The MoFo Top Comic Book & Graphic Novel Movies Countdown

[Godoggo]

Addams Family Values was on my list. I also really like Tales From the Crypt.

[TheUsualSuspect]

The Mask is Jim Carrey at the height of his zaniness. Very funny and re-watchable.

It also has Cameron Diaz the hottest she ever has been and ever will be.


Speed Racer is a bluray dream. Beautiful to look at, hyper-kinetic with a poor story. It has some "on in the background" feel to it.

[Mr.Sparkle]

This list is a joke.

Some of the worst movies of ALL-TIME are on this Best of All Time list? Come on people. One man throws a crappy film in his top 5 and all of a sudden it warrants a spot on the list? Maybe films included on the list should have at least a certain number of votes.

Maybe 5 members put one film at their 25th spot, while one joker but a crappy film in his number one spot and that crappy film makes it while the other does not. How is this just?

I hope we start getting to some good films, cause this is embarrassing.

[Sexy Celebrity]

This is not a Best of All Time List. This is a Top Comic Book & Graphic Novel Movies List!


Get it right!

[jiraffejustin]

Sexy Celebrity defending the list is great. Complete turnaround from the other lists.

[jiraffejustin]

This list is a joke.

Some of the worst movies of ALL-TIME are on this Best of All Time list? Come on people. One man throws a crappy film in his top 5 and all of a sudden it warrants a spot on the list? Maybe films included on the list should have at least a certain number of votes.

Maybe 5 members put one film at their 25th spot, while one joker but a crappy film in his number one spot and that crappy film makes it while the other does not. How is this just?

I hope we start getting to some good films, cause this is embarrassing.

If you would have actually voted you might have helped prevent this.

[gandalf26]

Hey Gandalf Man Of Steel will crack the top 20, I know it.

Helped by you putting it at no 1.

[The Rodent]

68

When The Wind Blows

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/WhenTheWindBlows_zpsfe586fcb.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/WhenTheWindBlows_zpsfe586fcb.jpg.html)

1986

Points - 38

Voters - 3/35


67

The Rocketeer

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/TheRocketeer_zpse509f028.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/TheRocketeer_zpse509f028.jpg.html)

1991

Points - 38

Voters - 3/35


66

Heavy Metal

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/HeavyMetal_zps9ead7e9e.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/HeavyMetal_zps9ead7e9e.jpg.html)

1981

Points - 40

Voters - 3/35


65

Mystery Men

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/MysteryMen_zps21889152.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/MysteryMen_zps21889152.jpg.html)

1999

Points - 40

Voters - 3/35

[The Rodent]

This list is a joke.

Some of the worst movies of ALL-TIME are on this Best of All Time list? Come on people. One man throws a crappy film in his top 5 and all of a sudden it warrants a spot on the list? Maybe films included on the list should have at least a certain number of votes.

Maybe 5 members put one film at their 25th spot, while one joker but a crappy film in his number one spot and that crappy film makes it while the other does not. How is this just?

I hope we start getting to some good films, cause this is embarrassing.


Rather than coming in here and slamming everyone else's choices... you should have used the 6 month lead up to put your own list in and gobsmacked us.




Anyway...
Mystery Men is a great film... enjoyed The Rocketeer when I first saw it.
Haven't seen the other two.

[jiraffejustin]

I considered voting for When the Wind Blows and I enjoyed The Rocketeer, but neither made my list.

[Yoda]

Aw. Sad Mystery Men isn't higher. I know it gets panned a lot, but I've never understood that. I can only assume it comes from wanting it to be an action film, even though it's really a comedy. And a really funny one, too.

"We are number one. All others are number two, or lower."

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-IdTHLwoTxFk/UU9XLp9Ot1I/AAAAAAAAEfc/U6ib67Rj-oE/s1600/the_sphinx1.jpg

[The Rodent]

Aha!!


So if I did shorten the list, Mystery Men wouldn't have made it all...


Busted... :D

[Yoda]

A necessary sacrifice. :D

Can't believe only two others even voted for it. I DON'T EVEN KNOW YOU PEOPLE ANY MORE.

[The Rodent]

Bit of a stats thing now...


Tomorrow is 64-61... much of a muchness, with only needing a couple votes to get a film on the list...


