1970's Hall of Fame

[edarsenal]

WELCOMETO
https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/81BT1oAAjlL._SL1200_.jpg
HALL OF FAME!!

Hello, grab a bean bag, turn on a lava lamp and spend some time in the "Me" Generation. Where personal attire were, a bit courageous, to say the least, grindhouse and exploitation films were king, and doing copious amounts of cocaine was actually smiled upon.

The rules of Hall of Fame are pretty much the same as others before:
You nominate a movie, PM said movie to the Host, said me,
I post all the nominations, everyone involved watches all the movies, write up a review for each movie and once done, make a list (favorite to least favorite), PM said list to said Host and at the end: big reveal, game show antics and prizes by made up sponsors (which, no one actually really gets anyways)

And yes, if you join, please finish.
If you do join and don't finish, I won't hunt you down, murder you and make some sort of southern delicacy out of you, wear you skin for a mask and jiggle my belly while waving a chainsaw in the air.
BUT one, or more of the others here might - just for the fun of it. While the rest of us cheer them on.
Just saying.

I haven't posted mentions right away, but depending on how things go, I might.

There's no specific deadline for when nominations need to be in, it may be a week from today, may be sooner, depending on how much time is necessary for everyone who joins in.

And, yes, we will do the "Guess Who Nominated What" game before posting them.

I am considering doing 1 week per player for the final deadline and will post the final decision/date here for everyone.

[edarsenal]

Participants/Reviews

edarsenal VOTE SENT IN
Sorcerer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1795235#post1795235)
Three Days of the Condor (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1795373#post1795373) NO LONGER IN HALL OF FAME
The Sting (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1797469#post1797469)
Dog Day Afternoon (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1799592#post1799592) NO LONGER IN HALL OF FAME
The Warriors (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1803898#post1803898)
What's Up, Doc? (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1811716#post1811716)
Fantastic Planet (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1819660#post1819660)
Eraserhead (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1824298#post1824298)
Kramer vs Kramer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1835021#post1835021)
F is For Fake (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1835047#post1835047)
Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1840641#post1840641)
Red Psalm (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1843017#post1843017)

rauldc14 VOTE SENT IN
Three Days of the Condor (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1802826#post1802826) NO LONGER IN HALL OF FAME
F For Fake (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1802834#post1802834)
The Warriors (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1808175#post1808175)
Fantastic Planet (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1808646#post1808646)
What's Up, Doc? (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1818083#post1818083)
Eraserhead (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1826841#post1826841)
Kramer vs Kramer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1831384#post1831384)
The Sting (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1835264#post1835264)
Sorcerer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1837837#post1837837)
Red Psalm (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1841296#post1841296)
Dog Day Afternoon (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1850201#post1850201) NO LONGER IN HALL OF FAME

Yam12 5/10 VOTE SENT IN
Eraserhead (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1811112#post1811112)
The Warriors (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1854343#post1854343)
The Sting (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1854343#post1854343)
What's Up, Doc? (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1854343#post1854343)
Fantastic Planet (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1854343#post1854343)

Citizen Rules VOTE SENT IN
Sorcerer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1798579#post1798579)
What's Up, Doc? (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1805748#post1805748)
Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1807898#post1807898)
Kramer vs Kramer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1808715#post1808715)
Dog Day Afternoon (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1809249#post1809249) NO LONGER IN HALL OF FAME
Three Days of the Condor (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1811396#post1811396) NO LONGER IN HALL OF FAME
F For Fake (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1813751#post1813751)
Fantastic Planet (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1815710#post1815710)
Red Psalm (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1831577#post1831577)
The Sting (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1838991#post1838991)
Eraserhead (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1840322#post1840322)


JayRedrum VOTE SENT IN
The Warriors (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1820254#post1820254)
F For Fake (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1831659#post1831659)
Fantastic Planet (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1840965#post1840965)
Kramer vs Kramer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1841134#post1841134)
What's Up, Doc? (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1841405#post1841405)
Red Psalm (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1841478#post1841478)
Dog Day Afternoon (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1842020#post1842020) NO LONGER IN HALL OF FAME
Sorcerer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1843008#post1843008)
The Sting (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1847820#post1847820)
Eraserhead (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1849333#post1849333)
Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1853221#post1853221)


Joel VOTE SENT IN
Kramer vs Kramer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1795159#post1795159)
Sorcerer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1799712#post1799712)
Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1802077#post1802077)
What's Up, Doc? (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1805513#post1805513)
Dog Day Afternoon (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1810185#post1810185) NO LONGER IN HALL OF FAME
The Warriors (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1850377#post1850377)
Fantastic Planet (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1850377#post1850377)
F is for Fake (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1850377#post1850377)
The Sting (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1852111#post1852111)
Red Psalm (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1852347#post1852347)
Eraserhead (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1852407#post1852407)



matt72582 Honorary Reviewer
Red Psalm (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1797204#post1797204)


cricket VOTE SENT IN
Sorcerer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1802475#post1802475)
Eraserhead (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1803851#post1803851)
Three Days of the Condor (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1808519#post1808519) NO LONGER IN HALL OF FAME
What's Up, Doc? (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1816974#post1816974)
Fantastic Planet (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1819455#post1819455)
F For Fake (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1828586#post1828586)
The Warriors (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1828712#post1828712)
Red Psalm (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1838958#post1838958)
Kramer vs Kramer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1839512#post1839512)
Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1843032#post1843032)
The Sting (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1846004#post1846004)
Dog Day Afternoon (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1846461#post1846461) NO LONGER IN HALL OF FAME


HashtagBrownies VOTE SENT IN
Eraserhead (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1794391#post1794391)
Dog Day Afternoon (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1794548#post1794548) NO LONGER IN HALL OF FAME
The Sting (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1795097#post1795097)
Kramer vs Kramer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1795107#post1795107)
F For Fake (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1795111#post1795111)
Red Psalm (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1838415#post1838415)
Fantastic Planet (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1842527#post1842527)
What's Up, Doc? (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1843235#post1843235)
The Warriors (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1849421#post1849421)
Sorcerer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1850694#post1850694)
Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1851477#post1851477)

Velvet 9/10
Fantastic Planet (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1795562#post1795562)
Dog Day Afternoon (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1795843#post1795843) NO LONGER IN HALL OF FAME
Sorcerer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?t=51442&page=17#)
Three Days of the Condor (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1796298#post1796298) NO LONGER IN HALL OF FAME
Kramer vs Kramer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1796315#post1796315)
The Sting (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1802747#post1802747)
The Warriors (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1802749#post1802749)
What's Up, Doc? (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1802753#post1802753)
Eraserhead (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1837840#post1837840)
Red Psalm (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1848261#post1848261)

CaptainT 4/10 NO LONGER IN HALL OF FAME
F For Fake (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1840978#post1840978)
The Warriors (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1842506#post1842506)
What's Up, Doc? (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1842516#post1842516)
The Sting (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1848572#post1848572)

Jeff Costello VOTE SENT IN
Three Days of the Condor (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1801393#post1801393) NO LONGER IN HALL OF FAME
Eraserhead (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1801393#post1801393)
The Warriors (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1811514#post1811514)
Fantastic Planet (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1816365#post1816365)
Red Psalm (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1848906#post1848906)
What's Up, Doc? (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1848906#post1848906)
Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1848906#post1848906)
F is for Fake (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1848906#post1848906)
Kramer vs Kramer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1853420#post1853420)
The Sting (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1855527#post1855527)
Sorcerer (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1855527#post1855527)



Deadline: January 16, 2018

[edarsenal]

Indagine su un cittadino al di sopra di ogni sospetto aka Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion (1970) Italian, Director: Elio Petri Nominated by Jeff Costello
http://ftv01.stbm.it/imgbank/GALLERYXL/IN/01666601.JPG


What's Up, Doc? (1972) Director: Peter Bogdanovich Nominated by edarsenal
http://img.moviepostershop.com/whats-up-doc-movie-poster-1972-1020222777.jpg


Még kér a nép aka Red Psalm (1972) Hungarian, Director: Miklós Jancsó Nominated by Velvet
https://assets.mubi.com/images/notebook/post_images_danny/multiple%20images/MPOTW/Strausfield_RedPsalm.jpg


La planète sauvage aka Fantastic Planet (1973) French, Director: René Lalouxr Nominated by rauldc14
http://img.moviepostershop.com/fantastic-planet-movie-poster-1973-1020209792.jpg


Sorcerer (1978) Director: William Friedkin Nominated by cricket
http://img.moviepostershop.com/sorcerer-movie-poster-1977-1020256151.jpg


F for Fake (1973) Directors: Orson Welles, Oja Kodar, François Reichenbach, Gary Graver Nominated by HashtagBrownies
https://i.pinimg.com/736x/e5/19/f2/e519f29c4d520a96da8ae162171a294b--orson-welles-film-posters.jpg


Kramer vs. Kramer (1979) Director: Robert Benton Nominated by Joel
https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/M/MV5BNDM3YjNlYmMtOGY3NS00MmRjLWIyY2UtNDA0MWM3OTNlZTY2XkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyMTQxNzMzNDI@._V1_UY1200_CR76,0,6 30,1200_AL_.jpg


The Sting (1973) Director: George Roy Hill Nominated by Jay Redrum
https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/M/MV5BMTY5MjM1OTAyOV5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTgwMDkwODg4MDE@._V1._CR52,57,915,1388_UY1200_CR80,0,630,1200_AL_.jp g


The Warriors (1979) Director: Walter Hill Nominated by Citizen Rules
http://img.moviepostershop.com/the-warriors-movie-poster-1979-1020466664.jpg


Eraserhead (1977) Director: David Lynch Nominated by Yam12
https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/M/MV5BMDExYzg5YjQtMzE0Yy00OWJjLThiZTctMWI5MzhjM2RmNjA4L2ltYWdlXkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyNTAyODkwOQ@@._V1_UY1200_ CR85,0,630,1200_AL_.jpg

[rauldc14]

I'll more than likely be in, Ed!

[edarsenal]

glad to hear it, raul!

[Yam12]

I'm thinking of joining but I probably need some time to make a decision

[edarsenal]

I'm thinking of joining but I probably need some time to make a decision
I intend to be laid back about time restrictions, so, you have time, my friend ;)

[Yam12]

I intend to be laid back about time restrictions, so, you have time, my friend ;)

In that case there are two, maybe three things I'm thinking of picking as my nom. I'll probably see who else joins before I make my decision

[edarsenal]

In that case there are two, maybe three things I'm thinking of picking as my nom. I'll probably see who else joins before I make my decision
Kool & The Gang

[Citizen Rules]

I'm in of course! I will think about my nom (like I haven't been thinking about it for weeks already):D So I just have to decide between artsy film that you guys will probably hate, or fun film that you've probably seen...decisions, decisions.:p

[edarsenal]

I'm in of course! I will think about my nom (like I haven't been thinking about it for weeks already):D So I just have to decide between artsy film that you guys will probably hate, or fun film that you've probably seen...decisions, decisions.:p

Oh, I know, I have three ready to go. Pretty well known, I think, and I'm going to wait till everyone else sends theirs in and see what may be left and make a choice - unless of course I stumble upon something and go that route. . .

