The Western III Hall of Fame

Oop, I’m late!

My list so far

1.
2.
3. Bone Tomahawk
4.
5. Meek’s Cutoff
6.
7. The Scalphunters
8. Dirty Little Billy

And @Citizen Rules I claim eighth place with no shame

Oh you!

__________________
What I actually said to win MovieGal's heart:
- I might not be a real King of Kinkiness, but I make good pancakes

~Mr Minio

I liked my own nom!!

1.
2. Red River
3. Bone Tomahawk
4.
5. Meek’s Cutoff
6.
7. The Scalphunters
8. Dirty Little Billy

I had Red River at #2.

BRB

I had Billy at 4 and Red River at 3.


and, now, for our second Tie:

YESSSSSS MY #1 WONN!!!

1. McCabe and Mrs Miller
2. Red River
3. Bone Tomahawk
4. The Big Gundown
5. Meeks Cutoff
6. The Grey Fox
7. The Scalphunters
8. Dirty Little Billy

Thanks for hosting Ed!!!

Oh oops I posted before he revealed it

1. McCabe and Mrs. Miller
2. Red River
3.
4.
5.
6.
7. Dirty Little Billy
8. Scalphunters


The other 4 are all so close that I have no idea what order I'd put them in.




Good job everyone!

Congrats Ahwell, yet again...don't you get tired of having your movies win Seriously Mc Cabe and Mrs Miller was a good choice.

Thanks Mucho Ed for hosting! Nicely done.

And thanks to everyone for joining & nominating some interesting films, and especially for finishing!

THANKS EVERYONE
and CONGRATS to John-Connor for the WIN!!!


I also wanted to post the running tally. It was seriously tight race for the top 3 positions.
I have this set as the first 3 votes tallied, followed by the next three and then the last two votes


McCabe & Mrs Miller ...... 1st/21pts.... 2nd/32pt .... 1st/45pts ....

The Grey Fox ...... 6th/12pts.... 3rd/29pts.... 2nd/42pts*....

The Big Gundown ....... 4th/14pts.... 1st/33pts*.... 2nd/42pts*....

Red River ...... 2nd/16pts.... 1st/33pts*.... 3rd/39pts*....

Dirty Little Billy ...... 7th/11pts .... 4th/28pts... 3rd/39pts*....

Meek’s Cutoff ...... 3rd/15pts.... 5th/21pts .... 4th/35pts....

Bone Tomahawk ...... 5th/13pts.... 3rd/29pts .... 5th/32pts....

The Scalphunters ...... 8th/6pts ..... 6th/11pts .... 6th/14pts....


* TIES

THANK YOU CR!!!

though awhell nominated Red River, McCabe was his First Place Vote

My List
The Grey Fox
The Big Gundown
Red River
Dirty Little Billy
Bone Tomahawk
McCabe & Mrs. Miller
The Scalphunters
Meek's Cutoff

Well then...better luck next time Ahwell

And Congrats to John Connor!

My voting list

1 Meek's Cutoff (2010)
2 Red River (1948)
3 Dirty Little Billy (1972)
4 McCabe & Mrs. Miller (1971)
5 The Grey Fox (1982)
6 The Scalphunters (1968)
7 The Big Gundown (1966)
8 Bone Tomahawk (2015)

Really happy with the results. Was hoping The Grey Fox would win, but McCabe and Mrs Miller was decent. I need to rewatch that.
I voted Scalphunters, my pick, last. Didn’t like the acting outside of the two mains. Felt they could have made it more serious.
Really enjoyed The Big Gundown and was happy with how high it placed.
All around a decent HOF guys. Thanks again, Ed for hosting.*
Looking forward to the next one

Definitely some great gems in here, Billy, Grey and Big Gundown were the biggest surprises for me as far as enjoyment went.