Movie Forums (http://www.movieforums.com/community/index.php)
-   Ongoing Tournaments & Brackets (http://www.movieforums.com/community/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   A Song For October (http://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?t=62413)

Chypmunk 09-25-20 01:00 PM

A Song For October
 
Same as was done in previous tournaments of this type.....
  • Join in and drop out as you please
  • No set number of nominations, nominate on the fly
  • Max song duration: 10 minutes
  • No individual matches means no random or host 'fixing' the matches
  • Only one nomination per person per 'round'
  • Only those with songs nominated in any 'round' are eligible to vote; except the 'Final' where all those that have previously nominated a song in the month may vote should they wish

Every couple of days will be a new 'round' where any and all newly nominated songs are up against each other. As soon as voting starts for one 'round' nominations will be accepted for the next 'round'.

Players vote by ranking all the songs in that 'round' from 1 (their favourite) to n (their least favourite). Songs will be awarded points based on their positional ranking in each vote (number of points will depend on the number of songs contesting the 'round' - if 10 songs #1 song would get 10 points, #10 song would get 1 point).

The winning song from each 'round' (or songs in the case of a tie) goes through to the 'Final' at the end of the month.

Songs that made it to previous 'finals' are ineligible -
list here  


Simples but if any relevant questions just ask.

Chypmunk 09-25-20 01:01 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
Thread up plenty early so @Yoda can perhaps clear a little space in his diary for a round or three of this.....

Chypmunk 09-25-20 01:03 PM

Nominations for Round 1 welcome - open until 9am IST/BST on October 1st.

Mine:
O Children - Ruins

pahaK 09-25-20 06:26 PM

Originally Posted by Chypmunk (Post 2127233)
[*]Max song duration: 10 minutes
There's a song I've wanted to nominate multiple times but it's annoyingly 10:11 long so it barely fails the rules check :D

gbgoodies 09-26-20 03:07 AM

I've been busy, so I may be in and out during the month, but I'm in for Round 1. :)

Joe Cocker - Edge Of A Dream

Chypmunk 09-26-20 03:29 AM

Originally Posted by pahaK (Post 2127325)
There's a song I've wanted to nominate multiple times but it's annoyingly 10:11 long so it barely fails the rules check :D
Ok, next one I do will have a special eleven minute time limit as a one-off. You may well have to remind me though ;)

HollowMan 09-28-20 06:29 PM

I'm in. Round 1 nomination:


Fleetwood Mac - The Chain.


https://youtu.be/xwTPvcPYaOo

Yoda 09-28-20 09:10 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
Sorry for the delay! Yeah, I think I can manage, if someone can give me a capsule summary of how this works/what's required of me and all that.

gbgoodies 09-28-20 11:41 PM

Originally Posted by Yoda (Post 2127891)
Sorry for the delay! Yeah, I think I can manage, if someone can give me a capsule summary of how this works/what's required of me and all that.

Basically, each person who joins nominates one song per round. (The nominated song can't be a previous tournament winner, (listed in the first post of this thread), and it can't be longer than 10 minutes.)

When the nominations for the round close, the host (@Chypmunk;) posts all of the nominations.

Everyone who joined listens to all of the nominations, and ranks them in order from their favorite to their least favorite. (We post our lists in the thread.)

While waiting for everyone to vote, anyone who wants to join the next round, posts their nomination for the next round.

Then the host calculates the results and announces the winner of the round.

The host then posts the next round, and we continue with rounds until the end of the month. (You can join as many or as few rounds as you want, but you can only vote in the rounds that you nominate a song, and in the final round if you've nominated a song in any round of the tournament.)

The last round is all of this tournament's rounds winners. We rank these songs, and then the tournament winner is announced.

Then we all wait patiently for the next tournament. :)

Chypmunk 09-29-20 04:47 AM

Re: A Song For October
 
Thanks gbg!

Yoda 09-29-20 11:04 AM

Re: A Song For October
 
So, to start, I literally just pick one song, any song, and post it here? No theme or anything, just anything I either like or (probably better) think others might like?

Chypmunk 09-29-20 11:10 AM

Originally Posted by Yoda (Post 2128000)
So, to start, I literally just pick one song, any song, and post it here?
Yep, post it at any point before 9am IST/BST (that's 4am Eastern Time I believe) on 1st October and it'll be entered into Round 1. Preferably in an external link format (like gbg and I have) if you can, if not just imbed the video and I'll format the link (like I do for HM).

No theme or anything, just anything I either like or (probably better) think others might like?
If you want to theme your own songs then feel free to do so (honeykid has done this in the past) but that's entirely optional and there's no overall theme. The only limitation is no song can be over ten minutes in duration.

Yoda 09-29-20 12:02 PM

"Doesn't Matter" - Christine and the Queens

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=UCwD5f1APTY

Captain Spaulding 09-29-20 06:05 PM

Round 1 nom:
Girlschool - Race with the Devil


And tagging past participants who might be interested in playing but just haven't seen the thread: @jiraffejustin; @cat_sidhe; @honeykid; @Derek Vinyard; @Sedai; @John-Connor; @resopamenic; @CaptainT; @HashtagBrownies; @ynwtf; @Nostromo87; @edarsenal; @ahwell

ynwtf 09-29-20 06:25 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
October 1, eh? So I get another work day to waste wondering what of the three songs I've already posted in every tournament that won't win, to post! I may be game again.

RealHero 09-29-20 06:36 PM

ok, let's join for funz and do aesthetics and stuff. Put a needle in Your eardrum fast.

Aseul - Fisher

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VnY5pnbLJF0
uwu

Derek Vinyard 09-29-20 09:23 PM

I’ll join!!

gbgoodies 09-30-20 01:29 AM

Originally Posted by Chypmunk (Post 2127943)
Thanks gbg!