[Joel]

I'd like to join but not sure I'll be able to commit, but my eye is on this thread :)

[edarsenal]

Even if you're unable to join in, visiting is still a wonderful option, Joel

[matt72582]

Great thread!

[edarsenal]

Great thread!

THANKS Matt! Feel free to join in on comments or the occasional review should you be inclined

[Citizen Rules]

I'd like to join but not sure I'll be able to commit, but my eye is on this thread
Join Joel!.....You've been a great new member in the 14th Hof, and we need people like you to be enthusiastic about movies and be willing to discuss them, you're a natural at this!

You'll like this Hof too:), it has a different 'feel' than the 14th Hof, more laid back and probably will have less people. All of the genre/decades Hofs I've been in have had really good movies too. I enjoy these Hofs much more than the main one.

Great thread! Matt join! everything I just said to Joel applies to you too. I know you are passionate about the 1970s, so here's your chance. But if you don't join, please hang out and discuss the movies with us:)

[Jay Redrum]

I'll join in the fun :)
Is the objective to nominate lesser known films?

[Citizen Rules]

I'll join in the fun :)
Is the objective to nominate lesser known films?It's fun, also it's work. If you join you get to nominate a film, but...you have to watch all of the other films that get nominated and then write about them.

The goal is to nominate a movie that you fully believe is great. It's not abut lesser known films, but one could be nominated if you thought it was worthy of being in a Movie Hall of Fame....think of the Sports or Music Hall of Fames.

[Jay Redrum]

It's fun, also it's work. If you join you get to nominate a film, but...you have to watch all of the other films that get nominated and then write about them.

The goal is to nominate a movie that you fully believe is great. It's not abut lesser known films, but one could be nominated if you thought it was worthy of being in a Movie Hall of Fame....think of the Sports or Music Hall of Fames.

Don't worry im up for the task.
Okay sounds good I already know what my nom will be then.

[Citizen Rules]

Don't worry im up for the task.
Okay sounds good I already know what my nom will be then. Cool, it's always good to get new members in the Hofs. I think I have my nom ( I wish I could choose 10 movies:p) I'm sure many have seen my movie before, but that's OK as I love it.

[matt72582]

Thanks, I'll probably watch or have watched many of the movies.. Maybe I'll wait and send a list..... I can't even control my own movie habits, and I don't do anything half-assedly.

[Yam12]

I'm in.

Will send in my nom shortly

[edarsenal]

Don't worry im up for the task.
Okay sounds good I already know what my nom will be then.

WELCOME! Jay!!
Got your nom, thank you!

[Jay Redrum]

So when should I expect this will start?

[CaptainT]

I'm thinking about joining this but I'm not totally sure yet.

[edarsenal]

So when should I expect this will start?
I'm giving it about a week for people to join and send in noms, if it ends up being quicker, I'll post regarding it.

[edarsenal]

think it over and let us know, CaptainT. Be happy to have ya!

[Joel]

Join Joel!.....You've been a great new member in the 14th Hof, and we need people like you to be enthusiastic about movies and be willing to discuss them, you're a natural at this!

You'll like this Hof too:), it has a different 'feel' than the 14th Hof, more laid back and probably will have less people. All of the genre/decades Hofs I've been in have had really good movies too. I enjoy these Hofs much more than the main one.



I might join! Seems more my pace, and definitely not as nutty as that survivor thread...unless we start roleplaying from a Cassavetes film, like the dinner table scene in Woman under the Influence ;P

[Citizen Rules]

I might join! Seems more my pace, and definitely not as nutty as that survivor thread...unless we start roleplaying from a Cassavetes film, like the dinner table scene in Woman under the Influence ;P Ha:D no, not Survivor:eek:

I went for a fun 70s film, that you probably seen, but something tells me you'll like it. So pick a movie and join!

[matt72582]

I'm in... I'll send you my nomination today.

[matt72582]

I might join! Seems more my pace, and definitely not as nutty as that survivor thread...unless we start roleplaying from a Cassavetes film, like the dinner table scene in Woman under the Influence ;P

"A Woman Under The Influence" wasn't my first Cassavetes, but I discovered it on a 70's favorite list... I still don't know recommended it, but I'll always be thankful... There's never been a movie even close to this in terms of originality and quality..

<just got chills thinking of how great Gena Rowlands was... a top 5 performance ever>

[Joel]

"A Woman Under The Influence" wasn't my first Cassavetes, but I discovered it on a 70's favorite list... I still don't know recommended it, but I'll always be thankful... There's never been a movie even close to this in terms of originality and quality..

<just got chills thinking of how great Gena Rowlands was... a top 5 performance ever>

Husbands was my first Cassavetes. No, wait a minute. No, Gloria was my first one, then I worked backwards, ..that's right.

Yeah, Gena Rowlands is a force of nature! I love her!

[Joel]

OK, I'm in, and really hope my nom hasn't been used already if there have been past 1970's HOF's.

[edarsenal]

OK, I'm in, and really hope my nom hasn't been used already if there have been past 1970's HOF's.
Just checked, you are good to go.

matt72582 that is FANTASTIC news!! Very cool to see you joining the 70s HoF.

This is getting pretty d@mn exciting now!

[cricket]

I'm in

[rauldc14]

I have but no idea what I should pick yet though.

[Citizen Rules]

OK, I'm in, and really hope my nom hasn't been used already if there have been past 1970's HOF's.This is a first! There's never been a 1970s Hof, until now.

I have but no idea what I should pick yet though.I have a spare nom that I can loan ya:p

[matt72582]

I have a question.. Since we only send one nomination, what happens if we select the same movie?

Who in here has seen "A Woman Under The Influence"? for example... I'll try to look at everyone's "Lists" to see what they have already seen, it would be a shame to waste a nomination on a movie everyone has seen, considering the 70s are my favorite decade for movies (and music)

[Citizen Rules]

I have a question.. Since we only send one nomination, what happens if we select the same movie? That's up to the host, Ed. I'm sure he'll answer. I think it's pretty darn rare for two people to pick the same movie.

Who in here has seen "A Woman Under The Influence"? for example... I'll try to look at everyone's "Lists" to see what they have already seen, it would be a shame to waste a nomination on a movie everyone has seen, considering the 70s are my favorite decade for movies (and music)I've never seen A Woman Under The Influence. Pretty sure Cricket has, maybe Raul and Ed?

[Joel]

I have a question.. Since we only send one nomination, what happens if we select the same movie?

Who in here has seen "A Woman Under The Influence"? for example... I'll try to look at everyone's "Lists" to see what they have already seen, it would be a shame to waste a nomination on a movie everyone has seen, considering the 70s are my favorite decade for movies (and music)

I've seen it but it's been since 2008 so watching it again would be like seeing it for the first time, especially with a movie like that!

[rauldc14]

Seen it. Please don't nominate that lol.

[matt72582]

That's up to the host, Ed. I'm sure he'll answer. I think it's pretty darn rare for two people to pick the same movie.

Who in here has seen "A Woman Under The Influence"? for example... I'll try to look at everyone's "Lists" to see what they have already seen, it would be a shame to waste a nomination on a movie everyone has seen, considering the 70s are my favorite decade for movies (and music)I've never seen A Woman Under The Influence. Pretty sure Cricket has, maybe Raul and Ed?[/quote]

Part of me wants a less known movie, but the "Lists" contain only a certain category for each one.. Otherwise, I'd select "Harry and Tonto", considering it's my favorite of all-time.

[Citizen Rules]

@matt72582 (http://www.movieforums.com/community/member.php?u=85325)

Personally I just pick what movie I love, or believe in...and if everyone has seen it, big deal...it just means they have less movies to watch.

I think the problem lately in the main Hof is people try too hard to pick obscure movies, then half of the people end up hating the noms.

[edarsenal]

SO VERY HAPPY you're in, cricket!!! A 70's HoF without you just wouldn't be right.

And to answer your question, matt72582, if someone PMs me their nom and someone already has it, I'll let that person know they need to pick another. Also, we do a little pre-game of trying to guess who nominated what before actually getting into gear. I'll post a list without saying who nominated what and for the fun of it, everyone who cares to, takes a stab at which nom belongs to who. Then, of course, I'll post the names to the movies which will be found on the front page along with a list of links to reviews as they come in.

and, oh my god, rauldc14, pick a d@mn movie already LOL
I'm looking to keep this open til around next Thursday (give or take) for joining and getting a nom in, so keep a looking. . . or hey, I've had fun with blind grabs in 2 separate HoFs so that's always a possibility.

[edarsenal]

and like CR mentioned, going with a favorite is a good thing. And a lot of times, even very well known movies haven't been seen by a lot or its been forever since last viewing them, so it all comes out in the wash - as it were

[Camo]

Me and Sean just did John Cassavetes for the Director of the Month. First time i watched A Woman Under The Influence (for the first Hall of Fame i joined here actually) i didn't like it much, but yeah on rewatch it was incredible; Rowlands performance has to be the best portrayal of mental illness. I actually preferred Love Streams of the four we watched though.

[edarsenal]

I had back tracked in your Director of the Month thread about those movies, camo. Very interesting stuff.
I've always had trouble watching Cassavetes, not sure why, though it has been a long time since my last attempt, so it could be a possibility in the future.

[Thursday Next]

I'm pretty sure Woman Under the Influence has been nominated for a hall of fame before. Not that that necessarily disqualifies it.

I can't commit to this hall of fame at the moment but I'll be watching with interest!

[Citizen Rules]

I've only seen one of Cassavetes movies, the one that Cricket nominated in an Hof Micky and Nicky. Didn't like it, but would like to see more.

Oh wait, he didn't direct that one.

[edarsenal]

I'm pretty sure Woman Under the Influence has been nominated for a hall of fame before. Not that that necessarily disqualifies it.

I can't commit to this hall of fame at the moment but I'll be watching with interest!

by all means, Thursday, pop in when ever you can, that'll be wonderful.
And yeah, I did see Woman Under The Influence was in an HoF but it didn't win which, if I understand correctly, allows it to be nominated again. I know Spring, Summer, Fall, Winter (not sure of the order) has been nominated twice and I think one or two others may have as well.

[edarsenal]

I've only seen one of Cassavetes movies, the one that Cricket nominated in an Hof Micky and Nicky. Didn't like it, but would like to see more.

Oh wait, he didn't direct that one.

I remember when that HoF was going on and I tried finding a decent link/copy of Micky and Nicky with no luck. I'll have to try again for that one, Thanks for the reminder :)

[Citizen Rules]

I'm pretty sure Woman Under the Influence has been nominated for a hall of fame before. Not that that necessarily disqualifies it. You're right, on both accounts.

Hall of Fame 5
It came in at 9/15

[Thursday Next]

I've only seen one of Cassavetes movies, the one that Cricket nominated in an Hof Micky and Nicky. Didn't like it, but would like to see more.

