Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

Sherlock Jr was #3 for me. Made me realized just how much of his work I've foolishly gone without watching all my life.

__________________
What I actually said to win MovieGal's heart:
- I might not be a real King of Kinkiness, but I make good pancakes

~Mr Minio

No I just really liked this Hall...


Sherlock Jr...first one that placed right where I had it

yeah, some great films in this HoF - totally agree

I loved The Kid, Chaplin is great as an actor, director and writer. It wasn't my number one but that's only because we had such great films in this HoF.

Cool another one I voted high. Had the Kid at 4. Which means the next two are my 1 and 2, so I’m real happy.

Place your bets which film is #2 and which is #1

This SHOULD have been #3 but since I've missed out on Keaton my entire life, I put my all time favorite silent comedian one step below at #4.

#2 Pandora
#1 Metropolis

which is actually how I placed them

Doesn’t matter to me , I loved both, but I think metropolis will take it.

I really want to see The Kid again. I gave it 7/10 but I think I underrated it.

Nice my blind nom won haha

Good stuff folks and thank you guys, you rock

Congrats to one awesome silent film....Metropolis...which is the official inductee of the 1930s HoF Part 1.

VERY NICE!!!!

CONGRATS to Ahwell for the win. Definitely a powerhouse that will probably score in the top 3 of the Countdown easily.

And BRAVO CR for making Hosting a true art form!

My List
1) Metropolis
Pandora's Box
Sherlock Jr
The Kid
The Man Who Laughs
Lucky Star
Sadie Thompson
Faust
The Unknown
10) Marianne

Here's my list, and yes my own nom is last, and Lucky Star almost was my #1. But any of my top 7 would've been fine with me as winning. Marianne was the only film I didn't like. Faust I appreciated but wasn't into. Sadie Thompson I think, would have been pretty good with the lost ending found.

1 Metropolis
2 Lucky Star
3 The Kid
4 Pandora's Box
5 The Unknown
6 Sherlock Jr.
7 The Man Who Laughs
8 Sadie Thompson
9 Faust
10 Marianne

Thanks for hosting CR a very fun HoF.

Nice choices on your noms, Ahwell! It was great to finally see the fully restored Metropolis.