You're welcome. :)

Chypmunk 09-30-20 07:58 AM

Re: A Song For October
 
Nominations still accepted for Round 1 for the next 21 hours if anyone else wishes to join in....

resopamenic 09-30-20 08:56 AM

Re: A Song For October
 
okidoki, count me in

toconoma - relive

ynwtf 09-30-20 11:57 AM

Thanks, @Captain Spaulding for the reference. I miss everything.

So I've thought long and hard on the the subject of what tracks to sacrifice up to the MOFO music gawds that are never pleased with my offerings. This month? I say screw it. I'll throw my own themed party this time around, and the celebration is a selection of soundtracks from the 80s. Right out of the gate, Real Life...

https://media1.tenor.com/images/84c5...affd/tenor.gif

Inspired by a recently watched (and fondly remembered) B-movie story of a local, small town boy fighting all odds against big corporation and sellout commercialism in the form of BMX freestyle, I nominate Real Life - Send me an Angel, from the 1986 movie, Rad. This movie taught me that I will never be coordinated enough to even pull off a wheelie, or have enough money to buy a BMX with pegs or proper rotor. This song and music sequence within the movie taught me of love, the lengths one must go to earn it, and the devastating cold reality of heartache and loss when Cru races off into the night before Christian is able to push through the student crowd to ask his name. Lori Loughlin? I never cared that you bribed you kid's way into college. I still love you.

honeykid 09-30-20 12:16 PM

Dusty Springfield - Spooky

Sedai 09-30-20 12:27 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
Toto - Rosanna

pahaK 09-30-20 12:36 PM

Let's do this. No noisy blowers in the apartment before next week so I can actually listen to these. No promises I'll do every round.

R1 nomination:
PANZERFAUST - The Faustian Pact

ynwtf 09-30-20 02:38 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
By all rights, Bowie probably should have been my first nom. I must admit that I did consider a track-by-track submission of the Labyrinth soundtrack album. I thought better of it, on reconsideration, as that would have been unfair to all other noms and would have most certainly defeated the purpose of the competition.

Derek Vinyard 09-30-20 04:08 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
The Mooney Suzuki - Alive & Amplified

I'm innnn

jiraffejustin 10-01-20 04:50 AM

Re: A Song For October
 
John Anderson - Seminole Wind

If this one is blocked for anybody, I guess any alternative is fine. This one is just much better quality than most of the others, so I wanted those who could listen to it to have the best quality possible.

I just nominated the song that's been stuck in my head for the past three weeks.

Chypmunk 10-01-20 05:01 AM

Re: A Song For October
 
Nominations closed - round 1 up shortly.

Chypmunk 10-01-20 05:11 AM


Chypmunk 10-01-20 05:30 AM

For anyone working with "www" type song links (as opposed to the "youtu.be" variety) that doesn't know how to make a song link external (rather than imbedding the video):
External linking is easy:
  1. Copy the url of the song link you want (it has to be a free to access link - most of the time players tend to use YouTube)
  2. Type the text of the song or whatever in a response ... i.e. "The Beatles - In My Life"
  3. Highlight the text
  4. In the list of optional actions at the top of the response box (where italics, bold, underline etc. are) click the picture of a globe with 2 links of a chain underneath it
  5. In the box that comes up paste the url you copied earlier
  6. Edit the "www" in the link to "m"
  7. Click ok and it will wrap the HTML for the link around the text and that's it

You can verify it looks right and even that they work by previewing the post.

For example here's the one for The Beatles - In My Life
I'd appreciate if those using "www" type links would try to do the above as it just makes it that little bit easier for the lazy dog that is otherwise known as myself ;)

Thanks,
Chyp

Chypmunk 10-01-20 06:59 AM

Here are the results of the 'lazy dog' jury......

  1. O. Children - Ruins
    Underappreciated goth gem imo
  2. Dusty Springfield - Spooky
    Classic choon - looks like hk might be theming again this time around
  3. Fleetwood Mac - The Chain
    Big F1 fan here
  4. PANZERFAUST - The Faustian Pact
    Well suited to my mood today
  5. The Mooney Suzuki - Alive & Amplified
    A welcome burst of energy as I'm feeling about as energetic as a week-old fart in a bath today
  6. John Anderson - Seminole Wind
    Don't think I've ever listened to any of his before, quite liked it
  7. Doesn't Matter - Christine and the Queens
    Usual decent hooks from a group I quite like
  8. Girlschool - Race with the Devil
    One of the better tunes in their armoury (saw them live back in the day)
  9. Real Life - Send me an Angel
    Easily the best song Yin has entered into this tourney thus far
  10. toconoma - relive
    Grew on me the more it went on
  11. Joe Cocker - Edge Of A Dream
    Usual easy listen from Joe
  12. Aseul - Fisher
    Quite liked it, easy listen
  13. Toto - Rosanna
    Not being 'Africa' worked to its advantage but it's still Toto

Being down the list doesn't necessarily mean I didn't like it ..... quite a strong round imo.

honeykid 10-01-20 08:25 AM

Dusty Springfield - Spooky - Yes, I'm theming again. Obvious from the start this time. :D

The Mooney Suzuki - Alive & Amplified - It's a nice pastiche? Affectionate tribute? I don't know, but I like it.

Girlschool - Race with the Devil - Quality from a band which doesn't get listened to as often as it should.

toconoma - relive - A minute in and I'm liking this. If it doesn't outstay its welcome expect to see this nearer the top than the bottom.

Real Life - Send me an Angel - 80's euro pop stylee? Yes please.

Fleetwood Mac - The Chain - For a UK F1 fan, this is always going to do well. Unless I find lots of new songs I really like here I can't see this not doing well for me this round.

Toto - Rosanna - Classic. But suffers when it's not the chorus.

O. Children - Ruins - Very 80's goth. Not exactly my thing, but not bad.

Doesn't Matter - Christine and the Queens - This is pretty pleasant.