... but the Top 60, which starts on Friday (60-57), is a bit of a change.
Bit of a jump in voter numbers (with exception to only one of them), we're looking at 4, 5 and 6 being the minimum amount of votes to get on the list.

[Swan]

I had no idea Mystery Men was based on a comic book, otherwise it would have been on my list, and pretty high up too.

I did have Heavy Metal on my list, at #8.

[linespalsy]

Well, I gave Mystery Men 24 of its points.

[Cobpyth]

I might watch Heavy Metal tonight.

[Yoda]

Well, I gave Mystery Men 24 of its points.
Good man. :up:

Favorite quote? I know, I know, it's unfair to ask anyone to choose.

[cricket]

Heavy Metal was a late cut from my list; it's been a long time, but I liked it.

I put on Mystery Men once, but didn't watch enough for me to even say I saw it.

Seen 6/36
My List 2/36

[linespalsy]

Good man. :up:

Favorite quote? I know, I know, it's unfair to ask anyone to choose.

That's impossible.

-I'm a Pantera's box you do not wanna open.

-Looks like tonight the lone wolf rides alone.

-You dress in the manner of a male prostitute!

-Let's triangulate.
-Equilateral or isosceles?

-When you care what is outside, what is inside cares for you.

Or for some longer ones...

-What vill we do about the greatest superhero Champion City has ever known?
For the answer, I want you all to walk this way.
-Dude, can we bring the brewskis?
-Yes, of course. You may absolutely bring ze brewskis.

-Well, it all started when I was just 13 years of age. One day, while walking with some friends, I accidentally cut the cheese. In my adolescent awkwardness, I blamed it on an old gypsy woman who happened to be passing by. BIG MISTAKE! The gypsy woman placed a curse upon my head. Because I smelled it, she decreed I would forevermore BE HE WHO DEALT IT!

etc.

[gandalf26]

Mystery Men is good fun. Havent watched in years though. Rocketeer was a childhood favourite, although it may not stand up to another viewing.

[wintertriangles]

I had no idea Mystery Men was based on a comic book, otherwise it would have been on my list, and pretty high up too.This

[mark f]

I like Heavy Metal and Mystery Men, but the only one I voted for was The Rocketeer, my #9. That's three from my list.

[The Sci-Fi Slob]

Seen 19/36
My list 2/32

I like The Rocketeer. Mystery Men is bilge, though.

[Guaporense]

I have downloaded When the Wind Blows and I plan to watch Heavy Metal.

[The Rodent]

I had no idea Mystery Men was based on a comic book, otherwise it would have been on my list, and pretty high up too.





Was a Dark Horse comic called Super Carrot Head or something like that...


I honestly thought it was an original script as well until I looked it up.

[Sexy Celebrity]

I HATED Mystery Men.

I so don't agree with that one being on here.

[TheUsualSuspect]

Mystery Men is stupid fun. A pre-famous Dane Cook has a small cameo as the Waffler Man.

[The Gunslinger45]

Alright Heavy Metal made it!

[TokeZa]

I dont know about this list...

I love From Up On Poppy Hill from 2011 and Air Doll by Koreeda looks interesting. Otherwise it look likes movie turds i would a watch as a young kid and never really gotten back to.

I really hope stuff like Akira will be way up high!

I guess it would be ok if a History of Violence and Barbarella also made the list considering how the list looks like now.

[christine]

Lovely to see When The Wind Blows on the list. Such a touching book that is. In fact anything written by Raymond Briggs is awesome - The Snowman, Father Christmas, Ethel and Ernest . My kids favourite when they were little was a pop up Fungus the Bogeyman book, I still have all battered and torn now but it had a well loved life!

