
A Haunting in Venice, 2023
An alienated Poirot (Kenneth Branagh) is keeping very much to himself, but he is lured out by old friend Ariadne (Tina Fey) to attend a seance in the home of famous opera singer Rowena (Kelly Reilly). Ariadne wants to debunk the veracity of medium Joyce (Michelle Yeoh). But as the evening goes on, someone begins to enact a deadly agenda.
Satisfying neither as a mystery nor a supernatural thriller, this is movie features a great cast all dressed up and with nowhere to go.
It’s fun writing about a movie I love, and there’s even some emotional fuel in writing about a movie I dislike. But what to say about a movie like this one?
Agatha Christie wrote a lot of strong mysteries, but as many film adaptations have shown, it is possible to create bad movies from them. (Though this film is apparently just loosely based on one of her novels).
Where to even begin? I didn’t hate the overall premise, which has to do with the semi-recent death of Rowena’s daughter under tragic circumstances. I will concede that once it’s all said and done, I appreciated some of the elements of the overall mystery.
But getting there? Woof. The movie is dark and muted. I didn’t like the way that I struggled with the overall geography of the large house. I wasn’t gripped by any of the characters, and I found the gestures at the supernatural annoying. Mostly I was frustrated by the sheer number of contrived character actions and choices just to put characters in the correct physical locations for different things to happen.
I felt, ultimately, really empty watching this movie. I found myself thinking things like “Michelle Yeoh sure is pretty.” “Jamie Dornan looks nice in that outfit.” “I wonder how long it took Branagh to grow that mustache.” And so on.
A decent way to pass the time, but not much more.