Joe Cocker - Edge Of A Dream - It's Joe Cocker. It sounds like Joe Cocker. It's ok and that's about it really.

Aseul - Fisher - On another day I think this would've done better with me. Today is not that day though.

John Anderson - Seminole Wind § (alt vsn if needed) - At least it's not last. Though that may upset you. :D

PANZERFAUST - The Faustian Pact - Too much too long today.

pahaK 10-01-20 11:03 AM

Re: A Song For October
 
01: PANZERFAUST - The Faustian Pact
02: O Children - Ruins
03: Girlschool - Race with the Devil
04: Real Life - Send me an Angel
05: Dusty Springfield - Spooky
06: John Anderson - Seminole Wind
07: Fleetwood Mac - The Chain
08: Joe Cocker - Edge Of A Dream
09: toconoma - relive
10: The Mooney Suzuki - Alive & Amplified
11: Toto - Rosanna
12: Christine and the Queens - Doesn't matter
13: ASEUL - FISHER

Chypmunk 10-01-20 11:12 AM

Re: A Song For October
 
My R2 nom:
Sadistik - Cotard's Syndrome

pahaK 10-01-20 11:24 AM

I'll try to keep my usual mix so only every other song should be metal...

R2 nomination:
Lonesome Wyatt and the Holy Spooks - Waiting for the End

resopamenic 10-01-20 01:00 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
1 Dusty Springfield - Spooky
2 toconoma - relive
3 O Children - Ruins
4 PANZERFAUST - The Faustian Pact
5 The Mooney Suzuki - Alive & Amplified
For a band that has two former vocalists of CAN by the name, I expect it to give something more rather than a standard hard rock sound.
6 Toto - Rosanna
7 Fleetwood Mac - The Chain
8 Christine and the Queens - Doesn't matter
9 John Anderson - Seminole Wind
10 Girlschool - Race with the Devil
11 Joe Cocker - Edge Of A Dream
12 ASEUL - FISHER
13 Real Life - Send me an Angel

resopamenic 10-01-20 01:11 PM

r2 nom
G-Schmitt - Cathedral Junky

RealHero 10-01-20 01:22 PM

Damn, these choices made me feel extremely GenZ.
1 O. Children - Ruins
2 Dusty Springfield - Spooky
3 Christine and the Queens - Doesn't matter
4 Fleetwood Mac - The Chain
5 Girlschool - Race With The Devil
6 toconoma - relive
7 Seminole Wind
8 Toto - Rosanna
9 Real Life - Send Me An Angel '89
10 Edge Of A Dream-Joe Cocker
11 PANZERFAUST - The Faustian Pact
12 The Mooney Suzuki - Alive & Amplified


round 2
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qn2L9M7kfHE

Chypmunk 10-01-20 01:27 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
@RealHero - you forgot to include a vote for your own song - I need you to rank all 13 songs for your R1 votes to count ;)

RealHero 10-01-20 01:36 PM

Originally Posted by Chypmunk (Post 2128585)
@RealHero - you forgot to include a vote for your own song - I need you to rank all 13 songs for your R1 votes to count ;)

ah well then don't pick my votes at the end. I won't vote my picks ;)

Chypmunk 10-01-20 01:40 PM

Originally Posted by RealHero (Post 2128587)
ah well then don't pick my votes at the end. I won't vote my picks ;)
Completely up to you but everybody else does and plenty of people don't automatically vote their own song as #1 in their ranking which is why I can't just assume where anyone would rank their own song.

RealHero 10-01-20 02:10 PM

Originally Posted by Chypmunk (Post 2128590)
Completely up to you but everybody else does and plenty of people don't automatically vote their own song as #1 in their ranking which is why I can't just assume where anyone would rank their own song.
ah then I put my own picks at last position.

Chypmunk 10-01-20 02:28 PM

Originally Posted by RealHero (Post 2128598)
ah then I put my own picks at last position.
Ok, I'll add in your votes for R1 in the spreadsheet with your own song in 13th on your ballot - please do include your own song in your rankings for future rounds for purposes of transparency though and don't feel you have to place them last in all future rounds should you have a change of heart with regards voting for your own songs.

pahaK 10-01-20 02:38 PM

Originally Posted by RealHero (Post 2128598)
ah then I put my own picks at last position.
Why? I'd assume you nominate songs you like so nothing wrong with having them at or near the top of your vote.

HollowMan 10-01-20 03:45 PM

1. Fleetwood Mac
2. Dusty Springfield
3. O Children
4. Joe Cocker
5. Christine and the Queens
6. Toto
7. John Anderson
8. Aseul
9. Toconoma
10. Girlschool
11. Real Life
12. The Mooney Suzuki
13. Panzerfaust

HollowMan 10-01-20 03:56 PM

Round 2 pick:


BB King - The Thrill is Gone



https://youtu.be/kpC69qIe02E

Derek Vinyard 10-01-20 09:25 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
The Mooney Suzuki - Alive & Amplified
Toto - Rosanna
O. Children - Ruins
Aseul - Fisher
Joe Cocker - Edge Of A Dream
Doesn't Matter - Christine and the Queens
Girlschool - Race with the Devil
Fleetwood Mac - The Chain
Real Life - Send me an Angel
PANZERFAUST - The Faustian Pact
toconoma - relive
John Anderson - Seminole Wind § (alt vsn if needed)
Dusty Springfield - Spooky

Derek Vinyard 10-01-20 09:28 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
nom 2: LIVE - Lightning Crashes

gbgoodies 10-02-20 02:54 AM

1) Dusty Springfield - Spooky
2) John Anderson - Seminole Wind
3) Joe Cocker - Edge Of A Dream
4) Toto - Rosanna
5) Doesn't Matter - Christine and the Queens
6) Fleetwood Mac - The Chain
7) Real Life - Send me an Angel
8) toconoma - relive
9) Aseul - Fisher
10) O. Children - Ruins
11) Girlschool - Race with the Devil
12) The Mooney Suzuki - Alive & Amplified
13) PANZERFAUST - The Faustian Pact

gbgoodies 10-02-20 03:56 AM

My Round 2 Nom:
Ricky Van Shelton - Somebody Lied

Chypmunk 10-02-20 04:46 AM

Still @Yoda, @Captain Spaulding, @ynwtf, @Sedai and @jiraffejustin to vote....

honeykid 10-02-20 08:16 AM

My Round 2 Nom:
Focus - Hocus Pocus

ynwtf 10-02-20 10:46 AM

Re: A Song For October
 
Will rank after work this evening.