Oh wait, he didn't direct that one.

Yeah, Cassavetes is in it but Elaine May directed it.

I think Faces was nominated for one of the HoFs (or possibly a tournament). I really didn't like that very much.

[Citizen Rules]

Yeah, Cassavetes is in it but Elaine May directed it.

I think Faces was nominated for one of the HoFs (or possibly a tournament). I really didn't like that very much.
Your right again, I just looked it up. Faces with nominated by Hitchfan in the 2nd Hof.

[Camo]

I had back tracked in your Director of the Month thread about those movies, camo. Very interesting stuff.
I've always had trouble watching Cassavetes, not sure why, though it has been a long time since my last attempt, so it could be a possibility in the future.

Can i ask which ones you've tried? I found Shadows close to unwatchable and he apparently made a few like that. Think you'd have an easier time with A Woman Under The Influence, Love Streams or Opening Night. Although none of them are typical films.

I'm pretty sure Woman Under the Influence has been nominated for a hall of fame before. Not that that necessarily disqualifies it.


Yeah i mentioned in my post that i watched it for the first Hall of Fame i joined here.

[Camo]

I've only seen one of Cassavetes movies, the one that Cricket nominated in an Hof Micky and Nicky. Didn't like it, but would like to see more.

Oh wait, he didn't direct that one.

He was a talented actor too, his directed films are nothing like the roles he took i don't think. He was a major influential figure in American Independent Films, particularly after his death.

[Camo]

Yeah, Cassavetes is in it but Elaine May directed it.

I think Faces was nominated for one of the HoFs (or possibly a tournament). I really didn't like that very much.

Your right again, I just looked it up. Faces with nominated by Hitchfan in the 2nd Hof.

Faces is supposed to be similar to Shadows. Me and Sean found Shadows really tough to sit through; actually Sean didn't even finish it. The other ones we watched were pretty great tho.

[Citizen Rules]

Faces is supposed to be similar to Shadows. Me and Sean found Shadows really tough to sit through; actually Sean didn't even finish it. The other ones we watched were pretty great tho.I'm going to have to back read your thread. But in a nut shell, in what way was it tough to sit through?

[matt72582]

I had back tracked in your Director of the Month thread about those movies, camo. Very interesting stuff.
I've always had trouble watching Cassavetes, not sure why, though it has been a long time since my last attempt, so it could be a possibility in the future.

The first time I watch one of his movies, there is a bit frustration... Second viewing is so amazing, because Cassavetes never spoon-feeds, and after you know the movie, you can watch and notice other things...

[matt72582]

I'm going to have to back read your thread. But in a nut shell, in what way was it tough to sit through?

I also found Faces a little difficult.. Shadows is a bit better, but I like where he's trying to go.. I want to see these again.

No one talks about the two movies he made in the studio system that I think are great - A Child Is Waiting, Too Late Blues

"Minnie and Moskowitz" was one of those gritty 70's naturalistic movies without the cliches. This was the 1st movie of Cassavetes, and during the first half (12 years ago) I was so frustrated, but by the end, it all came together.

"Opening Night" is very tough, because it's a play within a play within a play. "Love Streams" is also one I like... Actually the only one I couldn't stand was Killing of a Chinese Bookie.

[Camo]

I'm going to have to back read your thread. But in a nut shell, in what way was it tough to sit through?

It was just really unpleasant to watch and listen to. The sound and visuals were really unpleasant to me. It also had a very disjointed structure which wouldn't have been a problem if it wasn't that intrusive visually and audibly, i found the story very hard to concentrate on due to this and i think Sean fell asleep :laugh: It is acclaimed though, particularly for its place in American Independent Film history; it was his first. Not for me though.

Here's what me and Sean posted, neither of us posted spoilers or said very much since we had such an awful time with it :

Sean - https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1769051#post1769051
Me - https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1780690#post1780690

[Camo]

The first time I watch one of his movies, there is a bit frustration... Second viewing is so amazing, because Cassavetes never spoon-feeds, and after you know the movie, you can watch and notice other things...

I actually pointed out how much i appreciated the credit he gives his audience in my Love Streams review. Particularly regarding the brother-sister relationship.

[edarsenal]

Can i ask which ones you've tried? I found Shadows close to unwatchable and he apparently made a few like that. Think you'd have an easier time with A Woman Under The Influence, Love Streams or Opening Night. Although none of them are typical films.
Actually had to go and look, It's been a good 2 decades since trying to watch them. I remember struggling with Husbands and didn't finish. Loved Falk, as I always do, but, if I remember it may be I kept thinking "What a bunch of d1cks,". And I remember the cool friends saying I was a d1ck for not appreciating it lol
I vaguely remember attempting Faces and having no luck with it.

There is one I DID watch and enjoy: Gloria. Saw it as a rental from Blockbuster back in the mid to late 80's. Rowlands was great in that one from what I can remember.

Not sure if I've ever tried A Woman Under the Influence, and I know I haven't seen Opening Night (which, reading it looks rather intense) or Love Streams.

[Camo]

Actually had to go and look, It's been a good 2 decades since trying to watch them. I remember struggling with Husbands and didn't finish. Loved Falk, as I always do, but, if I remember it may be I kept thinking "What a bunch of d1cks,". And I remember the cool friends saying I was a d1ck for not appreciating it lol
I vaguely remember attempting Faces and having no luck with it.


Pretty sure Husbands and Faces are the two others that are like Shadows so it's not surprising you didn't like them.

A Woman Under The Influence actually has a really straightforward story. Opening Night and Love Streams are deliberately all over the place, but A Woman Under The Influence is basically a linear drama film about a woman (Gena Rowlands) with a severe mental illness; with Peter Falk as her husband. I've only seen 4/12 of Cassavetes films so i can't say overall but out of those at least i'd say that would be the easiest to get into.

[Joel]

@matt72582 (http://www.movieforums.com/community/member.php?u=85325)



I think the problem lately in the main Hof is people try too hard to pick obscure movies, then half of the people end up hating the noms.

I suspected something along those lines...

[matt72582]

I actually pointed out how much i appreciated the credit he gives his audience in my Love Streams review. Particularly regarding the brother-sister relationship.

Isn't it odd they never made a movie together, as a couple? I liked how someone who isn't well herself could have helped, albeit in a strange way, but it wasn't the most convincing, aybe it's because I knew they were married, and at first glance, I think even a rookie would smile, but THAT doesn't matter... I actually liked the father-son scenario most.

[Camo]

Isn't it odd they never made a movie together, as a couple? I liked how someone who isn't well herself could have helped, albeit in a strange way, but it wasn't the most convincing, aybe it's because I knew they were married, and at first glance, I think even a rookie would smile, but THAT doesn't matter... I actually liked the father-son scenario most.

I knew they were married too (i only watched Love Streams last night) and i think it was incredible how well they pulled off a sibling relationship considering their actual relationship. The father-son one was odd to me, i dunno can't be bothered going into it. Thought Cassavetes was amazing in the father-son scenes though.

[Joel]

I watched Husbands first and thought it was equally fascinating and misogynistic. But I'd watch it again out of curiosity.

A Woman Under the Influence was funny and disturbing. I think I laughed because of Peter Falk. His voice when he gets animated has that effect on me.

I couldn't get through Shadows or Faces.

The Killing of a Chinese Bookie I found dull and messy. I love Ben Gazzara but this wasn't his movie for me. I struggled bad with this one.

Opening Night..there's one that Birdman probably ripped off a little bit. I did like it, but may have to see it again at some point.

Gloria was my first Cassavetes film. I liked it. It was actually really awesome and Gena Rownlands as the action hero was so unique because she wasn't all bombastic. She had a subtle way of kicking ass. Like a very realistic way. She really is the best there was.

I need to see Love Streams. That was has me curious because it's PG-13 and a Cannon film. I guess the Golan/Globus Bros gave Cassavetes carte blanche.

Minny and Moskowitz I wasn't a fan of. Too grimy for me. It was semi interesting but it wasn't my thing, really.

And though not a Cassavetes film, I really liked Mikey and Nicky. I thought it was funny. Loved the diner scene with Falk.

[edarsenal]

A Woman Under the Influence definitely seems like something I should try for and yeah, Joel, Falks' voice has the same effect for me too. I just love listening to him talk and I crack up from the joy of it.

[Joel]

A Woman Under the Influence definitely seems like something I should try for and yeah, @Joel (http://www.movieforums.com/community/member.php?u=96380), Falks' voice has the same effect for me too. I just love listening to him talk and I crack up from the joy of it.

Like in Made...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UiYVjeY88dg

[Camo]

I think i was constantly disturbed throughout A Woman Under The Influence, because in the first three minutes you see Rowlands she gets raped and has no idea what's going on in the morning. The only scenes that aren't disturbing to me in the film are the ones with Peter Falk and the kids, and one of them even has underage drinking :laugh:

That's my only actual criticism of the film. It's not even a criticism actually more a want, i would have liked more scenes with Falk and the kids or Falk coping on his own those were amazing; think they brought Rowlands back too soon.

[matt72582]

I watched Husbands first and thought it was equally fascinating and misogynistic. But I'd watch it again out of curiosity.

A Woman Under the Influence was funny and disturbing. I think I laughed because of Peter Falk. His voice when he gets animated has that effect on me.

I couldn't get through Shadows or Faces.

The Killing of a Chinese Bookie I found dull and messy. I love Ben Gazzara but this wasn't his movie for me. I struggled bad with this one.

Opening Night..there's one that Birdman probably ripped off a little bit. I did like it, but may have to see it again at some point.

Gloria was my first Cassavetes film. I liked it. It was actually really awesome and Gena Rownlands as the action hero was so unique because she wasn't all bombastic. She had a subtle way of kicking ass. Like a very realistic way. She really is the best there was.

I need to see Love Streams. That was has me curious because it's PG-13 and a Cannon film. I guess the Golan/Globus Bros gave Cassavetes carte blanche.

Minny and Moskowitz I wasn't a fan of. Too grimy for me. It was semi interesting but it wasn't my thing, really.

And though not a Cassavetes film, I really liked Mikey and Nicky. I thought it was funny. Loved the diner scene with Falk.

I'm glad you noticed Birdman. I agree 100% on Chinese Bookie -- too muddled. Gloria is one of his more commercial movies, only because he wanted to sell it, but ended up doing it himself.

I think Falk is the crazy one, but I don't think J.C. wanted to tell the audience what to feel and maybe wanted to see how people would respond. There are a few scenes where it's just by luck, chance, where she is considered crazy.. The first thing we hear from Falk is that he thinks Mabel is mad at him for not spending any time, and even when he makes a date to make up for this, he doesn't show up, she sits up all night, and etc.., but she wanted it to work, even going to her mother for a babysitter, not even sure if she should have..

Falk comes home and the first thing he says is "Cook me and these 10-15 guys I work with food" and "SIT YOUR ASS".. Notice how Falk ends that, telling Mabel she did nothing wrong, so she's probably a very self-conscious (e.g. what she says to herself) by leaving everything because his mother was seeking sympathy for a tummy ache.

