This is how everything went down. The Ascent gained the lead right away and kept it through the first seven lists, Little Women got the lead after the eighth then We Need To Talk About Kevin after the ninth before The Ascent regained it with the final list. We didn't agree on much as you say everything was all over the place. The only position that stayed the same was The Last Supper in last place.
2 Lists (Camo + Cricket)
01. The Ascent - 16 Points (1x4th, 1x2nd)
02. We Need To Talk About Kevin - 15 Points (1x1st, 1x6th)
Nothing Bad Can Happen - 15 Points (1x2nd, 1x5th)
Morvern Callar - 15 Points (1x1st, 1x6th)
05. Europa Europa - 12 Points (1x3rd, 1x7th)
06. Little Women - 10 Points (1x4th, 1x8th)
Orlando - 10 Points (1x3rd, 1x9th)
08. Take This Waltz - 8 Points (1x5th, 1x9th)
09. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 7 Points (1x7th, 1x8th)
10. The Last Supper - 2 Points (2x10th)
3 Lists (Citizen Rules Added)
01. The Ascent - 23 Points (1x2nd, 2x4th)
02. Europa Europa - 20 Points (2x3rd, 1x7th)
Little Women - 20 Points (1x1st, 1x4th, 1x8th)
04. Morvern Callar - 19 Points (1x1st, 1x6th, 1x7th)
05. Nothing Bad Can Happen - 17 Points (1x2nd, 1x5th, 1x9th)
06. Orlando - 16 Points (1x3rd, 1x5th, 1x9th)
A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 16 Points (1x2nd, 1x7th, 1x8th)
We Need To Talk About Kevin - 16 Points (1x1st, 1x6th, 1x10th)
09. Take This Waltz - 11 Points (1x5th, 1x8th, 1x9th)
10. The Last Supper - 7 Points (1x6th, 2x10th)
4 Lists (Sean C Added)
01. The Ascent - 33 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 2x4th)
02. Europa Europa - 26 Points (2x3rd, 1x5th, 1x7th)
Morvern Callar - 26 Points (1x1st, 1x4th, 1x6th, 1x7th)
04. We Need To Talk About Kevin - 25 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x6th, 1x10th)
Little Women - 25 Points (1x1st, 1x4th, 1x6th, 1x8th)
06. Nothing Bad Can Happen - 20 Points (1x2nd, 1x5th, 1x8th, 1x9th)
A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 20 Points (1x2nd, 2x7th, 1x8th)
08. Take This Waltz - 19 Points (1x3rd, 1x5th, 1x8th, 1x9th)
09. Orlando - 18 Points (1x3rd, 1x5th, 2x9th)
10. The Last Supper - 8 Points (1x6th, 3x10th)
5 Lists (Siddon Added)
01. The Ascent - 37 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 2x4th, 1x7th)
02. We Need To Talk About Kevin - 35 Points (2x1st, 1x2nd, 1x6th, 1x10th)
03. Little Women - 34 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x4th, 1x6th, 1x8th)
04. Europa Europa - 31 Points (2x3rd, 1x5th, 1x6th, 1x7th)
05. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 28 Points (1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x7th, 1x8th)
06. Morvern Callar - 27 Points (1x1st, 1x4th, 1x6th, 1x7th, 1x10th)
07. Nothing Bad Can Happen - 26 Points (1x2nd, 2x5th, 1x8th, 1x9th)
08. Take This Waltz - 21 Points (1x3rd, 1x5th, 1x8th, 2x9th)
Orlando - 21 Points (1x3rd, 1x5th, 1x8th, 2x9th)
10. The Last Supper - 15 Points (1x4th, 1x6th, 3x10th)
6 Lists (Thursday Next Added)
01. The Ascent - 45 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 1x7th)
02. Little Women - 41 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 2x4th, 1x6th, 1x8th)
Europa Europa - 41 Points (1x1st, 2x3rd, 1x5th, 1x6th, 1x7th)
04. We Need To Talk About Kevin - 38 Points (2x1st, 1x2nd, 1x6th, 1x8th, 1x10th)
05. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 37 Points (2x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x7th, 1x8th)
06. Morvern Callar - 32 Points (1x1st, 1x4th, 2x6th, 1x7th, 1x10th)
07. Nothing Bad Can Happen - 28 Points (1x2nd, 2x5th, 1x8th, 2x9th)