Sedai 10-02-20 11:15 AM

1 Toto - Rosanna - Putting this is first to fly in the face of the Toto haters. Sure, they bring the cheese, but when you round up all the band members, including their work with other projects, they have over 200 Grammy nominations. Also, this song is great.

2 Real Life - Send me an Angel - Excellent 80s synth pop.

3 Dusty Springfield - Spooky - Can't rank this any lower. Great stuff.

4 O. Children - Ruins - Above average goth track. I like it!

5 Fleetwood Mac - The Chain - Classic, but a bit overplayed at this point.

6 Aseul - Fisher - Reminds me of old-skool Orbital, which reminds me of my rave days, which reminds me of simpler, care-free times.

7 PANZERFAUST - The Faustian Pact - Some nasty riffs in this tune, but I ike the vocal in the verses, but the song is a bit too noisy and chaotic for my taste. Still good, though.

8 Doesn't Matter - Christine and the Queens - This is a good round, as even this far down the list, I still like this song quite a bit.

9 Girlschool - Race with the Devil - Rockin tune!

10 The Mooney Suzuki - Alive & Amplified - Cool, if really derivative, song. Still, it's one of those 90s bands that was acting like they were a 70s band. Kind of gimmicky.

11 Toconoma - Relive - Kind of fun, but I wasn't feeling it.


12 John Anderson - Seminole Wind - I just can't get around the twangy sounds of some country, and this is definitely one of those songs. Can't do it.

13 Joe Cocker - Edge Of A Dream - But I would still rather listen to the above country song than this, which is straight up elevator music to me. Sorry! I like other Cocker songs, but not this one.

Sedai 10-02-20 11:19 AM

Re: A Song For October
 
Round 2 NOM

Obscura - Emergent Evolution

Another extreme metal track for folks to send to the bottom of their lists. At least it has pretty sections... ;)

Yoda 10-02-20 11:28 AM

Oh, we rank our own, too? I guess I can see that, though I'm pretty likely to rank my own really highly since I expect I'll usually be picking songs I already love. Maybe I'll mix it up with some weirder ones I don't love as much, then. Anyway!

  1. The Chain
  2. Doesn't Matter
  3. Seminole Wind
  4. Spooky
  5. Ruins
  6. relive
  7. Send Me An Angel '89
  8. Alive & Amplified
  9. Edge of a Dream
  10. Rosanna
  11. Race with the Devil
  12. The Faustian Pact
  13. Fisher

A little too distracted to do write-ups on each but maybe next time. I really liked "Seminole Wind" though, the strings in that are great. And I agree, this was great, I can't imagine it's normal that even the ones towards the bottom of the list would be enjoyable.

resopamenic 10-02-20 12:13 PM

Originally Posted by honeykid (Post 2128813)
My Round 2 Nom:
Focus - Hocus Pocus
you beat me to it HK. I considered proposing this hilarious song too xD

Chypmunk 10-02-20 01:23 PM

Originally Posted by Yoda (Post 2128841)
Oh, we rank our own, too? I guess I can see that, though I'm pretty likely to rank my own really highly since I expect I'll usually be picking songs I already love. Maybe I'll mix it up with some weirder ones I don't love as much, then.
Nominate whatever you fancy as long as it's under ten minutes long. It's nice that there's usually a variety of tastes involved in these so 'weirder' stuff can sometimes do quite well.

P.s. Don't forget the voting and nomination windows run concurrently so if you want to have a song in Round 2 you'll need to put one forward within the next 14 1/2 hours or so ;)

jiraffejustin 10-02-20 01:31 PM

1. John Anderson - Seminole Wind

2. Girlschool - Race with the Devil
- Never heard of these girls before, but I'm all the way in.

3. The Mooney Suzuki - Alive & Amplified
- This song was in some video game I used to play a long time ago, I just don't remember which one. It's a fun time.

4. Doesn't Matter - Christine and the Queens
- so this is what Yoda listens to.

5. Fleetwood Mac - The Chain
- I've never been able to get into Fleetwood Mac for whatever reason. I should try listening to Rumours again.

6. PANZERFAUST - The Faustian Pact
- Sometimes a problem with this type of music and vocals is that the music is so good that when they start doing their vocal stuff, it feels unnecessary. I'm still not sold on this style of vocals, so I was totally down to let that music ride before the fella piped in. It's also hilarious to read the lyrics, because they always say some silly stuff like "In a world of sin, of sh*t". I love the music, but do all these fellas have to be total edgelords?

7. Dusty Springfield - Spooky
- The lyrics seem kinda dumb, but I'm digging the vibe.

8. O. Children - Ruins
- This song reminds me of the "we have it at home meme". This is the we have Joy Division at home.

9. Aseul - Fisher
- Probably not for me, but pretty good for something not for me.

10. toconoma - relive
- Way too long. It has its moments, but I spent most of the time wanting it to end.

11. Toto - Rosanna
- Times were different.

12. Real Life - Send me an Angel
- Times were different.

13. Joe Cocker - Edge of a Dream
- Not big on Joe Cocker

Yoda 10-02-20 01:36 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
Alright, I'll pick another song today!