The party... When they come back, they see the little girl running naked, and when grandma asks, the little girl seems afraid and doesn't answer.. Of course grandma suggests "Was it mommy?" - when that wasn't true.. She simply told the kids to wear their costumes.. And then lies the "crazy" -- she dances.. So what! That was another time Falk punches her out (before threatening to kill the kids) because the swan dance probably helps her anxieties... She asks him a few times if she loves him, and he says nothing.. During a moment of quiet, you hear Mabel basically say how she got pregnant (shot-gun wedding, regrets?)... Falk seems to side with his mother on everything, and instead of the mother taking the blame for not raising her kid right, it's typical she would blame Mabel for ALL the woes... "My husband doesn't do anything, he's a good boy" (when the psychiatrist shows up, who only makes things worse by being the typical smarmy elitist)..

I didn't even mention the beach.. I'm glad I wasn't the only one to notice it was too cold, yet Falk was wearing shorts in that freezing weather, and seems so disjointed, and needs to seek approval from co-workers, and his overbearing mother.

A sign of the times... Mabel goes to pick up the kids, and she needs to know what time it is. She asks a few women walking by and they totally ignore her, and she's frustrated by their lack of empathy, at one point yelling "You have a watch on!".. But it's all good, she was on time, etc... I'm not saying she was perfect, but I don't think she was abnormal, and her anxieties were caused by others.. And for Falk to throw a huge party the minute she comes out of the mental institution, which obviously doesn't help.. She tells the guests she wants to be alone, and everyone else wants to tell her what she can or cannot handle.. Even Falk says "She shouldn't see the kids" until his mother actually changes, and appears the only responsible person, and perhaps some guilt we don't know about for Mabel -- why else would she change course all of a sudden? Because she got what she wanted, screaming that she needs to be put away..

At the end, he does scream "I love you so who cares" and the proverbial band-aid as they get ready for bed..

"Husbands" is one that doesn't seem to be watched much. It's somewhere in the middle for me, but I wish some would watch the two movies he made in the studio, which are very structured... Too Late Blues was the first, with Bobby Darin, and it's probably the best movie that describes music and the business, the lines between making a career out of it without selling out... A Child Is Waiting has Burt Lancaster, Judy Garland, Gena Rowlands, etc, but Judy steals the show.. I think it was her best role, and she was in the condition to play it with so much vulnerability without being corny.

If anyone is interested, here is the 544-paged "Cassavetes on Cassavetes" by Ray Carney, who really loves American independent movies and really knows his stuff.

http://www.thestickingplace.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/Cass-on-Cass.pdf

So I don't forget, John Cassavetes' mother is probably the funniest person in movies, although he has a wicked sense of humor, the smile, the eyes.. Hilarious in The Dirty Dozen -- "I never ate that.. Stepped in it a few times, never ate it"....

And I love "Mikey and Nicky" and movies like that. Real-time, no act 1, 2, and 3 (not that there's anything wrong with that) but it's nice to have options and not be encumbered by convention.

[Velvet]

I join

[cricket]

I join

My man!

[Velvet]

My man!



hey just got unbanned. I actually just got back from the theater where I saw fantastic planet. Good to see you posting and feeling better

[cricket]

hey just got unbanned. I actually just got back from the theater where I saw fantastic planet. Good to see you posting and feeling better

Thanks, back to normal

[Velvet]

man I want to blind nom a super obscure film but I dont know if I or others will be able to find a download link

[HashtagBrownies]

I might be in. How long will we have to watch all the films?

[cricket]

I might be in. How long will we have to watch all the films?

Usually get a week for each

[rauldc14]

I just sent in my nomination. I'm sure most have seen it, but I wanted to revisit it and see everyone discuss it, so that's that.

[HashtagBrownies]

I'm in and sent my nom.

My first HoF...

http://i.imgur.com/gbw7RMb.gif

[edarsenal]

WELCOME to the show, HashtagBrownies!!

Of course, with it being the 70s, may I suggest:
https://i.giphy.com/media/FNEsFZLyDB2vK/giphy.webp

and with that, we are at 9 participants presently! VERY nice. Kinda feel like dancing myself lol

[Jeff Costello]

You can more than likely count me in, but I will officially announce my participation on Wednesday after I find my nomination.

[Velvet]

really hoping somebody nominates the holy mountain

[HashtagBrownies]

really hoping somebody nominates the holy mountain

Why didn't you nominate it?

https://media.tenor.com/images/f13a71af50a1edf19aa3ef3621eb01b8/tenor.gif

[Velvet]

It was on my shortlist but I chose another film

[edarsenal]

You can more than likely count me in, but I will officially announce my participation on Wednesday after I find my nomination.

sure thing, jeff! I'll hold off posting your name on the participating list if ya like?

[edarsenal]

Want to welcome our most recent 70's player: AlexWilder

[Velvet]

You are now


https://media.giphy.com/media/Ae7SI3LoPYj8Q/giphy.gif
AlexWilder

[edarsenal]

just want to post a few mentions for some folks that had interest and/or join in on these so that I can adjust the start date of Thursday October 5 to accommodate anyone. (I won't add those already joined or have already spoken with regarding this.)
Also, I do know there is a lot of great things going on elsewhere on this forum, never mind the insanity of normal life; so, no pressure if you're going with a pass. A simple "middle finger" in the thread or per PM will do quite nicely ;)

CosmicRunaway Sarge jiraffejustin Miss Vicky Nestorio_Miklos Thursday Next seanc


List so far
edarsenal
rauldc14 (Nom Sent)
yam12 (Nom Sent)
Citizen Rules (Nom Sent)
Jay Redrum (Non Sent)
Joel (Nom Sent)
matt72582 (Nom Sent)
cricket (Nom Sent)
HashtagBrownie (Nom Sent)
Velvet (Nom Sent)
AlexWilder (Nom Sent)

[Yam12]

October 5th sounds great. Hopefully I can use the next couple of days to finish the current HoF

[edarsenal]

I've got two more films to watch for that one too!

[AlexWilder]

thanks for the nice welcome Velvet and edarsenal
i'm very excited about this, i hope it'll be fun !

[Citizen Rules]

Hey Alex, I remember you, good to see ya again:)

[AlexWilder]

yeah Citizen, i had a brief adventure here before lol thanks

[TheUsualSuspect]

I'd love to, but I have Survivor and Horror Film Challenge going on. I wouldn't be able to find the time.

[Citizen Rules]

yeah Citizen, i had a brief adventure here before lol thanks I remember your nomination in the ill fated Comedy Hof...Wild Tales (2014) It was one of the better films nominated.

[cricket]

I remember your nomination in the ill fated Comedy Hof...Wild Tales (2014) It was one of the better films nominated.

I still have that on my watchlist

[edarsenal]

I'd love to, but I have Survivor and Horror Film Challenge going on. I wouldn't be able to find the time.

Survivor does take up a lot of time and the Horror Film looks to be a lot of fun - gonna try to watch that one as it pans out. ENJOY 'EM!

[CosmicRunaway]

I've been thinking about this since you mentioned wanting to host it, and still haven't made up my mind. I know, I'm a terribly indecisive person. There are so many great films from the 70s, and I'm really interested to see what everyone has nominated.

Survivor is nearing the end, and I only have 2 films left for the 14th HoF, but I'm not sure if I want to commit to anything right now. This past month has been exhausting, with a lot of stuff going on here and in my life. I think I need some time to just watch things at my own pace, and by my own choosing. I do have a ton of horror films I want to watch this month, in addition to 2 games I'm very excited for.

Even if I don't join, I'll probably loiter around here anyway though haha.

[rauldc14]

I have 2 more to watch for the 14th, then I can go to this. I think I can finish up the 14th today!

[edarsenal]

I've been thinking about this since you mentioned wanting to host it, and still haven't made up my mind. I know, I'm a terribly indecisive person. There are so many great films from the 70s, and I'm really interested to see what everyone has nominated.

Survivor is nearing the end, and I only have 2 films left for the 14th HoF, but I'm not sure if I want to commit to anything right now. This past month has been exhausting, with a lot of stuff going on here and in my life. I think I need some time to just watch things at my own pace, and by my own choosing. I do have a ton of horror films I want to watch this month, in addition to 2 games I'm very excited for.

Even if I don't join, I'll probably loiter around here anyway though haha.
If you simply loiter, I would love that and I completely understand how exhausting Survivor can be and, even more so, life in general; and an occasional break from HoFs can be necessary.
Have you had a chance to check out the October Horror Challenge (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?p=1781002#post1781002) that camo is hosting? A little loitering or possibly venturing in there may be a wonderful Horror movie hook up. He has a great set up list of choosing your own movies.

So, PLEASE, my dear, DO NOT feel pressured to join if you need a break; so relax, enjoy your working fridge, and loiter at your leisure if that's what you decide. :)

[Camo]

enjoy your working fridge

Man i love this. I'm going to start saying this to family and friends as a term of endearment.

And yeah if you're watching horrors this month join us in that thread if you want Cosmic. You don't have to actually take part in the challenge or try and fit films into the categories or whatever, it's for all Horror discussion some of us are just doing that so it's not a generic horror thread.

[Nestorio_Miklos]

hey guys, when's the deadline to send a nom?

[edarsenal]

Man i love this. I'm going to start saying this to family and friends as a term of endearment.

yeah, it's a Canadian thing, tell them that when they ask what you mean, :D

[Jeff Costello]

hey guys, when's the deadline to send a nom?

Thursday, I believe.

[edarsenal]

hey guys, when's the deadline to send a nom?
I was getting worried and ready to extend to make you sure you made it.
Tentatively, I'm aiming at the 5th. And willing to adjust for anyone who needs it. I know Jeff will be making a decision tomorrow on a nom and if he'll be in.
So, if ya need a little time, let me know.

[Jeff Costello]

I was getting worried and ready to extend to make you sure you made it.
Tentatively, I'm aiming at the 5th. And willing to adjust for anyone who needs it. I know Jeff will be making a decision tomorrow on a nom and if he'll be in.
So, if ya need a little time, let me know.

Maybe, even in couple of hours Ed !

[Nestorio_Miklos]

I was getting worried and ready to extend to make you sure you made it.
Tentatively, I'm aiming at the 5th. And willing to adjust for anyone who needs it. I know Jeff will be making a decision tomorrow on a nom and if he'll be in.
So, if ya need a little time, let me know.
i can make it by Thursday.
thank you

[rauldc14]

Look forward to the unveil! I already know 2 of the films :)

[CaptainT]

I finally decided. I'm in! I'll send my nom right now.

[edarsenal]

WELCOME, CaptainT!! Got your nom, and I gotta say, some really great ones coming in all across the board!!

and a pre-WELCOME To Nestorio_Miklos and, of course, again, WELCOME to Jeff Costello!! So very glad you guys can make it!

[edarsenal]

Nestorio sent his nom in, so I'll be doing the REVEAL later tonight with the updates for the front page. I'll put mentions to let everyone know as well so we can do "Guess Who Nominated What" before I post who DID nominate what and we'll get this sucka goin.