[The Rodent]

64

Tekkonkinkreet

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/Tekkonkinkreet_zpsddab33e0.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/Tekkonkinkreet_zpsddab33e0.jpg.html)

2006

Points - 40

Voters - 4/35


63

Only Yesterday

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/OnlyYesterday_zps6c123b1d.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/OnlyYesterday_zps6c123b1d.jpg.html)

1991

Points - 42

Voters - 2/35


62

Popeye

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/Popeye_zps86ab6ec2.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/Popeye_zps86ab6ec2.jpg.html)

1980

Points - 43

Voters - 2/35


61

The Addams Family

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/AddamsFamily_zps70cad9db.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/AddamsFamily_zps70cad9db.jpg.html)

1991

Points - 43

Voters - 4/35

[Sexy Celebrity]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qGb2o_U4kdc

ON MY LIST
Conan the Destroyer -- # 2
Batman & Robin -- # 4
Addams Family Values -- # 8
The Addams Family -- # 9
X-Men: The Last Stand -- # 18
X-Men Origins: Wolverine -- # 19
The Mask -- # 20
Howard the Duck -- # 24

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y6QS-3w0ZQw

[jiraffejustin]

I've seen all four of these, I voted for three of them. I was hoping to see them higher up than this, but I will take what I can get.

MY LIST

#5 - Only Yesterday
#13 - The Addams Family
#20 - Tekkonkinkreet
#23 - The Lone Wolf and Cub: Sword of Vengeance

[Cobpyth]

Only Yesterday is a wonderful film! I didn't know it was based on a Manga.

[The Rodent]

Yep, Manga of the same name by Hotaru Okamoto and Yuko Tone.


A lot of these have opened my eyes to how many are original and how many are based on books and novels. Kinda surprising.

[jiraffejustin]

Sexy gave The Addams Family more points than I did. Good man.

[Deadite]

Tekkonkinkreet was pretty cool. Nice to see it made the list.

[cricket]

I liked The Addams Family; it was one of my last cuts.

[Godoggo]

Tekkonkinkreet was pretty cool. Nice to see it made the list.

I know Jirrafe and I voted for it. Who else did?

[The Rodent]

wintertriangles and sane were the other two who voted for it.

[wintertriangles]

Meeeeee. Same with Only Yesterday

[Godoggo]

I thought those two might be alright. ;)

[wintertriangles]

I HAVE HER ACCEPTANCE. NOW MY MATING DANCE
http://funnyasduck.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/funny-fabulous-bird-animated-gif-pics.gif

[Godoggo]

That's a good start. :D

[Guaporense]

I've seen all four of these, I voted for three of them. I was hoping to see them higher up than this, but I will take what I can get.

MY LIST

#5 - Only Yesterday
#13 - The Addams Family
#20 - Tekkonkinkreet
#23 - The Lone Wolf and Cub: Sword of Vengeance

So it was you who also voted for it. :D I think we put it into similar places. Only Yesterday is in my top 25 favorites, indeed one of the best movies I ever watched.

Tekkonkinkreet looks interesting.

[The Rodent]

60

Blade 2

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/Blade2_zps2e320b51.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/Blade2_zps2e320b51.jpg.html)

2002

Points - 43

Voters - 6/35


59

Ichi The Killer

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/IchiTheKiller_zpsd2a44ba4.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/IchiTheKiller_zpsd2a44ba4.jpg.html)

2001

Points - 44

Voters - 4/35


58

Batman: The Mask Of Phantasm

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/BatmanTheMaskOfPhantasm_zps363f716d.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/BatmanTheMaskOfPhantasm_zps363f716d.jpg.html)

1993

Points - 45

Voters - 5/35


57

Battle Royale

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/BattleRoyale_zpseddcbcb7.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/BattleRoyale_zpseddcbcb7.jpg.html)

2000

Points - 46

Voters - 3/35

[The Gunslinger45]

Blade II is another one from my list!

[The Rodent]

Haven't seen Ichi but the rest are decent. Battle Royale definitely the strongest there.

[The Rodent]

May as well start doing this...

My list so far... only got 3...

1 -
2 -
3 -
4 -
5 -
6 -
7 -
8 -
9 -
10 -
11 -
12 -
13 -
14 -
15 -
16 -
17 -
18 - X-Men: The Last Stand (2006) 80th
19 -
20 -
21 -
22 - Cowboys And Aliens (2011) 91st
23 -
24 - The Addams Family (1991) 61st
25 -

[cricket]

Ichi the Killer is the 3rd one from my list; I had it at #23.

I liked Battle Royale but didn't vote for it.

[jiraffejustin]

I didn't realize Battle Royale was based on a manga. I probably would have watched before the deadline if I had known.

I might have seen Blade II when I was younger, I can't remember anything about it though. I know I have seen Mask of the Phantasm and Ichi the Killer. I don't like MotP as much as the animated series, but it's still a fun watch. I hated Ichi the Killer.