08. Orlando - 27 Points (1x3rd, 2x5th, 1x8th, 2x9th)
09. Take This Waltz - 25 Points (1x3rd, 1x5th, 1x7th, 1x8th, 2x9th)
10. The Last Supper - 16 Points (1x4th, 1x6th, 4x10th)
7 Lists (edarsenal Added)
01. The Ascent - 51 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 1x6th, 1x7th)
02. Little Women - 49 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 1x6th, 1x8th)
03. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 47 Points (1x1st, 2x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x7th, 1x8th)
04. Europa Europa - 46 Points (1x1st, 2x3rd, 1x5th, 2x6th, 1x7th)
05. Morvern Callar - 41 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x4th, 2x6th, 1x7th, 1x10th)
We Need To Talk About Kevin - 41 Points (2x1st, 1x2nd, 1x6th, 2x8th, 1x10th)
07. Orlando - 34 Points (1x3rd, 1x4th, 2x5th, 1x8th, 2x9th)
08. Nothing Bad Can Happen - 29 Points (1x2nd, 2x5th, 1x8th, 2x9th, 1x10th)
09. Take This Waltz - 27 Points (1x3rd, 1x5th, 1x7th, 1x8th, 3x9th)
10. The Last Supper - 20 Points (1x4th, 1x6th, 1x7th, 4x10th)
8 Lists (Hashtag Added)
01. Little Women - 54 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 2x6th, 1x8th)
02. The Ascent - 52 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 1x6th, 1x7th, 1x10th)
03. We Need To Talk About Kevin - 51 Points (3x1st, 1x2nd, 1x6th, 2x8th, 1x10th)
04. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 49 Points (1x1st, 2x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x7th, 1x8th, 1x9th)
Europa Europa - 49 Points (1x1st, 2x3rd, 1x5th, 2x6th, 1x7th, 1x8th)
06. Morvern Callar - 45 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x4th, 2x6th, 2x7th, 1x10th)
07. Orlando - 40 Points (1x3rd, 1x4th, 3x5th, 1x8th, 2x9th)
08. Nothing Bad Can Happen - 38 Points (2x2nd, 2x5th, 1x8th, 2x9th, 1x10th)
09. Take This Waltz - 34 Points (1x3rd, 1x4th, 1x5th, 1x7th, 1x8th, 3x9th)
10. The Last Supper - 28 Points (1x3rd, 1x4th, 1x6th, 1x7th, 4x10th)
9 Lists (JJ Added)
01. We Need To Talk About Kevin - 60 Points (3x1st, 2x2nd, 1x6th, 2x8th, 1x10th)
02. Little Women - 59 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 3x6th, 1x8th)
Europa Europa - 59 Points (2x1st, 2x3rd, 1x5th, 2x6th, 1x7th, 1x8th)
04. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 56 Points (1x1st, 2x2nd, 1x3rd, 1x4th, 2x7th, 1x8th, 1x9th)
The Ascent - 56 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 1x5th, 2x7th, 1x10th)
06. Morvern Callar - 51 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x4th, 1x5th, 2x6th, 2x7th, 1x10th)
07. Orlando - 42 Points (1x3rd, 1x4th, 3x5th, 1x8th, 3x9th)
Take This Waltz - 42 Points (2x3rd, 1x4th, 1x5th, 1x7th, 1x8th, 3x9th)
09. Nothing Bad Can Happen - 41 Points (2x2nd, 2x5th, 2x8th, 2x9th, 1x10th)
10. The Last Supper - 29 Points (1x3rd, 1x4th, 1x6th, 1x7th, 5x10th)
Final List (Jal Added)
01. The Ascent - 66 Points (2x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 1x5th, 2x7th, 1x10th)
02. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 63 Points (1x1st, 2x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 2x7th, 1x8th, 1x9th)
Europa Europa - 63 Points (2x1st, 2x3rd, 1x5th, 2x6th, 2x7th, 1x8th)
We Need To Talk About Kevin - 63 Points (3x1st, 2x2nd, 1x6th, 3x8th, 1x10th)
05. Little Women - 61 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 3x6th, 1x8th, 1x9th)
06. Morvern Callar - 59 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 1x4th, 1x5th, 2x6th, 2x7th, 1x10th)
07. Orlando - 51 Points (1x2nd, 1x3rd, 1x4th, 3x5th, 1x8th, 3x9th)