I'll also post the Deadline here and on the front page, which, after calculating a movie a week per player actually puts it a week after the new year and, since we'll be running through the holidays and all that occurs here, and in our lives, I'm adding an extra week and I'm sure we'll all need the full amount of time. And of course, like everything, that date will be tentative and I will extend should it be necessary.

Deadline: January 12, 2018

Quite the incredible wide range of genre/films for the decade including 2 foreign films. So its definitely quite the smorgasbord.

[Yam12]

Nestorio sent his nom in, so I'll be doing the REVEAL later tonight with the updates for the front page. I'll put mentions to let everyone know as well so we can do "Guess Who Nominated What" before I post who DID nominate what and we'll get this sucka goin.

I'll also post the Deadline here and on the front page, which, after calculating a movie a week per player actually puts it a week after the new year and, since we'll be running through the holidays and all that occurs here, and in our lives, I'm adding an extra week and I'm sure we'll all need the full amount of time. And of course, like everything, that date will be tentative and I will extend should it be necessary.

Deadline: January 12, 2018

Quite the incredible wide range of genre/films for the decade including 2 foreign films. So its definitely quite the smorgasbord.

So we currently have 14 people. Out of interest what's the biggest hall of fame?

[Citizen Rules]

So we currently have 14 people. Out of interest what's the biggest hall of fame?I believe it was the Hall Of Fame 7, which had 20 people at the start and 18 finished.

14 members is doing pretty good though:up:

[Velvet]

do you know what time ur gonna reveal

[Yam12]

I have to log off soon so I'm probably going to miss the reveal. Hopefully I can still guess what everyone nominated when the reveal happens.

[Velvet]

Gonna go to bed in 30 minutes so ill probably miss it

[edarsenal]

THE REVEAL

rauldc14, Yam12, Citizen Rules, Jay Redrum, Joel, matt72582, cricket, HashtagBrownies, Velvet, AlexWilder, CaptainT, Jeff Costello, Nestorio_Miklos



Three Days of the Condor (1975) Director: Sydney Pollack
https://i.pinimg.com/originals/11/a1/d0/11a1d056f488a60a19e0035633fb1651.jpg


Indagine su un cittadino al di sopra di ogni sospetto aka Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion (1970) Italian, Director: Elio Petri
http://ftv01.stbm.it/imgbank/GALLERYXL/IN/01666601.JPG


Dog Day Afternoon (1975) Director: Sidney Lumet
http://www.gablescinema.com/media/filmassets/dog_day_afternoon_poster.jpg.500x715_q85_crop-smart.jpg


The Last Picture Show (1971) Director: Peter Bogdanovich
http://resizing.flixster.com/DL7GmqAnA58TwNw9AVAgZ5frJU8=/799x1066/v1.bTsxMTI5MDk0ODtqOzE3NTg4OzIwNDg7MTUzNjsyMDQ4


What's Up, Doc? (1972) Director: Peter Bogdanovich
http://img.moviepostershop.com/whats-up-doc-movie-poster-1972-1020222777.jpg


Még kér a nép aka Red Psalm (1972) Hungarian, Director: Miklós Jancsó
https://assets.mubi.com/images/notebook/post_images_danny/multiple%20images/MPOTW/Strausfield_RedPsalm.jpg


Fantastic Planet (1973), France, Director: René Laloux
http://img.moviepostershop.com/fantastic-planet-movie-poster-1973-1020209792.jpg


Sorcerer (1978) Director: William Friedkin
http://img.moviepostershop.com/sorcerer-movie-poster-1977-1020256151.jpg


F for Fake (1973) Directors: Orson Welles, Oja Kodar, François Reichenbach, Gary Graver
https://i.pinimg.com/736x/e5/19/f2/e519f29c4d520a96da8ae162171a294b--orson-welles-film-posters.jpg


Kramer vs. Kramer (1979) Director: Robert Benton
https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/M/MV5BNDM3YjNlYmMtOGY3NS00MmRjLWIyY2UtNDA0MWM3OTNlZTY2XkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyMTQxNzMzNDI@._V1_UY1200_CR76,0,6 30,1200_AL_.jpg


Harry and Tonto (1974) Director: Paul Mazursky
http://www.freecovers.net/preview/0/4b0633ffae9eded309de5607003f624a/big.jpg


The Sting (1973) Director: George Roy Hill
https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/M/MV5BMTY5MjM1OTAyOV5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTgwMDkwODg4MDE@._V1._CR52,57,915,1388_UY1200_CR80,0,630,1200_AL_.jp g


The Warriors (1979) Director: Walter Hill
http://img.moviepostershop.com/the-warriors-movie-poster-1979-1020466664.jpg


Eraserhead (1977) Director: David Lynch
https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/M/MV5BMDExYzg5YjQtMzE0Yy00OWJjLThiZTctMWI5MzhjM2RmNjA4L2ltYWdlXkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyNTAyODkwOQ@@._V1_UY1200_ CR85,0,630,1200_AL_.jpg

[Velvet]

ty so much

very interesting stuff

[edarsenal]

i'll post images with the title and year, director as well in a bit.

[Velvet]

eraserhead is a good one

[Citizen Rules]

Very cool noms! This is why I like the special Hofs so much.

OK I'll try and guess who's nom is who's... it will be pretty darn hard as there's a lot of new members who I don't know their movie taste....

But..very cool to get new people joining:)

[cricket]

Seen all of them except for the two foreign language films. Some I need to see again, some not. Some are favorites, some not.

[Citizen Rules]

Here's my guess, I'm sure most are wrong.:( At least I got one right.

edarsenal - The Sting
rauldc14 - What's Up, Doc?
yam12 - Dog Day Afternoon
Citizen Rules - F for Fake
Jay Redrum - Kramer Vs. Kramer
Joel - The Last Picture Show
matt72582 - Harry and Tonto
cricket - Sorceror
HashtagBrownie - Halloween
Velvet - Eraserhead
AlexWilder - Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion
CaptainT - The Warriors
Jeff Costello - Red Psalm
Nestorio_Miklos - Three Days of the Condor

[edarsenal]

you actually have 3 correct, Citizen Rules -- not too shabby
which one did you think you had right? And I'll let you know if it is

[edarsenal]

I've seen 6, the rest are ones I've WANTED to see and the 2 Foreign ones are brand new to me, but look pretty intriguing

[cricket]

Guesses

edarsenal - The Sting
rauldc14 - The Last Picture Show
yam12 - Kramer vs Kramer
Citizen Rules - Sorcerer
Jay Redrum - What's Up, Doc?
Joel - Eraserhead
matt72582 - Harry and Tonto
cricket - F for Fake
HashtagBrownie - Dog Day Afternoon
Velvet - The Warriors
AlexWilder - Three Days of the Condor
CaptainT - Halloween
Jeff Costello - Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion
Nestorio_Miklos - Red Psalm

[edarsenal]

2 correct, cricket

[Jay Redrum]

Not even gonna bother guessing :p
So this is my first HoF should I be like wathcing these all right now or what?

[Joel]

My guesses are edarsenal - The Sting
Harry and Tonto - Matt
F is for Fake - Citizen
Sorcerer - Cricket

That's about it for now. Lots of awesome flicks here, so good to see Bogdanovich, Pollack and Lumet in the list. Looking very much forward to this one, great line up!

[edarsenal]

you have 2 correct, Joel

Since it showed up 3 times, I will throw out a hint:
I did not nominate The Sting. Surprisingly.

[edarsenal]

Not even gonna bother guessing :p
So this is my first HoF should I be like wathcing these all right now or what?
you have until January 12, 2018 to watch them all.
You can start any time and start posting reviews once I reveal who actually nominated what.

[Joel]

Can't wait to start watching these. Shoot, I can't wait til there's a 70's HOF2!

[HashtagBrownies]

I've seen 6 of the nominated films, but I may give 2 of them a re-watch.

I can't even bother guessing.

[Yam12]

My guesses

Harry and Tonto - Matt
What's Up Doc? - Citizen Rules
Kramer vs Kramer - Raul

Those are the only ones I have some idea about

[matt72582]

edarsenal - The Sting
rauldc14 - Halloween
yam12 - The Warriors
Citizen Rules - F Is For Fake
Jay Redrum - Eraserhead
Joel - Dog Day Afternoon
matt72582 - Harry and Tonto
cricket - Sorcerer
HashtagBrownie - Last Picture Show
Velvet - What's up, Doc?
AlexWilder - Red Psalm
CaptainT - Kramer vs. Kramer
Jeff Costello - Three Days of the Condor
Nestorio_Miklos - Investigation of a Citizen Under Investigation

A little confusing with Citizen Rules AND Cricket guessing their own movie, which is the same??

[rauldc14]

Literally my top 3 picks all got picked. Wow this one going to be good!!! I've seen 7 of them already but I'll probably watch them all again.

[matt72582]

I had "Investigation...." but needed to make room and got rid of it :(

Luckily, there are a few I haven't seen in a long time, I might even get started today!

[Velvet]

edarsenal - The Sting
rauldc14 - The last picture show
yam12 - Kramer vs Kramer
Citizen Rules - F for Fake
Jay Redrum - dog day afternoon
Joel - eraserhead
matt72582 - Harry and Tonto
cricket - Sorcerer
HashtagBrownie - The Warriors
AlexWilder - whats up doc
CaptainT - Halloween
Jeff Costello - Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion
Nestorio_Miklos - Red Psalm
Velvet - three days of condor


stole some guesses from others

[Velvet]

cool picks, was hoping for more foreign but still really good picks


I might be able to see Halloween in the theater so that would be cool

[CosmicRunaway]

Great picks. :up:

If you like foreign films Velvet, I do still plan to host a Foreign Language HoF. It might not be any time soon, but it will eventually happen haha.

[AlexWilder]

from the 14 movies on the list i saw 4, i've never heard of 3, and the other 7 were all in my watch list !

[edarsenal]

My guesses

Harry and Tonto - Matt
What's Up Doc? - Citizen Rules
Kramer vs Kramer - Raul

Those are the only ones I have some idea about
You got one right. In fact, it was highlighted since it was very common correction.edarsenal - The Sting
rauldc14 - Halloween
yam12 - The Warriors
Citizen Rules - F Is For Fake
Jay Redrum - Eraserhead
Joel - Dog Day Afternoon
matt72582 - Harry and Tonto
cricket - Sorcerer
HashtagBrownie - Last Picture Show
Velvet - What's up, Doc?
AlexWilder - Red Psalm
CaptainT - Kramer vs. Kramer
Jeff Costello - Three Days of the Condor
Nestorio_Miklos - Investigation of a Citizen Under Investigation

A little confusing with Citizen Rules AND Cricket guessing their own movie, which is the same??
you have 3 correct as well, matt. Also, I gave a hint that I did not nominate The Sting since that was guessed 3 times and was wrong. Also, some obvious ones are NOT. And to help things along, you are the only one who guessed their actual nomination.
edarsenal - The Sting
rauldc14 - The last picture show
yam12 - Kramer vs Kramer
Citizen Rules - F for Fake
Jay Redrum - dog day afternoon
Joel - eraserhead
matt72582 - Harry and Tonto
cricket - Sorcerer
HashtagBrownie - The Warriors
AlexWilder - whats up doc
CaptainT - Halloween
Jeff Costello - Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion
Nestorio_Miklos - Red Psalm
Velvet - three days of condor


stole some guesses from others
you have 3 correct as well, velvet.
Great picks. :up:

If you like foreign films Velvet, I do still plan to host a Foreign Language HoF. It might not be any time soon, but it will eventually happen haha.
Which I am looking forward and have a few already picked out.