[The Rodent]

Graphic Novel written by Koushun Takami, adapted into Manga again by Takami, then turned into the film, then to Manga again, then had sequels, then back into Manga again :D


One of Japan's highest grossing films too.

[jiraffejustin]

Yeah, the Battle Royale thing was definitely my fault. I am not too worried about it though.

[Swan]

Wow, Battle Royale and Ichi the Killer TOTALLY would have made my list if I knew they were based on mangas! I have a Battle Royale shirt, actually. Great films.

[the samoan lawyer]

i had Ichi 6th on my list and Battle Royale would have been top 5 had i known it was based on manga.

[Sexy Celebrity]

Couldn't get into Blade or Blade II but liked Blade: Trinity for Parker Posey as a vampire, Ryan Reynolds and a Pomeranian vampire.

That one's on my list but it probably won't make it.

[The Rodent]

I liked Blade more than the others. Blade Trinity next.


I thought Blade 2 was the weaker, the CGI wasn't great, or needed tbh. Still enjoyed it though with the twist in the Vamp genetics.

[teeter_g]

I liked the mutated vampires one the second one, but I still think that the first is far superior. If Ryan Reynolds hadn't been in the third I don't know that I would have liked it as much. His character was really funny and made the movie worth watching.

[mark f]

I liked them all (well, Ichi not as much), but Phantasm was the only one I voted for.

[Daniel M]

I also did not realise Battle Royale was based on a Manga and would have had it on my list otherwise.

[TheUsualSuspect]

Seems like battle royale would have placed higher had people known it was a manga.

Loooove Blade II. On par with original.

[The Rodent]

56

Wanted

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/Wanted2008_zpsa017c491.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/Wanted2008_zpsa017c491.jpg.html)

2008

Points - 47

Voters - 7/35


55

Tank Girl

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/TankGirl_zps30694ab6.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/TankGirl_zps30694ab6.jpg.html)

1995

Points - 49

Voters - 4/35


54

The Wolverine

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/XMenTheWolverine_zps76a3e82a.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/XMenTheWolverine_zps76a3e82a.jpg.html)

2013

Points - 49

Voters - 5/35


53

The Incredible Hulk

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/IncredibleHulk_zps0c87f1f3.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/IncredibleHulk_zps0c87f1f3.jpg.html)

2008

Points - 50

Voters - 5/35

[wintertriangles]

Holy horrible

[The Rodent]

But you voted for all 4 of those :D

[wintertriangles]

You're talking to yourself again

[The Rodent]

Am about to watch Incredible Hulk... only one of those 4 I didn't like was Wanted.

[The Rodent]

You're talking to yourself again



Nope. Pretty sure those 4 were your top 4...

[Swan]

I had Wanted on my list, but I only saw it once when it was in theaters. I'm not sure I would like it now. Had The Wolverine on my list too, that one's pretty good.

I didn't put The Incredible Hulk on my list, but I could have. It's not that great but I like it more than some of the movies on my list.

[The Rodent]

The Wolverine is the better of the X Men films. I think with it being a stand alone film based in another part of the world gives it a different edge to the others.
Def my fave of the X films.


Sadly though, I hadn't seen it when I put my list in otherwise it may have cracked my top 10 and got a higher placing on the countdown. I could have edited my list and cheated, but, that wouldn't have been fair.

[gandalf26]

The previous 4 was great, but this one truly sucks balls.

[The Gunslinger45]

The Incredible Hulk was very good. Don't care for or did not see the rest.

[mark f]

I didn't vote for any of those four. :)

[Sexy Celebrity]

55

Tank Girl

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/TankGirl_zps30694ab6.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/TankGirl_zps30694ab6.jpg.html)

1995

Points - 49

Voters - 4/35



*smiles triumphantly*

I was just thinking about this! Wondering if it would make it.