08. Take This Waltz - 47 Points (2x3rd, 1x4th, 1x5th, 1x6th, 1x7th, 1x8th, 3x9th)
09. Nothing Bad Can Happen - 42 Points (2x2nd, 2x5th, 2x8th, 2x9th, 2x10th)
10. The Last Supper - 35 Points (1x3rd, 1x4th, 1x5th, 1x6th, 1x7th, 5x10th)
2 Lists (Camo + Cricket)
01. The Ascent - 16 Points (1x4th, 1x2nd)
02. We Need To Talk About Kevin - 15 Points (1x1st, 1x6th)
Nothing Bad Can Happen - 15 Points (1x2nd, 1x5th)
Morvern Callar - 15 Points (1x1st, 1x6th)
05. Europa Europa - 12 Points (1x3rd, 1x7th)
06. Little Women - 10 Points (1x4th, 1x8th)
Orlando - 10 Points (1x3rd, 1x9th)
08. Take This Waltz - 8 Points (1x5th, 1x9th)
09. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 7 Points (1x7th, 1x8th)
10. The Last Supper - 2 Points (2x10th)
3 Lists (Citizen Rules Added)
01. The Ascent - 23 Points (1x2nd, 2x4th)
02. Europa Europa - 20 Points (2x3rd, 1x7th)
Little Women - 20 Points (1x1st, 1x4th, 1x8th)
04. Morvern Callar - 19 Points (1x1st, 1x6th, 1x7th)
05. Nothing Bad Can Happen - 17 Points (1x2nd, 1x5th, 1x9th)
06. Orlando - 16 Points (1x3rd, 1x5th, 1x9th)
A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 16 Points (1x2nd, 1x7th, 1x8th)
We Need To Talk About Kevin - 16 Points (1x1st, 1x6th, 1x10th)
09. Take This Waltz - 11 Points (1x5th, 1x8th, 1x9th)
10. The Last Supper - 7 Points (1x6th, 2x10th)
4 Lists (Sean C Added)
01. The Ascent - 33 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 2x4th)
02. Europa Europa - 26 Points (2x3rd, 1x5th, 1x7th)
Morvern Callar - 26 Points (1x1st, 1x4th, 1x6th, 1x7th)
04. We Need To Talk About Kevin - 25 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x6th, 1x10th)
Little Women - 25 Points (1x1st, 1x4th, 1x6th, 1x8th)
06. Nothing Bad Can Happen - 20 Points (1x2nd, 1x5th, 1x8th, 1x9th)
A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 20 Points (1x2nd, 2x7th, 1x8th)
08. Take This Waltz - 19 Points (1x3rd, 1x5th, 1x8th, 1x9th)
09. Orlando - 18 Points (1x3rd, 1x5th, 2x9th)
10. The Last Supper - 8 Points (1x6th, 3x10th)
5 Lists (Siddon Added)
01. The Ascent - 37 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 2x4th, 1x7th)
02. We Need To Talk About Kevin - 35 Points (2x1st, 1x2nd, 1x6th, 1x10th)
03. Little Women - 34 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x4th, 1x6th, 1x8th)
04. Europa Europa - 31 Points (2x3rd, 1x5th, 1x6th, 1x7th)
05. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 28 Points (1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x7th, 1x8th)
06. Morvern Callar - 27 Points (1x1st, 1x4th, 1x6th, 1x7th, 1x10th)
07. Nothing Bad Can Happen - 26 Points (1x2nd, 2x5th, 1x8th, 1x9th)
08. Take This Waltz - 21 Points (1x3rd, 1x5th, 1x8th, 2x9th)
Orlando - 21 Points (1x3rd, 1x5th, 1x8th, 2x9th)
10. The Last Supper - 15 Points (1x4th, 1x6th, 3x10th)
6 Lists (Thursday Next Added)
01. The Ascent - 45 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 1x7th)
02. Little Women - 41 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 2x4th, 1x6th, 1x8th)
Europa Europa - 41 Points (1x1st, 2x3rd, 1x5th, 1x6th, 1x7th)
04. We Need To Talk About Kevin - 38 Points (2x1st, 1x2nd, 1x6th, 1x8th, 1x10th)
05. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 37 Points (2x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x7th, 1x8th)
06. Morvern Callar - 32 Points (1x1st, 1x4th, 2x6th, 1x7th, 1x10th)
07. Nothing Bad Can Happen - 28 Points (1x2nd, 2x5th, 1x8th, 2x9th)
08. Orlando - 27 Points (1x3rd, 2x5th, 1x8th, 2x9th)
09. Take This Waltz - 25 Points (1x3rd, 1x5th, 1x7th, 1x8th, 2x9th)
10. The Last Supper - 16 Points (1x4th, 1x6th, 4x10th)