[seanc]

Good list of noms. You guys should have some fun. Don't know if anyone cares but Halloween did win the Slasher HOF.

[edarsenal]

Good list of noms. You guys should have some fun. Don't know if anyone cares but Halloween did win the Slasher HOF.

OH - SH#T
I missed that completely!! :eek:
I will let that person know - thank you so much, sean for the heads up.

[cricket]

I was going to lift by review from that Hall of Fame and it still didn't occur to me.

[edarsenal]

I had been pretty amazed that while one or two were previously nominated we were in the clear across the board.

Wish I could chalk it up to newbie screw ups but I have far too many on a daily basis for that lol

again, THANKS sean! Already sent a PM and will change it out when the new one comes in.

[Citizen Rules]

Here's my thoughts on the noms:

Three Days of the Condor...I've never seen this but have long wanted to!

Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion...no idea.

Dog Day Afternoon...I've also never seen this but have long wanted to!

The Last Picture Show...I seen this recently but will rewatch it, as I liked it, but I think another watch will kick it up a notch.

What's Up, Doc?...Haven't seen this since I was a kid, looking forward to it.

Red Psalm...no idea.

Halloween...Good fun for October, I haven't seen it in years.

Sorceror...A complete mystery to me, but I'm intrigued.

F for Fake...Orson Welles, who is that???

Kramer Vs. Kramer...It's been a long time, great film.

Harry and Tonto...I seen this fairly recently but I think I'll rewatch it and see if my appreciation will grow.

The Sting...It's been a long time, great film.

The Warriors...It's been a long time, great film.

Eraserhead

[edarsenal]

F for Fake...Orson Welles, who is that???

Eraserhead

Never heard of Welles. . . wasn't he that chubby guy with the beard, always smoking a cigar on the Dean Martin Man of the Hour Roasts??
(that sh#t made me laugh)

no thoughts on Eraserhead?

[Yam12]

Good list of noms. You guys should have some fun. Don't know if anyone cares but Halloween did win the Slasher HOF.

That's a shame. I was actually looking forward to watching it

[edarsenal]

me too, been decades since seeing it and it rounded out and complimented all the others quite nicely making it a full spectrum.
I feel even worse for the person, it wasn't their first choices since a couple were already nominated.

[Citizen Rules]

Never heard of Welles. . . wasn't he that chubby guy with the beard, always smoking a cigar on the Dean Martin Man of the Hour Roasts??
(that sh#t made me laugh)

no thoughts on Eraserhead?Whoops...that wasn't an intentional miss of Eraserhead, just too much in a hurry.

Eraserhead...I'm glad this was nominated. I hear it being talked about all the time. People either love it, love it, love it...
OR H A T E IT....I've never seen it, so am very curious about it. Good nom choice.

[Jeff Costello]

Great set of nominations !

I see couple of people already guessed mine.

[Yam12]

Judging by what Citizen posted I'm guessing F for Fake is his nomination

[Joel]

I change my guess...I'm guessing Citizen Rules picked Eraserhead, he had to of! :p

[edarsenal]

nope, yam, F For Fake is NOT Citizens. There a couple of obvious guess like me for The Sting, along with this and I believe, one other.

and since Jeff acknowledged, Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion is his. Intriguing lil crime film from Italy which, like so very many, I'm looking forward to.

[Velvet]

ersaserhead will be a fun one to hear about, saving it for last to make sure I dont rewatch too soon

[Citizen Rules]

nope, yam, F For Fake is NOT Citizens. There a couple of obvious guess like me for The Sting, along with this and I believe, one other.

and since Jeff acknowledged, Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion is his. Intriguing lil crime film from Italy which, like so very many, I'm looking forward to.Well if Jeff has mentioned his, I will say F for Fake is mine, it's one of Orson Welles best and it's his last film so it holds a special place in my heart. (thanks Ed for covering for me! but it's kinda of obvious, it's mine:p) I hope you guys like it:)

[Velvet]

F for Fake is a great nom Citizen. its one of the ones Im most excited to watch

[Citizen Rules]

F for Fake is a great nom Citizen. its one of the ones Im most excited to watch:up:

[Velvet]

Jeffs nom also looks very good

[Joel]

I'll give a hint..Eraserhead is not mine.

[Nestorio_Miklos]

Three Days of the Condor (1975) Director: Sydney Pollack - I've seen it several times and always liked it very much


Indagine su un cittadino al di sopra di ogni sospetto aka Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion (1970) Italian, Director: Elio Petri - never heard of it


Dog Day Afternoon (1975) Director: Sidney Lumet - I've seen it several times and liked it


The Last Picture Show (1971) Director: Peter Bogdanovich - seen it 2 times and liked it


What's Up, Doc? (1972) Director: Peter Bogdanovich - seen it however dont remember it


Még kér a nép aka Red Psalm (1972) Hungarian, Director: Miklós Jancsó - heard of it, never seen it


Halloween (1978) Director: John Carpenter - seen it several times and liked it


Sorcerer (1978) Director: William Friedkin - seen it once, dont remember much of it


F for Fake (1973) Directors: Orson Welles, Oja Kodar, François Reichenbach, Gary Graver - never heard of this one, it might be good


Kramer vs. Kramer (1979) Director: Robert Benton - seen it some 4 times and liked it


Harry and Tonto (1974) Director: Paul Mazursky - seen it, dont remember it


The Sting (1973) Director: George Roy Hill - same


The Warriors (1979) Director: Walter Hill - same


Eraserhead (1977) Director: David Lynch - of course seen it and liked it. Heavy stuff

this looks like a decent HOF and i can't wait for watching/rewatching the features. Good stuff!

[matt72582]

So I just saw Halloween for nothing?

[Joel]

So I just saw Halloween for nothing?

Leave a review, anyway!

[Velvet]

https://letterboxd.com/velvety/list/1970s-hall-of-fame/

Letterbox List


IMDB list

http://www.imdb.com/list/ls025743697/?publish=publish

[matt72582]

Halloween - I saw parts of this a long time ago... I think it was pretty boring and silly, but not horrible...

6/10

[edarsenal]

A truly in depth and one of your most poignant and illuminating review. I am in awe!! lol


Sorry for the inconvenience, that is on me for not double checking.
If it helps, you can post in the October Horror thread. . .

[Yam12]

I would also post my thoughts on the nominations but it'll give away my nom since that's the only one I've seen

[matt72582]

A truly in depth and one of your most poignant and illuminating review. I am in awe!! lol


Sorry for the inconvenience, that is on me for not double checking.
If it helps, you can post in the October Horror thread. . .

LOL... There wasn't much to review :)

[Joel]

Halloween - I saw parts of this a long time ago... I think it was pretty boring and silly, but not horrible...

6/10

I'll be honest. I've never been a huge fan of Halloween. I think Carpenter was a better filmmaker than that regardless of the supposed mark it made in history or whatever. I don't even agree it was a first for POV or slasher, etc. Black Christmas is an obvious forerunner.

It was just OK in my opinion.
Carpenter did much superior work a couple years prior with Assault on Precinct 13.

[Thursday Next]

Seen:

Dog Day Afternoon - great film, I really enjoyed this tale of a couple of really hapless bank robbers. One of those films that just hooks you right from the start.

The Warriors - Really like this one as well, looks great.

The Sting. - It's been a while since I saw this but I remember not being as impressed with it as I'd hoped after reading great things. It might be worth giving it another watch.

The Last Picture Show - Saw this around the time we did the 70s countdown. It's a pretty bleak film!

F is for Fake - I think this was in another hall of fame some time. I wasn't mad keen on it.

Kramer vs. Kramer - My mum likes this film but I don't like it all that much. I'm not sure it's dated well.

Halloween - Not keen. Horror isn't really my favourite genre, and slasher films are not one of the subgenres of horror I do like. I just really didn't see what was special about it at all.

Eraserhead - Honestly quite a chore to sit through.


(Not overwhelmingly positive responses, sorry nominators!)


Have not seen:

Three Days of the Condor
Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion*
What's Up, Doc?
Red Psalm
Sorceror*
Harry and Tonto


Starred a couple that have been ones I've always meant to watch, so maybe I'll bump them up my watch list and join in with the discussions.

[matt72582]

I'll be honest. I've never been a huge fan of Halloween. I think Carpenter was a better filmmaker than that regardless of the supposed mark it made in history or whatever. I don't even agree it was a first for POV or slasher, etc. Black Christmas is an obvious forerunner.

It was just OK in my opinion.
Carpenter did much superior work a couple years prior with Assault on Precinct 13.

I liked They Live -- for the theme of course... Then again, I think since those movies are so predictable, they do get boring.

[matt72582]

The only movies I didn't see were "Red Psalm", "The Warriors", "Sorcerer".... I saw the first 20 minutes of "Citizen..." (I like Petri and Volonte) wasn't that into it, and needed the space...

I actually have had "Eraserhead" on VHS since I was 18, and yes, it was a chore to watch, but I was a new film fan, and wanted to explore EVERYTHING.... There are some on that list I haven't saw in years, so it'll be nice to re-visit, as I've notice a few of my opinions changing, both ways.

[Joel]

I liked They Live -- for the theme of course... Then again, I think since those movies are so predictable, they do get boring.

They Live had an awesome premise but was executed like a drunk donkey tap dancer.

[Velvet]

have had "Eraserhead" on VHS since I was 18


Selling it? :laugh:

[matt72582]

Selling it? :laugh:

Sure.

[Velvet]

If you put it up on amazon I might buy it, what year is it from

[matt72582]

If you put it up on amazon I might buy it, what year is it from

I don't have Amazon, and won't go through the trouble for a few bucks.. I have it one of these boxes. I bought it around 2000.

[edarsenal]

They Live had an awesome premise but was executed like a drunk donkey tap dancer.
I f@ckin LOVE that!! :rotfl:
Always loved They Live never have I heard so many corny lines spoken so hilariously.
And if we talk Carpenter we HAVE to mention The Thing, which, for me, was his very best. Of course, for sheer fun, They Live and Big Trouble and Little China seem to tie.


So, anyways, if we've all finished guessing, I will wait for the replacement for Halloween and I'll probably reveal who nominated what some time this evening. And probably my own thoughts on what we have after the replacement nom comes in. . . or maybe not, no idea really. lol

[Joel]

I f@ckin LOVE that!! :rotfl:
Always loved They Live never have I heard so many corny lines spoken so hilariously.
And if we talk Carpenter we HAVE to mention The Thing, which, for me, was his very best. Of course, for sheer fun, They Live and Big Trouble and Little China seem to tie.