ON MY LIST
Conan the Destroyer -- # 2
Batman & Robin -- # 4
Addams Family Values -- # 8
The Addams Family -- # 9
Tank Girl -- # 17
X-Men: The Last Stand -- # 18
X-Men Origins: Wolverine -- # 19
The Mask -- # 20
Howard the Duck -- # 24

[The Sci-Fi Slob]

Seen 29/48
My List:

11. The Incredible Hulk
16. Superman Returns
18. X-Men The Last Stand

[The Rodent]

Gonna be starting the top 50 in a few minutes... 52-49

[The Rodent]

52

Spider-Man 3

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/SpiderMan3_zpsf42de2ff.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/SpiderMan3_zpsf42de2ff.jpg.html)

2007

Points - 52

Voters - 5/35


51

The Punisher

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/ThePunisher2004_zps44534af9.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/ThePunisher2004_zps44534af9.jpg.html)

2004

Points - 58

Voters - 7/35


50

Porco Rosso

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/Porco_zps286fb1e8.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/Porco_zps286fb1e8.jpg.html)

1992

Points - 59

Voters - 4/35


49

Dick Tracy

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/DickTracy_zps3155a117.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/DickTracy_zps3155a117.jpg.html)

1990

Points - 60

Voters - 6/35

[Masterman]

Yessss, The Punisher was mine, and so was Wanted. :)

[jiraffejustin]

Seen all four of these. The less said about Spider-Man 3 the better.

It's been awhile since I've seen The Punisher, but I remember it being at least good. Didn't vote for it though.

I did however vote for the other two. I am surprised to see Dick Tracy, I thought that if it hadn't shown up yet it just wasn't going to. Thanks to whoever else voted for it.

MY LIST

#5 - Only Yesterday
#6 - Porco Rosso
#13 - The Addams Family
#20 - Tekkonkinkreet
#21 - Dick Tracy
#23 - The Lone Wolf and Cub: Sword of Vengeance

[The Gunslinger45]

Voted for The Punisher

[cricket]

I had The Punisher at #17 and I liked Spidey 3 and Dick Tracy.

[linespalsy]

Battle Royale isn't based on a manga. Both the movie and the manga are adaptations of the novel. The first manga series even came after the movie. (the manga is terrible by the way. Haven't read the novel. The movie is alright but I didn't vote for it.)

Didn't vote for Tekkon Kinkreet (not sure if I even finished it), but the animation is nice. I read the manga when it was first serialized in English in Pulp magazine but that was long enough ago that I'm not sure how I'd rate it. It's worth reading, though.

Ichi the Killer (both the manga and the movie) is ok, but didn't vote for it either.

Along with the ones I've mentioned previously, I voted for Phantasm, Popeye, When the Wind Blows and Memories.

The rest I either think are okay or dislike.

[The Sci-Fi Slob]

Seen 32/52

The Punishers good, but not as good as the Dolph Lundgren version:D. I'm shocked to see Spider-man 3 on the list at all.:facepalm:
Dick Tracy isn't bad; not seen it in ages. Haven't seen Porco Rosso.

[Swan]

Seen 21 now.

[Cobpyth]

Love Porco Rosso (didn't know it was based on a graphic novel) and really like Dick Tracy.

[The Gunslinger45]

Seen 28 so far.

[seanc]

Spider-Man 3 is one of the worst movies I have ever seen. Wish I would have scanned the lists one more time because Porco Rosso probably would have been in my top 10.

[The Rodent]

I was surprised with Spidey 3 tbh... it didn't look like it was going to show then suddenly it shot up the list... must be a fave of some.

[Sexy Celebrity]

TEN movies from my list! All before #50!!!!

I had Spider-Man 3 at #7. I like the movie.

ON MY LIST
Conan the Destroyer -- # 2
Batman & Robin -- # 4
Spider-Man 3 -- #7
Addams Family Values -- # 8
The Addams Family -- # 9
Tank Girl -- # 17
X-Men: The Last Stand -- # 18
X-Men Origins: Wolverine -- # 19
The Mask -- # 20
Howard the Duck -- # 24

[The Sci-Fi Slob]

I had Spider-Man 3 at #7. I like the movie.



I might have known...:p

[wintertriangles]

Sexy has ruined what could have been a marginally passable list

[The Rodent]

Not to worry wint... we start the Top 40 on Wednesday... the next 8 are interesting though, will raise a few eyebrows.

[Sexy Celebrity]

Sexy has ruined what could have been a marginally passable list

I'm very proud of myself.