7 Lists (edarsenal Added)
01. The Ascent - 51 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 1x6th, 1x7th)
02. Little Women - 49 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 1x6th, 1x8th)
03. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 47 Points (1x1st, 2x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x7th, 1x8th)
04. Europa Europa - 46 Points (1x1st, 2x3rd, 1x5th, 2x6th, 1x7th)
05. Morvern Callar - 41 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x4th, 2x6th, 1x7th, 1x10th)
We Need To Talk About Kevin - 41 Points (2x1st, 1x2nd, 1x6th, 2x8th, 1x10th)
07. Orlando - 34 Points (1x3rd, 1x4th, 2x5th, 1x8th, 2x9th)
08. Nothing Bad Can Happen - 29 Points (1x2nd, 2x5th, 1x8th, 2x9th, 1x10th)
09. Take This Waltz - 27 Points (1x3rd, 1x5th, 1x7th, 1x8th, 3x9th)
10. The Last Supper - 20 Points (1x4th, 1x6th, 1x7th, 4x10th)
8 Lists (Hashtag Added)
01. Little Women - 54 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 2x6th, 1x8th)
02. The Ascent - 52 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 1x6th, 1x7th, 1x10th)
03. We Need To Talk About Kevin - 51 Points (3x1st, 1x2nd, 1x6th, 2x8th, 1x10th)
04. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 49 Points (1x1st, 2x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x7th, 1x8th, 1x9th)
Europa Europa - 49 Points (1x1st, 2x3rd, 1x5th, 2x6th, 1x7th, 1x8th)
06. Morvern Callar - 45 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x4th, 2x6th, 2x7th, 1x10th)
07. Orlando - 40 Points (1x3rd, 1x4th, 3x5th, 1x8th, 2x9th)
08. Nothing Bad Can Happen - 38 Points (2x2nd, 2x5th, 1x8th, 2x9th, 1x10th)
09. Take This Waltz - 34 Points (1x3rd, 1x4th, 1x5th, 1x7th, 1x8th, 3x9th)
10. The Last Supper - 28 Points (1x3rd, 1x4th, 1x6th, 1x7th, 4x10th)
9 Lists (JJ Added)
01. We Need To Talk About Kevin - 60 Points (3x1st, 2x2nd, 1x6th, 2x8th, 1x10th)
02. Little Women - 59 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 3x6th, 1x8th)
Europa Europa - 59 Points (2x1st, 2x3rd, 1x5th, 2x6th, 1x7th, 1x8th)
04. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 56 Points (1x1st, 2x2nd, 1x3rd, 1x4th, 2x7th, 1x8th, 1x9th)
The Ascent - 56 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 1x5th, 2x7th, 1x10th)
06. Morvern Callar - 51 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x4th, 1x5th, 2x6th, 2x7th, 1x10th)
07. Orlando - 42 Points (1x3rd, 1x4th, 3x5th, 1x8th, 3x9th)
Take This Waltz - 42 Points (2x3rd, 1x4th, 1x5th, 1x7th, 1x8th, 3x9th)
09. Nothing Bad Can Happen - 41 Points (2x2nd, 2x5th, 2x8th, 2x9th, 1x10th)
10. The Last Supper - 29 Points (1x3rd, 1x4th, 1x6th, 1x7th, 5x10th)
Final List (Jal Added)
01. The Ascent - 66 Points (2x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 1x5th, 2x7th, 1x10th)
02. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night - 63 Points (1x1st, 2x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 2x7th, 1x8th, 1x9th)
Europa Europa - 63 Points (2x1st, 2x3rd, 1x5th, 2x6th, 2x7th, 1x8th)
We Need To Talk About Kevin - 63 Points (3x1st, 2x2nd, 1x6th, 3x8th, 1x10th)
05. Little Women - 61 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 2x4th, 3x6th, 1x8th, 1x9th)
06. Morvern Callar - 59 Points (1x1st, 1x2nd, 1x3rd, 1x4th, 1x5th, 2x6th, 2x7th, 1x10th)
07. Orlando - 51 Points (1x2nd, 1x3rd, 1x4th, 3x5th, 1x8th, 3x9th)
08. Take This Waltz - 47 Points (2x3rd, 1x4th, 1x5th, 1x6th, 1x7th, 1x8th, 3x9th)
09. Nothing Bad Can Happen - 42 Points (2x2nd, 2x5th, 2x8th, 2x9th, 2x10th)
10. The Last Supper - 35 Points (1x3rd, 1x4th, 1x5th, 1x6th, 1x7th, 5x10th)