So, anyways, if we've all finished guessing, I will wait for the replacement for Halloween and I'll probably reveal who nominated what some time this evening. And probably my own thoughts on what we have after the replacement nom comes in. . . or maybe not, no idea really. lol

I absolutely agree that The Thing was Carpenter's crowing achievement on multiple levels. One of my fave films of all time to be honest. Big Trouble in Little China I adore that movie. It does exactly what it wants, and knows what it is with NO apologies. Like a punk rock Indiana Jones meets Abbot and Costello Meet Frankenstein.

[cricket]

Dog Day Afternoon-It used to be a big favorite, but when I last watched it about 5 years ago I wasn't as big a fan. I've been meaning to see it again so I can know for sure how I feel. I could have had a bad day.

Harry and Tonto-I don't need to watch it again but I might. I think it's a great movie that has a chance to win this thing.

Three Days of the Condor-I believe this was the last movie I watched for the 70's countdown. I remember it as a good movie, but the movie itself is escaping me.

The Warriors-An all time favorite that I've seen many times and has made appearance in my top 10. One of the coolest, most quotable, and most fun movies I've seen.

The Sting-Saw it once and enjoyed it. The strange thing is that my opinion of it has gone steadily down upon reflection. It usually goes the other way.

What's Up, Doc? and F for Fake-Didn't care for either when I saw them a couple of years ago. Taste changes so we'll see what happens.

Kramer vs Kramer-I remember it as brilliant but it's been many years.

Eraserhead-Thought it was an ok watch the one time I saw it about 4 years ago.

The Last Picture Show-I really liked it when I watched it for the 70's countdown. I remember thinking it could become a favorite if I ever saw it again. It looks like I'll be seeing it again.

Red Psalm and Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion-Heard of both but seen neither.

Sorcerer-Never heard of it before.

[HashtagBrownies]

My Guesses:

Cricket - Sorcerer
Raul - Last Picture show
Matt72582 - Harry and Tonto
Edar: Dog Day Afternoon
Yam: Kramer vs. Kramer
Citizen: What's up, Doc?
Redrum: The Sting
Joel: Red Psalm
Velvet: Eraserhead
Alex: The Warriors
Captain: Halloween
Jeff: Three Days of the Condor
Nestorio_Miklos - Investigation of a Citizen Under Investigation

And me...?
You think I'd actually tell you!?

https://www.askideas.com/media/37/Funny-Laughing-Gif-Picture.gif

[mark f]

Sorcerer-Never heard of it before.
Why give them clues?
Sorcerer (1977) 4
Exciting and filled with tension.
:cool:

[edarsenal]

And, the new replacement is in for Halloween:

Fantastic Planet (1973), France, Director: René Laloux
http://img.moviepostershop.com/fantastic-planet-movie-poster-1973-1020209792.jpg

[Yam12]

And, the new replacement is in for Halloween:

Fantastic Planet (1973), France, Director: René Laloux
http://img.moviepostershop.com/fantastic-planet-movie-poster-1973-1020209792.jpg

That's actually something else I've been wanting to see for a while

[cricket]

That's a good one too

[edarsenal]

HashtagBrownies you have 3 correct!

[edarsenal]

anyone want to guess who this is, or any others or shall I go for the reveal of who nominated what and we'll get this puppy. . . um, walked? neutured? paper-trained?

[Yam12]

Matt - Harry and Tonto
Citizen - F is Fake
Jeff - Investigation of a Citizen
Hashtag - Kramer vs Kramer
Cricket - Sorcerer
Raul - The Sting

[Swan]

Raul is Fantastic Planet/Halloween

[edarsenal]

Three Days of the Condor (1975) Director: Sydney Pollack Great spy flick with Robert Redford. Been quite some time since seeing this.

Indagine su un cittadino al di sopra di ogni sospetto aka Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion (1970) Italian, Director: Elio Petri I have not heard of this but it definitely looks intriguing.

Dog Day Afternoon (1975) Director: Sidney Lumet See this a couple of times, really enjoy it, looking forward to revisiting it.

The Last Picture Show (1971) Director: Peter Bogdanovich This was actually on my "Blind Grab" should the others I had ready got nabbed up, so, pretty cool to see it nominated.

What's Up, Doc? (1972) Director: Peter Bogdanovich Been a while since seeing this, Vaudevillian/Marx Brothers influenced comedy.

Még kér a nép aka Red Psalm (1972) Hungarian, Director: Miklós Jancsó Have not heard of it, but very very curious about it.

Fantastic Planet (1973) Director: René Lalouxr Haven't seen this since I was in my late teens/early twenties -- and VERY VERY HIGH lol

Sorcerer (1978) Director: William Friedkin haven't seen it, but I DO recognize the poster though. I'd be curious, but if cricket doesn't know anything about it, it can't be any good, right? ;)

F for Fake (1973) Directors: Orson Welles, Oja Kodar, François Reichenbach, Gary Graver Haven't seen it but Citizen has raved about it, so I'm definitely in.

Kramer vs. Kramer (1979) Director: Robert Benton One of those must sees that I never did see, so here's a perfect opportunity.

Harry and Tonto (1974) Director: Paul Mazursky Always been curious about this one, very glad to finally feed that curiosity.

The Sting (1973) Director: George Roy HillHUGE HUGE fan of this. Could easily do a review, but screw that, I'm gonna watch it again!

The Warriors (1979) Director: Walter Hill I abhor violence. I just don't feel very comfortable about this being in the HoF to be honest.
:D

Eraserhead (1977) Director: David Lynch Another I haven't and always hear the extremes when it's spoken about so, looking forward to seeing where I land on this one.

[edarsenal]

Matt - Harry and Tonto
Citizen - F is Fake
Jeff - Investigation of a Citizen
Hashtag - Kramer vs Kramer
Cricket - Sorcerer
Raul - The Sting
You have 3 correct.
Raul is Fantastic Planet/Halloween
Correct-amundo!

[Yam12]

edarsenal

Is What's Up Doc yours?

[edarsenal]

yes, Yam12, What's Up, Doc? IS mine BRAVO

[Citizen Rules]

edarsenal how about letting us know who nominated what?

[edarsenal]

Loved to,

gimme a sec

[edarsenal]

Three Days of the Condor (1975) Director: Sydney Pollack Nominated by Nestorio_Miklos

Indagine su un cittadino al di sopra di ogni sospetto aka Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion (1970) Italian, Director: Elio Petri Nominated by Jeff Costello

Dog Day Afternoon (1975) Director: Sidney Lumet Nominated by CaptainT

The Last Picture Show (1971) Director: Peter Bogdanovich Nominated by AlexWilder

What's Up, Doc? (1972) Director: Peter Bogdanovich Nominated by edarsenal

Még kér a nép aka Red Psalm (1972) Hungarian, Director: Miklós Jancsó Nominated by Velvet

Fantastic Planet (1973) Director: René Lalouxr Nominated by rauldc14

Sorcerer (1978) Director: William Friedkin Nominated by cricket

F for Fake (1973) Directors: Orson Welles, Oja Kodar, François Reichenbach, Gary Graver Nominated by HashtagBrownies

Kramer vs. Kramer (1979) Director: Robert BentonNominated by Joel

Harry and Tonto (1974) Director: Paul Mazursky Nominated by matt72582

The Sting (1973) Director: George Roy Hill Nominated by Jay Redrum

The Warriors (1979) Director: Walter Hill Nominated by Citizen Rules

Eraserhead (1977) Director: David Lynch Nominated by Yam12

[cricket]

Really didn't expect some of those matches

[edarsenal]

I was thinking the exact same thing as they came in.

[Citizen Rules]

Surprise! The Warriors is my nomination

I love this film....and I seen it first run when it came out back in 1979 at the theater.

Before watching it, you need to know, that it's not meant to be a realistic look at gangs in New York. The movie is told as a fable, set in some future dystopian time, when gangs had evolved and taken over the streets.

The movie is based on a 1965 novel that was based on an ancient Greek tale of Anabasis...and the movie also draws from Homer's Odyssey.

So if you go into this wondering why there's no cops, or traffic or people in the street, just remember this is a movie told in fable form, and set in some near-future.

[cricket]

Surprise! The Warriors is my nomination

I love this film....and I seen it first run when it came out back in 1979 at the theater.

Before watching it, you need to know, that it's not meant to be a realistic look at gangs in New York. The movie is told as a fable, set in some future dystopian time, when gangs had evolved and taken over the streets.

The movie is based on a 1965 novel that was based on an ancient Greek tale of Anabasis...and the movie also draws from Homer's Odyssey.

So if you go into this wondering why there's no cops, or traffic or people in the street, just remember this is a movie told in fable form, and set in some near-future.

This is news to me.

[Citizen Rules]

This is news to me. There's even a tie in to Orson Welles and The Warriors

From Wiki
The director Walter Hill wanted Orson Welles to do a narrated introduction about Greek themes but the studio did not like this idea and refused to pay for it. However, this sequence was finally included in the 2005 Ultimate Director's Cut, with Hill providing the narration himself.

[Citizen Rules]

BTW, I still like and recommend the original theatrical cut of The Warriors.

[edarsenal]

that was one of the matches I was surprised by. I just didn't picture Citizen getting into The Warriors.

and with cricket I was truly expecting a grindhouse film

[Citizen Rules]

that was one of the matches I was surprised by. I just didn't picture Citizen getting into The Warriors.

and with cricket I was truly expecting a grindhouse filmI was a mellow kid, but when I left the theater after watching The Warriors I remember feeling like I wanted to kick some ass! I hadn't seen anything like it at the time.

[cricket]

Sorcerer will probably be my first as the DVD arrived today.

[edarsenal]

never knew about the narration part and haven't seen the director's cut, but I'll definitely go with the theatrical version when I rewatch The Warriors.

I remember the comparisons to Odyssey and I remember the news talking about all the fights that would break out at the movie theaters while this movie was playing.

If I can find a copy of Sorcerer or Three Days on the Condor online I may go with one of them first.

[HashtagBrownies]

Official review

36076

This movie has quite an amazing atmosphere, it makes it quite spooky. The use of the humming and the white noise also helps to build the atmosphere of the film. The imagery is amazing. The special effects are really, really good.

It’s quite hard to give an actual review of this film as it’s more of an experience than a film.