[The Rodent]

48

Hugo

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/Hugo_zpsa692200d.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/Hugo_zpsa692200d.jpg.html)

2011

Points - 66

Voters - 4/35


47

Where The Wild Things Are

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/WhereTheWildThingsAre_zpsc5d8bfa0.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/WhereTheWildThingsAre_zpsc5d8bfa0.jpg.html)

2009

Points - 75

Voters - 5/35


46

Hellboy 2: The Golden Army

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/Hellboy2_zpsed0d759c.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/Hellboy2_zpsed0d759c.jpg.html)

2008

Points - 78

Voters - 6/35


45

American Splendor

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/AmericanSplendor_zpsbb915529.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/AmericanSplendor_zpsbb915529.jpg.html)

2003

Points - 78

Voters - 6/35

[wintertriangles]

Acceptable. Who else voted for Wild Things?

[The Rodent]

The other 4 were sarah f, Godoggo, Holden, and lines

[TheUsualSuspect]

We're counting children's books as comics?

[The Rodent]

Linespalsy was the first to vote for Wild Things, and I said no to it initially... then he asked me to check on it.


After an hour of research, I found that Picture Books are part of the same media as Comics and Graphic Novels.
This was explained in the original thread after lines and I had a PM session between us.

[TheUsualSuspect]

SC is the Armond White of movie forums. Ha.

[TheUsualSuspect]

I don't read rules come on!!!

[The Rodent]

:D


Nobody does.


I had most people not including dates on the films to decipher between originals and retakes (things like The Punisher and The Punisher) and had to keep asking people which one of the films they were voting for.


Meant overall, I had to research every film that was entered on its first time, to get the dates.

[Swan]

Yes! Hellboy II: The Golden Army was #10 on my list. The only reason it's so low is because I wanted to separate it and Hellboy, which I put much higher.

Love the Hellboy movies.

[cricket]

American Splendor is the 5th movie from my list to appear; I had it at #24.

[seanc]

I read the rules and went through the lists three times and still managed to miss some good stuff. I would have voted for Hugo. I did vote for American Splendor. The first movie I really noticed Giamatti in and he has become one of my faves. Love that movie.

[The Gunslinger45]

Hugo counted? DAMMIT! I should have voted for it!

I blame myself.

[Sexy Celebrity]

Yet another one from my list! American Splendor. At #12.

ON MY LIST
Conan the Destroyer -- # 2
Batman & Robin -- # 4
Spider-Man 3 -- #7
Addams Family Values -- # 8
The Addams Family -- # 9
American Splendor -- # 12
Tank Girl -- # 17
X-Men: The Last Stand -- # 18
X-Men Origins: Wolverine -- # 19
The Mask -- # 20
Howard the Duck -- # 24

And I DESPISE Where The Wild Things Are.

One of the worst movie theater viewing experiences I have ever had.

A total annoying sap fest.

[mark f]

And I DESPISE Where The Wild Things Are.
Sexy and his perception again. :)

[Sexy Celebrity]

SC is the Armond White of movie forums. Ha.

Well, Armond and I are possibly the only two people on Earth that liked Jack and Jill.

Armond White's review of Jack and Jill. (http://cityarts.info/2011/11/11/plumbing-ethnicity-sandler%E2%80%99s-jack-jill-and-tyler-perry/)

[jiraffejustin]

I voted for both Hugo and American Splendor. Great films.


MY LIST

#5 - Only Yesterday
#6 - Porco Rosso
#13 - The Addams Family
#17 - Hugo
#20 - Tekkonkinkreet
#21 - Dick Tracy
#22 - American Splendor
#23 - The Lone Wolf and Cub: Sword of Vengeance

[donniedarko]

I've hardly seen any of the films on this list, but Hugo Is Great :up:

[Sane]

From my list:

5. American Splendor
6. Hugo
8. From Up on Poppy Hill
12. When the Wind Blows
19. Tekkonkinkreet

[Holden Pike]

Hey, you finally made it to the top fifty, and I can start giving half a crap! Hooray? Not even going to bother and go back and read what was said about the likes of The Green fu*king Lantern and Tank Girl, but I will say which titles from my list have been revealed, thus far...