Yoda 10-02-20 01:36 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
Sorry in advance for all the pinging you'll have to do for me, I'm new and busy and forgetful.

Chypmunk 10-02-20 01:40 PM

Originally Posted by Yoda (Post 2128873)
Sorry in advance for all the pinging you'll have to do for me, I'm new and busy and forgetful.
Not a problem, I've taken to reminding whoever hasn't voted on Day 1 as a matter of course on Day 2 anyway. All you really have to remember is 'voting also means nominating' ;)

jiraffejustin 10-02-20 01:41 PM

Pusha T ft. Kendrick Lamar - Nosetalgia

Yoda 10-02-20 01:56 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
That's a good rule, vote and nominate at the same time. I didn't realize they were so close, but that makes sense.

Captain Spaulding 10-02-20 07:54 PM

Round 1

1. Girlschool - Race with the Devil
(Boasts one of those killer riffs that desperately makes me wish I could play guitar. Until recently, I was mostly only familiar with Girlschool through their associations with Motorhead, but I've been really digging their catalogue lately. Their sound is tougher than most all-girl rock groups.)

2. O. Children - Ruins
(Already knew within the first few seconds that I was going to dig this. One of the better goth tunes I've heard. Adding it to my playlist.)

3. Christine and the Queens - Doesn't Matter
(A really well constructed pop song, sonically and lyrically. Surprised by how much I enjoyed this.)

4. Fleetwood Mac - The Chain
(Since both my parents are big fans of Fleetwood, I probably heard too much of their music growing up to the point that I eventually tuned them out, but no doubt this is an all-time great song.)

5. Dusty Springfield - Spooky
(Such a sexy voice, and a seasonally appropriate nomination.)

6. Panzerfaust - The Faustian Pact
(Feels more accessible than most black metal, but it was so long that I had to deal with two separate ad breaks. WTF, YouTube? Don't you know it's extremely dangerous to interrupt a demonic incantation?)

7. John Anderson - Seminole Wind
(Hasn't Mr. Anderson received the memo? It's now "Washington Football Wind.")

8. Toto - Rosanna
(Somehow the cheesiness feels like an attribute instead of a detriment. I find it hard not to smile while listening to this song, though it does start to overstay its welcome a bit by the end.)

9. Toconoma - Relive
(Fun and danceable, but in the end it doesn't amount to more than a glorified jam session.)

10. Aseul - Fisher
(Perfect background music, which I guess is a bit of a back-handed compliment.)

11. Real Life - Send Me an Angel
(The chorus, particularly those soaring angelic background vocals, is what sinks this for me, which is strange since most of these 80's groups excelled at catchy choruses if nothing else.)

12. Joe Cocker - Edge of a Dream
(I like Cocker's voice for the most part, but this just sounds so dated and corny, like a slow-motion montage in a made-for-television 80's romance.)

13. The Mooney Suzuki - Alive & Amplified
(Sorta like listening to Greta Van Fleet when you could just listen to Led Zeppelin instead.)

Captain Spaulding 10-02-20 08:02 PM

Round 2 nom:
Tami Neilson - You Were Mine

jiraffejustin 10-02-20 09:29 PM

Originally Posted by Captain Spaulding (Post 2129025)
Round 1

7. John Anderson - Seminole Wind
(Hasn't Mr. Anderson received the memo? It's now "Washington Football Wind.")
This just in: John Anderson has apologized for his role in the song "Seminole Wind". The old, white, male singer claims that he's "deeply sorry" for "eliminating indigenous voices" and "voices of color". The alt-right singer also claims that he "wanted to bring attention to the plight of the Seminole peoples" but he "[realizes] now that [his/her] overzealousness to do so has caused more pain for the true and rightful owners of the Floridian lands". He will undergo racial justice training and a crucifixion to atone for the sins of his/her whiteness.


Originally Posted by Captain Spaulding (Post 2129025)
Round 1

13. The Mooney Suzuki - Alive & Amplified
(Sorta like listening to Greta Van Fleet when you could just listen to Led Zeppelin instead.)
All evidence supports the idea that this should be my thoughts on this song too, but I think the nostalgia of Madden 05 on my PS2 swayed me.

Yoda 10-02-20 09:45 PM

Round 2:

Foals - On the Luna

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hjuW7d7OZNE

ynwtf 10-03-20 02:13 AM

Round 1 (but technically, 1 is pretty straight. So. Iderno.)
  1. Dusty Springfield - Spooky
    Near perfect. Smokey smooth voice and equally smooth groove. That voice against the bass and driving electric piano can play forever and never dry out. The brass and sax give it just enough sexy without crossing a line, but we all know where those flirts go. Especially once the reverb kicks in. me-yeow.
  2. Real Life - Send me an Angel
    Well, obviously. Seriously, do none of you have beating hearts?! How could you have watched the movie Rad and NOT have cried during this scene?! Yes, I expect that you have all watched this movie as part of your agreements to participate in this Song of October list. *bows head in solemn respect and honor to the lis...* WTF people?! I know it’s not Bowie, but this should be higher up in your lists!! I’m looking at you, Spaulding. Well. I’m looking at your avatar. Not currently. I’m still typing this bit. BUT I WILL AFTER I POST THIS!!!! With stern eyes….. It’s not MY #1 because of my crush on Springfield’s voice. That and I’m too humble to place my nom first. This round.
  3. Doesn't Matter - Christine and the Queens
    Nice. Intro drum kick and claps remind me of The Ting Tings' That's Not My Name (just for a second or two, though), but the voice cut right through that association. I love this voice and synth bass that creeps in a bit later. Layers keep building, keeping interest up. If the movie, Drive, was just a BIT more upbeat (like 1/10th of whatever unit of measure defines upbeat), I would expect this on that alternate reality soundtrack. The lyrics are dark enough though. Pretty good track. I kinda think Doubledemin might dig this too. Isn't he into Drive/sountrack? I feel like he and I bonded over that Raised by Wolves season chat. That thread that you didn't take part in. After starting it.... *cough* (lol, in case that's not obvious)
  4. Aseul – Fisher
    A bit slow to get in, but I’m digging it. Lovely simple chord progression the vocals just whisper around. That note she sings and drops in “come on” (or whatever the lyrics are) is just a nice subtle dissonance to break the pattern of it all. On repeat now and I can hear that in the intro. That snare though! I keep wanting to hear it drop out into a drum-and-bass break.
  5. PANZERFAUST - The Faustian Pact
    Hey. I would have loved this when I was younger. I'd say I'm an old fogey, but I guess that would mean I'd stick by my younger ways and I'll still very much love this. Hm. I'm confused now on where I stand vs. where I should stand. This song deserves contemplation. I dig that snare about 2:40 in. Nice syncopation. Song is tight though. Very clean mix. The stuff I used to listen was mostly just white noise at a point. Nice.
  6. toconoma – Relive
    lol, this is pretty fun all around. Tight. I have several friends who would have been all over this in college. Bass sits very nicely in the mix. Curious, I did a quick search and found Highwind. Nice stuff, really. Thanks for the new reference!
  7. Girlschool - Race with the Devil
    No triggers here! That will make sense in a few nom comments down. Maybe that’s due, in part, to the country of origin? I don’t know, but I will find my anchor here (again, more sense comes later in the list). Speaking of......
  8. Fleetwood Mac - The Chain
    I've never been much of a MAC fan. Well, not since the early 90s probably when Apple was innovative. Now it's just a brand wh...wait. Hey. wrong Mac. Stevie Nicks' voice always got my attention, but I guess this was part of that transitional era of music for me coming out of my dad's selection and finding my own. This was more on his side of the wall.
  9. John Anderson - Seminole Wind
    Not a country fan, but this is pretty good for the style. Looking back, this song feels out of place in its decade, considering the twang and dance vibe of other pop country of the time. I can see this being a bridge song pulling a few curious rock fans in, by way of the Chris Isaak novelty of the time. I had to look this up to see where it actually sat on release. It peaked at #2 on US Hot Country Songs, apparently. I can buy that.
  10. The Mooney Suzuki - Alive & Amplified
    Wonky video. Cute stuff with the flowers blooming on the scream. I enjoyed the intro but that chorus is grating. Everything else is a bit funky, and that's fun. Just feels a bit choppy in the changes.
  11. O. Children - Ruins
    Great music and intro, but dude's voice throws me off the trail. Bits remind me of an unmentionable title from Spiderbait, but her voice is hawt.
  12. Joe Cocker - Edge Of A Dream
    I love Joe Cocker’s voice, but sadly I’m not a fan of this particular song. I guess it’s the 80’s of it. Gimme something from the With a Little Help from My Friends album and I’m there with a Bic in the air.
  13. Toto – Rosanna
    Nope. Shame on you (you and that other cat bringing up Fleetwood Mac) for digging up my 80’s radio pop abandonment issues between me and my dad!!! lol. Ugh. There’s at least 10 per competition so I should be used to it by now, huh? One day, I suppose, I will get to a place where I can listen to these songs without flashbacks of being left with a couple of bucks in quarters by the Galaga cabinet while he goes off hitting on bartenders. Hey. This is good. This is therapy. Still a pretty groovy bass line. Seems a theme in this list. NO! I will not enjoy this. But that creepy Jets vs. Sharks Roadhouse style, homoerotic gangland dance-off near end of the video was unexpected. I really don’t remember that. Hm. I digress. Decent guitar solo. Too much perm.
Round 2 nom incoming....

ynwtf 10-03-20 02:37 AM

Round 2 Nom (getting there)


As I'm currently working up my personal top 100, I found a lovely and sweet sleeper of a movie that I adored when I was a kid. It doesn't at all seem a likely pick, given the cast, but for some reason it connected with me deeply. Even now, when I watch it, I get all emotional. Jason Robards brought a bit of legitimacy to the cast and, surprisingly, played well on screen with.... Feldman. Yes. That Feldman. Corey Feldman, of the infamous two Coreys.


In keeping with my 80's themed soundtrack nom, this submission sits nicely in a later scene of Dream a Little Dream. When I hear the opening guitar and that twangy little hammer-on on the fourth pick, I always have to pause to give it the respect and love this heart-breaking song is due. The movie is probably silly for most, and if you didn't grow up with it in the context of that decade, it may never reach you the way it did me. Still. It sits well with an excellent supporting soundtrack.



Otis Redding - Dreams to Remember

ynwtf 10-03-20 02:46 AM

Originally Posted by Yoda (Post 2128873)
Sorry in advance for all the pinging you'll have to do for me, I'm new and busy and forgetful.

Don't feel too bad. I have to get at least 10 a day just to see an email notice to remind me to check my msgs reminding me to post my votes. Even then it's 50/50 if I remember to add my next nom. =\

Chypmunk 10-03-20 04:28 AM

All voted so without further ado.......

1st - Dusty Springfield - Spooky (135 pts)


2nd - O. Children - Ruins (121 pts)
3rd - Fleetwood Mac - The Chain (117 pts)
4th - Christine and the Queens - Doesn't Matter (107 pts)
5th - Girlschool - Race with the Devil (95 pts)
6th - John Anderson - Seminole Wind (89 pts)
7th - Toto - Rosanna (82 pts)
8th - toconoma - relive (81 pts)
8th - Real Life - Send me an Angel (81 pts)
10th - The Mooney Suzuki - Alive & Amplified (79 pts)
11th - PANZERFAUST - The Faustian Pact (77 pts)
12th - Joe Cocker - Edge Of A Dream (61 pts)
13th - Aseul - Fisher (58 pts)

Grats to hk on getting the first tune through to the Final :up:

Round two up around half an hour...