4

[Velvet]

just saw fantastic planet on the big screen and it was in 4k too. Ill try to type up a review for that then

[Camo]

Dog Day Afternoon: Great film, Pacino's best performance IMO.
The Last Picture Show: Liked this quite a bit but don't remember it that well. I preferred Paper Moon from Bogdanovich which is one of my favourite films.
What's Up Doc?: It's weird that Bogdanovich has two films in this. After loving Paper Moon i ended up watching this and Nickolodeon; had already seen Last Picture Show. I liked this quite well and disliked Nickolodeon.
Fantastic Planet: Solid but not a favourite.
F For Fake: Of the six Welles films i've seen i'd have this second last, i do like it though. Think i respect it more than i enjoy watching it.
Kramer vs Kramer: A cloying melodrama that usually gets called oscar-bait nowadays, but one i really like. Mostly due to Hoffman's performance and how natural the father-son relationship feels.
The Sting: I didn't like this but i don't remember why.
The Warriors: Not a fan. Think it's dated in a way i can't handle although i understand the love.
Eraserhead: One of my favourite films, completely understand people despising it though. Like most of Lynch's films it's just a surreal experience that will hit some people and some it won't, first time i saw it i thought i hated it actually but i had to see it again.

Seen 9/14. Good bunch, i think it was better i stayed out of it though as i'm trying to cut down on rewatches. Might check a few of the ones i've not seen out and post my thoughts, Sorcerer and Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion in particular are ones i've wanted to see.

[HashtagBrownies]

Also my guess:

Yam - Eraserhead
Citizen - The Warriors (i wouldn't have known this, would have guessed F For Fake)
Cricket - Sorcerer
Raul - The Last Picture Show
Jay Redrum - Fantastic Planet
Joel - Three Days of the Condor
Matt - Harry and Tonto
Hashtag - Kramer vs Kramer
Velvet - Red Psalm
AlexWilder - F For Fake
CaptainT - The Sting
Jeff Costello - Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion
Nestorio - Dog Day Afternoon
ed - What's Up Doc?

The nominations have already been announced.

[Camo]

The nominations have already been announced.

Missed that, took it out.

[HashtagBrownies]

Three Days on the Condor: Heard the title but don't know what it's about. Should be interesting.
Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion, Red Psalm: Never heard of them, but it looks like they'll be a real bitch to find a copy of.
Fantastic Planet: Holy crap, this looks like it will be great. Glad Halloween was replaced with this.
Sorcerer: Found out about it 'cause of a reference on the Simpsons years ago. Looks like it'll be really good.
F for Fake: Most hyped to see this one, it'll be my second Welles film.
Harry and Tonto: I like cats, so I guess I'll like this.
Warriors: Was on my Netflix watch-list for a while, looks like it's time to watch it.

Last Picture Show: Thought it was pretty 'meh', maybe it'll be better on a re-watch.

I'll post my reviews on The Sting, Kramer vs Kramer and Dog Day Afternoon in my own time.

[Camo]

Sorcerer: Found out about it 'cause of a reference on the Simpsons years ago.

What reference?

[HashtagBrownies]

What reference?

The Mr Plow episode, when Homers driving across the crappy, old bridge. I googled 'Simpsons references' one day and it said it was referencing Sorcerer.

[Camo]

The Mr Plow episode, when Homers driving across the crappy, old bridge. I googled 'Simpsons references' one day and it said it was referencing Sorcerer.

Wasn't aware that was a Sorcerer reference. Watch Wages of Fear which Sorcerer is a remake of but not that.

[HashtagBrownies]

Watch Wages of Fear but not that.

I have to though, I'm a part of the HoF! :)

[Camo]

I have to though, I'm a part of the HoF! :)

haha. I meant to say Watched, as in i have watched Wages of Fear but not Sorcerer. I'm familiar with the Hall of Fames haha.

[edarsenal]

The Last Picture Show: Liked this quite a bit but don't remember it that well. I preferred Paper Moon from Bogdanovich which is one of my favourite films.
What's Up Doc?: It's weird that Bogdanovich has two films in this. After loving Paper Moon i ended up watching this and Nickolodeon; had already seen Last Picture Show. I liked this quite well and disliked Nickolodeon.

Seen 9/14. Good bunch, i think it was better i stayed out of it though as i'm trying to cut down on rewatches. Might check a few of the ones i've not seen out and post my thoughts, Sorcerer and Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion in particular are ones i've wanted to see.
pleasantly surprised you enjoyed What's Up, Doc? and Paper Moon WAS on my list for choices; along with Get Carter and The Man Who Would Be King

And CONGRATS to HashtagBrownies for being THE FIRST review of the HoF

I'm about a third into Sorcerer, really enjoying this movie though I may need to find a version with a little better audio, but a helluva movie.

[matt72582]

I liked The Last Picture Show.. I LOVED Paper Moon.. Couldn't stand What's Up Doc?


I didn't see who nominated what...

[Jeff Costello]

edarsenal

Since you mentioned your alternative choices, my original nomination was supposed to be The Tin Drum, Palm d'Or winner from 1979. In the end I decided against it due to some disturbing scenes which I thought would be off-putting to some participants. I wonder if anyone has seen that film and what they thought of it ...

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0078875/?ref_=ttawd_awd_tt

[HashtagBrownies]

edarsenal

Since you mentioned your alternative choices, my original nomination was supposed to be The Tin Drum, Palm d'Or winner from 1979. In the end I decided against it due to some disturbing scenes which I thought would be off-putting to some participants. I wonder if anyone has seen that film and what they thought of it ...

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0078875/?ref_=ttawd_awd_tt

I would've liked to see it.

[Yam12]

I'm probably going to need a link for the two foreign movies. If someone could help me out it would be great.

[Yam12]

Also since you talked about alternatives, my second choice would've been Badlands (1973). It was hard deciding between the two but in the end I went with Eraserhead because I felt that would generate a lot of discussion

[Velvet]

I was thinking salo, the holy mountain, and picnic at hanging rock.

[HashtagBrownies]

I was thinking salo, the holy mountain, and picnic at hanging rock.

I would've preferred any of those over Red Psalm, it's gonna be a chore trying to find a copy of it.

[Velvet]

I got a download

[Citizen Rules]

...I didn't see who nominated what... They're here:
https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?anchor=1&p=1794209#post1794209

and also on the second post, on the 1st page.

I was thinking salo, the holy mountain, and picnic at hanging rock. I thought you might go for Aguirre, the Wrath of God (1972)

Myself, I was thinking of going with The Beguiled (1971) (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?anchor=1&p=1756102#post1756102) as my nomination.

[HashtagBrownies]

I was thinking of going with The Beguiled (1971) (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?anchor=1&p=1756102#post1756102)

I was having a desperate time wondering should I nominate F for Fake or Don't Look Now.

[Velvet]

I saw it over the summer twice so I didnt want to do it again

[Velvet]

I did a blind nomination

[HashtagBrownies]

I saw it over the summer twice so I didnt want to do it again

You wouldn't need to, you'd just have to write your thoughts on it.

[cricket]

They're here:
https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?anchor=1&p=1794209#post1794209

and also on the second post, on the 1st page.

I thought you might go for Aguirre, the Wrath of God (1972)

Myself, I was thinking of going with The Beguiled (1971) (https://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?anchor=1&p=1756102#post1756102) as my nomination.

I might have nominated The Beguiled if you hadn't watched it recently.

[Velvet]

Ik I didnt have to watch it but I wanted to nominate something I havent seen

[Camo]

The best i've got for Red Psalm so far is a link where you'll have to download and add your own subtitles (i could send the ones i already have over the e-mail thing like i did for Citizen, it takes two seconds). It's easy to do i showed Citizen how to and it was no problem, thing is though it's above embedded subtitles from another language which you can't remove. I tried it for maybe a minute, it's not that intrusive that it's unwatchable but i imagine it would hurt your enjoyment somewhat.

If anyone is interested in this PM me.

[Citizen Rules]

I might have nominated The Beguiled if you hadn't watched it recently. That would have been cool. I might have even rewatched it even though I just seen it. Great film that oozes early 70s film making.

Sorcerer sounds pretty damn cool too.
Four unfortunate men from different parts of the globe agree to risk their lives transporting gallons of nitroglycerin across dangerous South American jungle. That alone makes me want to see the movie! And it has Roy Schneider too, who's always intense. Good choice.

[cricket]

I decided to go with something a little more accessible for everyone this time. I had been going with foreign or more artistic movies lately.

[Velvet]

I wanna host a 60s hof

[Jeff Costello]

Did anyone see The Tin Drum (1979) by any chance ?

Also, I will probably need some assistance with finding Harry and Tonto . It is suprisingly difficult to find.

[cricket]

Did anyone see The Tin Drum (1979) by any chance ?

Also, I will probably need some assistance with finding Harry and Tonto . It is suprisingly difficult to find.

I thought it was great and it was another I considered nominating.

[HashtagBrownies]

Official review

36083

Absolutely brilliant. It certainly deserved the Oscar for best original screenplay. John Cazale and Pacino give a brilliant performance, probably my favourite performance by Pacino. The tension and the claustrophobic setting MAKE this film. Lots of comedic relief. Wasn’t at all surprised when I found out it was directed by Sidney Lumet, who directed the masterpieces 12 Angry Men and Network. The relationship between Pacino and his boy/girlfriend is very heartwarming.

Also it has the best fking tagline of all time.
'The robbery should have taken 10 minutes. 4 hours later, the bank was like a circus sideshow. 8 hours later, it was the hottest thing on live T.V. 12 hours later, it was all history. And it's all true.'
If that doesn't hype you up for this film I don't know what will.

4
Might change it to a 4.5 if I'm really generous.

[Jeff Costello]

I thought it was great and it was another I considered nominating.

That was supposed to be my original nomination, but I decided against it because of some disturbing scenes. Cool thing about Tin Drum is that there is one pretty big scene which was shot in my neighborhood.

[cricket]

That was supposed to be my original nomination, but I decided against it because of some disturbing scenes. Cool thing about Tin Drum is that there is one pretty big scene which was shot in my neighborhood.


I have nominated some movies that are more disturbing than that. I wouldn't worry about that one, and it would be a great nomination for the eventual foreign film Hall of Fame.

[CosmicRunaway]

Did anyone see The Tin Drum (1979) by any chance ?
That was supposed to be my original nomination, but I decided against it because of some disturbing scenes.
That was one of the films I was considering nominating, actually. :up:

[cricket]

That was one of the films I was considering nominating, actually. :up:

Did you see that recently? Because I thought you said in the past you hadn't seen it. I could be mistaken.

[CosmicRunaway]

Did you see that recently? Because I thought you said in the past you hadn't seen it. I could be mistaken.
I'm not sure how long ago it was since I have a very poor concept of time. It was within the past couple of months though. I saw someone post about The White Ribbon, so I watched that and The Tin Drum over whichever weekend that was.

[cricket]

I'm not sure how long ago it was since I have a very poor concept of time. It was within the past couple of months though. I saw someone post about The White Ribbon, so I watched that and The Tin Drum over whichever weekend that was.

That makes sense because it's probably been a year since I asked you. I don't see you posting what you watch anywhere.

[Citizen Rules]

@cricket (http://www.movieforums.com/community/member.php?u=68505) @CosmicRunaway (http://www.movieforums.com/community/member.php?u=90868)

Here is the scene I was talking about. Shot in my neighborhood square though it looks drastically different now. My father was actually one of the extras in that scene.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hSU6U1nxhUAWhere is that at? what city?