70. Addams Family Values (#16, ten points)
67. The Rocketeer (#8, eighteen points)
65. Mystery Men (#23, three points)
61. The Addams Family (#15, eleven points)
49. Dick Tracy (#25, one point)
48. Hugo (#10, sixteen points)
47. Where the Wild Things Are (#2, twenty-four points)
45. American Splendor (#9, seventeen points)

http://www.movieforums.com/community/attachment.php?attachmentid=13644&stc=1&d=1397514762

[The Rodent]

Finally got to the top 50? Other countdowns take near a month to get to the top 50... I've taken two weeks...


4 per day, Dude... gets it done quicker... and gets the ball rolling to the Top 20 faster too.

[Holden Pike]

Finally got to the top 50? Other countdowns take near a month to get to the top 50... I've taken two weeks...4 per day, Dude... gets it done quicker... and gets the ball rolling to the Top 20 faster too.

Oh, sorry. To be clear, I mean "finally" as in, we have finally moved past the fifty films you shouldn't have even considered revealing as part of the official countdown, and which won't appear on the lists section. And now I can start reading the thread as the films are revealed, instead of ignoring it.

So..yippee! Finally.

[The Rodent]

I made a bit of an error, but, people will remember this list... :D

[Holden Pike]

Not 51-100, they won't. I won't. But now, on with the opera....

[The Rodent]

I get it... your films are only in the Top 50... so that when you start paying attention :D


Glory Hunter... :D

[Sexy Celebrity]

Oh, sorry. To be clear, I mean "finally" as in, we have finally moved past the fifty films you shouldn't have even considered revealing as part of the official countdown, and which won't appear on the lists section.

They better appear on the lists section. That's absolutely foul if they don't.

[Holden Pike]

I get it... your films are only in the Top 50... so that when you start paying attention :D
Glory Hunter... :D


Nope, apparently you still don't get it, but I'm way past explaining it to you, again. At least you can admit it was a mistake.

And I will look forward to tomorrow's reveals. :)

[The Rodent]

I think after the list Is done and I reveal the missed-outs, (101-155), Yoda should include them in the final list in the list section :D


Just to pee Holden off.

[Godoggo]

Yes! Hellboy II: The Golden Army was #10 on my list. The only reason it's so low is because I wanted to separate it and Hellboy, which I put much higher.

Love the Hellboy movies.

Both made my list too. :)
Was kind of expecting Where the Wild Things Are to be higher, actually. I have come to absolutely love that movie.

[Guaporense]

Tons of great movies in there. Some mediocre ones and some very poor movies like Spider Man 3.

[Guaporense]

I think after the list Is done and I reveal the missed-outs, (101-155), Yoda should include them in the final list in the list section :D


Just to pee Holden off.

I guess Yoda should include this top 100, just because it has a ton of movies that are great but relatively obscure in these parts (like the ones I put in).

[Sexy Celebrity]

Tons of great movies in there. Some mediocre ones and some very poor movies like Where The Wild Things Are.

I agree.

[the samoan lawyer]

I cant believe people are still complaining!? Get over it Holden.

Keep her lit Rodent.

[The Rodent]

44

Man Of Steel

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/ManOfSteel_zpsc7cb5b94.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/ManOfSteel_zpsc7cb5b94.jpg.html)

2013

Points - 80

Voters - 8/35


43

Superman 2

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/Superman2_zpsb0b8a361.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/Superman2_zpsb0b8a361.jpg.html)

1980

Points - 82

Voters - 7/35


42

Whisper Of The Heart

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/WhisperOfTheHeart_zps5e1d59d3.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/WhisperOfTheHeart_zps5e1d59d3.jpg.html)

1995

Points - 87

Voters - 4/35


41

Conan The Barbarian

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/ConanTheBarbarian_zpscebd7b74.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/ConanTheBarbarian_zpscebd7b74.jpg.html)

1982

Points - 88

Voters - 4/35

[Swan]

Man of Steel was bad.

[TheUsualSuspect]

It wasn't bad. It redundant.

[Yoda]

I liked that they tried to incorporate some philosophical sparring into it. And I appreciated its sense of scale. Didn't love it, but I can't help but feel the people who hated it were letting high expectations spoil what was there.

I'd be down for another, for sure. There's potential there.

[The Sci-Fi Slob]

And I DESPISE Where The Wild Things Are.

One of the worst movie theater viewing experiences I have ever had.

A total annoying sap fest.