Chypmunk 10-03-20 05:00 AM


Chypmunk 10-03-20 09:17 AM

  1. Tami Neilson - You Were Mine
    Ticks all the boxes for me, I'll be looking into her catalogue
  2. Lonesome Wyatt and the Holy Spooks - Waiting for the End
    Simple but very nicely composed and effective, another I might look into
  3. BB King - The Thrill is Gone
    Classic choon from one of the blues greats
  4. Otis Redding - Dreams to Remember
    Mellifluous tune from a soul superstar
  5. G-Schmitt - Cathedral Junky
    It's all about the bass - mixed it up just enough imo
  6. Ricky Van Shelton - Somebody Lied
    Nice vocal and I do enjoy a good downbeat country song
  7. Pastel Ghost - Clouds
    A bit like OMD with a heavy bassline - me likes
  8. Sadistik - Cotard's Syndrome
    I've no expectations with this nom, he's not always the most accessible so I expect little love
  9. Pusha T ft. Kendrick Lamar - Nosetalgia
    Decent, not listened to any Pusha T before
  10. Foals - On the Luna
    Wasn't keen at the start but it did grow on me as it went on
  11. LIVE - Lightning Crashes
    Decent but not particularly memorable for me
  12. Obscura - Emergent Evolution
    Mixed bag for me, somewhat enjoyable
  13. Focus - Hocus Pocus
    Technically it's very accompished but it's just not my type of jam really (and that's partly why)

Not quite as strong as R1 but another pretty solid round imo and again being down the order doesn't necessarily mean it wasn't at least somewhat liked.

Chypmunk 10-03-20 10:33 AM

Re: A Song For October
 
Rounds been up for 6 1/2 hours and no votes from Yin yet so I guess it must be time for a reminder @ynwtf :D

Sedai 10-03-20 12:47 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
1 BB King - The Thrill is Gone - No fair putting songs like this in the tournament. This will bump my entry to #2 on my list.

2 Obscura - Emergent Evolution - Technical death metal that is still fairly catchy.

3 Otis Redding - Dreams to Remember - Should probably beat #2, but I will give that slot to the metal tracks today.

4 Tami Neilson - You Were Mine - Great set of pipes here. Not the most original in approach, but she kills it for what it is.

5 Foals - On the Luna - I have liked both of Yoda's tracks a lot so far. I dig this style of music quite a bit.

6 Pastel Ghost - Clouds - Love me some synths!

7 G-Schmitt - Cathedral Junky - Pretty smooth stuff.

8 LIVE - Lightning Crashes - I like this band a lot, and I saw them live multiple times in the 90s. Today, they don't resonate as much with me.

9 Pusha T ft. Kendrick Lamar - Nosetalgia - These guys are good rappers, but this track isn't one of the better ones I have heard from Pusha.

10 Focus - Hocus Pocus - Much prefer the Gary Hoey instrumental version that changes out the annoying yodeling for slick guitar lines.

11 Lonesome Wyatt and the Holy Spooks - Waiting for the End - Didn't do much for me, but I appreciate the Halloween theme.

12 Sadistik - Cotard's Syndrome - Wasn't feeling it.

13 Ricky Van Shelton - Somebody Lied - You all know where stuff like this places for me! As usual, I fully expect GB to plop my track down at 13, as well! Seems to be a theme for us. ;)

pahaK 10-03-20 12:48 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
01: Lonesome Wyatt and the Holy Spooks - Waiting for the End
02: Tami Neilson - You Were Mine
03: Obscura - Emergent Evolution
04: G-Schmitt - Cathedral Junky
05: BB King - The Thrill is Gone
06: Focus - Hocus Pocus
07: LIVE - Lightning Crashes
08: Otis Redding - Dreams to Remember
09: Foals - On the Luna
10: Ricky Van Shelton - Somebody Lied
11: Sadistik - Cotard's Syndrome
12: Pastel Ghost - Clouds
13: Pusha T ft. Kendrick Lamar - Nosetalgia

pahaK 10-03-20 12:50 PM

R3 nomination:
Rex Defunctis - Alucarda

Sedai 10-03-20 12:54 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
Round 3 NOM

Sorry, this song got pulled from Youtube, and is only available on Vimeo. Hopefully doesn't cause any trouble!

Kite - True Colors

Not sure if there is a way to alter the url to not show the video here. m. doesn't work.

@Yoda?

Chypmunk 10-03-20 01:14 PM

My R3 nom:
Anna von Hausswolff - Källans återuppståndelse

Was gonna wait for @cat_sidhe to be joining in before I nominated this one (as it's from Abbaland) but what the heck might as well throw it in now.

Chypmunk 10-03-20 01:27 PM

Originally Posted by Sedai (Post 2129158)
Round 3 NOM

Sorry, this song got pulled from Youtube, and is only available on Vimeo. Hopefully doesn't cause any trouble!

Not sure if there is a way to alter the url to not show the video here. m. doesn't work.

