaps subconsciously I'm actually hoping to dislike them so I can level more hate his way.


mirror
mirror

Year of release
1973

Directed by
Woody Allen

Starring
Woody Allen
Diane Keaton
John Beck
Marya Small
Susan Miller

Sleeper

-

I know this is considered to be one of the funniest of Allen's films amongst many of his fans but it just really didn't do it for me. I actually found this to be pretty insufferable to be honest. The whole thing just annoyed me, and that was never more true than when it came to the Benny Hill inspired sequences which drove me to despair any time that the stupid music kicked in and the slapstick started up. I just found them to be brutally unfunny. And that's how I'd sum up Woody Allen in general. I just find his whole schtick to be spectacularly irritating. It's like he's doing a stereotypical impression of a Jewish person with his neurotic behaviour and constant whining. I'm struggling to think of an other actor that instils such a desire to punch them within me. And he seems to do the exact same thing in every movie! It seems to be almost impossible to differentiate one performance from any other. For me there were only really a couple of rare laughs to be found; Rags the robot dog and the robot tailors he encounters. And I did enjoy the absurdist idea of stealing the Leader's nose. But really very little for me here. And in terms of how much I actually 'enjoyed' this I'm perhaps being generous with my rating. The one thing that did work in its favour however is that at just 80 minutes long it had the good grace to get out of there early.


I know the views I've expressed here aren't shared by many people, if anybody on here, but just wanted to throw them out there anyway. That's now 5 or 6 Woody Allen films down and it's really not looking like he's for me. However I'm not saying that I will give up on him quite yet. I might try Manhattan next, although if I'm to really like any of his films I get the feeling it will be one that he doesn't actually star in.



I think you let your opinions on certain subjects influence your ratings too much sometimes. Like on Goodfellas and The Last Temptation of Christ for a start which you seem to dislike because you don't like gansters and you're not religious. And then Woody Allen films because you don't like the man.



I've just started watching Woody Allen films this year. I've seen 5 so far and Sleeper was my least favorite, although I did find it to be rather funny. I haven't seen the other two yet. I like that his films are not very long.

How I rank what I've seen

1. Blue Jasmine
2. Annie Hall
3. Manhattan
4. Crimes and Misdemeanors
5. Sleeper