@Yoda?
Here ya go Seds:
Kite - True Colors

(you does gots to press the Play button manually though if on Chrome, Safari or Firefox as it won't auto-start)

resopamenic 10-03-20 02:29 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
1. Focus - Hocus Pocus
2. G-Schmitt - Cathedral Junky
3. Pastel Ghost - Clouds
4. Otis Redding - Dreams to Remember
5. BB King - The Thrill is Gone
6. Sadistik - Cotard's Syndrome
7. Ricky Van Shelton - Somebody Lied
8. Foals - On the Luna
9. Obscura - Emergent Evolution
10. Tami Neilson - You Were Mine
11. Pusha T ft. Kendrick Lamar - Nosetalgia
12. LIVE - Lightning Crashes
13. Lonesome Wyatt and the Holy Spooks - Waiting for the End

resopamenic 10-03-20 02:34 PM

r3 nom ;

kokushoku elegy - yume no naru koro

HollowMan 10-03-20 03:57 PM

1. BB King
2. LIVE
3. Tami Neilson
4. Pastel Ghost
5. Pusha T
6. Ricky Van Shelton
7. G-Schmitt
8. Otis Reading
9. Foals
10. Focus
11. Lonesome Wyatt and the Holy Spooks
12. Sadistik
13. Obscura

HollowMan 10-03-20 04:01 PM

Round 3 pick: REM - Electrolite


https://youtu.be/qO73cFm0tuk

Chypmunk 10-04-20 05:13 AM

Still @RealHero, @Derek Vinyard, @gbgoodies, @honeykid, @jiraffejustin, @Captain Spaulding, @Yoda and @ynwtf to vote.....

RealHero 10-04-20 06:03 AM

G-Schmitt - Cathedral Junky
Lonesome Wyatt and the Holy Spooks - Waiting for the End
Foals - On the luna
Tami Neilson "You Were Mine"
Live - Lightning Crashes
Ricky Van Shelton - Somebody Lied
Dreams to Remember
The Thrill Is Gone
Cotard's Syndrome
Pusha T f. Kendrick Lamar "Nosetalgia"
OBSCURA - Emergent Evolution
Focus - Hocus Pocus
Pastel Ghost - Clouds


Round 3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JfFQ8NB-W8g

honeykid 10-04-20 09:18 AM

My neck is aching today so no comments.

Round 2

Focus - Hocus Pocus

Otis Redding - Dreams to Remember

BB King - The Thrill is Gone

G-Schmitt - Cathedral Junky

Lonesome Wyatt and the Holy Spooks - Waiting for the End

Foals - On the Luna

Tami Neilson - You Were Mine

Obscura - Emergent Evolution

Pastel Ghost - Clouds

Pusha T ft. Kendrick Lamar - Nosetalgia

Sadistik - Cotard's Syndrome

LIVE - Lightning Crashes

Ricky Van Shelton - Somebody Lied

honeykid 10-04-20 09:21 AM

Round 3 nomination.

The Steve Miller Band - Abracadabra

gbgoodies 10-04-20 01:16 PM

All voted so without further ado.......

1st - Dusty Springfield - Spooky (135 pts)


Grats to hk on getting the first tune through to the Final :up:

Congratulations @honeykid! :up:

Derek Vinyard 10-04-20 01:38 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
LIVE - Lightning Crashes
BB King - The Thrill is Gone
Pastel Ghost - Clouds
Sadistik - Cotard's Syndrome
Lonesome Wyatt and the Holy Spooks - Waiting for the End
Focus - Hocus Pocus
Obscura - Emergent Evolution
Otis Redding - Dreams to Remember
G-Schmitt - Cathedral Junky
Foals - On the Luna
Ricky Van Shelton - Somebody Lied
Tami Neilson - You Were Mine
Pusha T ft. Kendrick Lamar - Nosetalgia

sorry for the delay

Derek Vinyard 10-04-20 01:39 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
nom:
Ozzy Osbourne - I Don't Wanna Stop

Yoda 10-04-20 01:45 PM

Re: A Song For October
 
Am I too late? I can do this today if not!

Chypmunk 10-04-20 01:48 PM

Originally Posted by Yoda (Post 2129339)
Am I too late?
Not yet, still 15 hours of the voting/nomination window remaining.

gbgoodies 10-04-20 02:26 PM

1) Ricky Van Shelton - Somebody Lied
2) Otis Redding - Dreams to Remember
3) Pastel Ghost - Clouds
4) Lonesome Wyatt and the Holy Spooks - Waiting for the End
5) BB King - The Thrill is Gone
6) Foals - On the Luna
7) Tami Neilson - You Were Mine
8) LIVE - Lightning Crashes
9) G-Schmitt - Cathedral Junky
10) Focus - Hocus Pocus
11) Sadistik - Cotard's Syndrome
12) Pusha T ft. Kendrick Lamar - Nosetalgia
13) Obscura - Emergent Evolution


I'll post my Round 3 nom in a little while.

gbgoodies 10-04-20 02:29 PM

Originally Posted by Sedai (Post 2129155)
13 Ricky Van Shelton - Somebody Lied - You all know where stuff like this places for me! As usual, I fully expect GB to plop my track down at 13, as well! Seems to be a theme for us. ;)

Do I usually vote your nom last? I rarely look at who nominated what unless I really like a song, so I never notice if there's a pattern of not liking someone's noms.

gbgoodies 10-04-20 02:32 PM

Originally Posted by Chypmunk (Post 2129166)
Here ya go Seds:
Kite - True Colors

(you does gots to press the Play button manually though if on Chrome, Safari or Firefox as it won't auto-start)

@Chypmunk, Thanks for the info. I didn't know that there was a way to embed a Vimeo link.

gbgoodies 10-04-20 02:37 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Originally Posted by honeykid (Post 2129302)
My neck is aching today so no comments. [
@honeykid, I don't know if you can get this near you, but I've used the back pain version of this, and it works great. I hope you feel better soon.

ThermaCare® Neck Pain Therapy


Chypmunk 10-04-20 02:38 PM

Originally Posted by gbgoodies (Post 2129349)
@Chypmunk, Thanks for the info. I didn't know that there was a way to embed a Vimeo link.
Neither did I until Sedai posed the question ;)

gbgoodies 10-04-20 03:32 PM

My Round 3 nom:
T.G. Sheppard ~ Do You Wanna Go To Heaven


All times are GMT -3. The time now is 10:22 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright, ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright © Movie Forums