I watched it in the cinema with my sister and two nephews. I tried to keep a straight face and pretended i was enjoying it (seeing as it was my idea to watch it) but every time I looked at them they were laughing their heads off. At least we all had a good laugh.:D

[rauldc14]

Don't think Man of Steel was bad. Then again I feed off of films that people think are bad.

[cricket]

Superman 2 is the 6th movie from my list; I had it at #9.

I like Conan the Barbarian but I like The Destroyer more.

[mark f]

Conan the Barbarian got 20 pts. from me, and considering it got 68 other pts. from three other people, the four of us all love it and the rest of you either haven't seen it or have your heads in a very dark place. :cool:

[The Rodent]

Yeah, Barbarian got 20, 20, 23 and 25...


Got a feeling that makes it one of the only films to be in the top 10 on 100% of its votes.

[Sexy Celebrity]

Another movie! Conan the Barbarian. My #1 movie! It's like everyday now there's a movie from my list.

ON MY LIST
Conan the Barbarian -- # 1
Conan the Destroyer -- # 2
Batman & Robin -- # 4
Spider-Man 3 -- #7
Addams Family Values -- # 8
The Addams Family -- # 9
American Splendor -- # 12
Tank Girl -- # 17
X-Men: The Last Stand -- # 18
X-Men Origins: Wolverine -- # 19
The Mask -- # 20
Howard the Duck -- # 24

[The Rodent]

I've got 5 so far... the last 4 were two of my picks...


1 -
2 -
3 -
4 -
5 -
6 -
7 - Superman 2 (1980)
8 -
9 -
10 -
11 -
12 -
13 -
14 -
15 -
16 - Man Of Steel (2013)
17 -
18 - X-Men: The Last Stand (2006)
19 -
20 -
21 -
22 - Cowboys And Aliens (2011)
23 -
24 - The Addams Family (1991)
25 -

[Camo]

Finally one of mine turns up. I had Superman 2 at 14, it's always been my favourite Superman film. The only other film i have seen there is Conan and i can't stand either of them.

Seen - 15/60
List - 1/25

[The Rodent]

Top 40 starts tomorrow...
Big jump in voter numbers and points too. We're jumping from 88 points minimum, to needing over 100 to make the list...


I think tomorrow's 40-37 will surprise a few of you though...

[The Rodent]

I was kinda surprised how little votes Superman 2 got... 7 people yet only 82 points...


I was expecting top 20 for Supes 2 tbh.


On the other hand though, Man Of Steel is higher than I thought it would be. I thought between 80 and 100, yet it got more votes (less points but more votes) than Superman 2.

[Voigan]

I though MOS would make the list but I didn't think it would this high. :( Ah well. At least Superman II made the list as well. Love that movie.

[The Gunslinger45]

I am SO happy Superman II beat out Man of Steel!

[mark f]

You can thank me for the three pts. I gave Superman II. :)

[jiraffejustin]

I haven't seen Superman II, I have seen Man of Steel. I wasn't expecting much from Man of Steel, and I got a little bit less than that. Conan the Barbarian was fun for the first 30 minutes or so, but it just overstayed it's welcome for me.

Whisper of the Heart is a brilliant film. I gave it 25 points.


MY LIST

#1 - Whisper of the Heart (#42)
#5 - Only Yesterday (#63)
#6 - Porco Rosso (#50)
#13 - The Addams Family (#61)
#17 - Hugo (#48)
#20 - Tekkonkinkreet (#64)
#21 - Dick Tracy (#49)
#22 - American Splendor (#45)
#23 - The Lone Wolf and Cub: Sword of Vengeance (#81)

[Holden Pike]

Conan the Barbarian got 20 pts. from me, and considering it got 68 other pts. from three other people, the four of us all love it and the rest of you either haven't seen it or have your heads in a very dark place. :cool:

John Milius' Conan the Barbarian got twenty-three pojnts from me (third on my list). That it isn't way up near the top and utter dogsh!t like Man of Steel continues to pop up is just sad. And that we are nearly to the top forty and it still only takes four people voting for something to get it on the list is kinda sad. But, better than the films on the list that only one person voted for. Four times as good, by my math.

But party on.

http://www.movieforums.com/community/attachment.php?attachmentid=13660&stc=1&d=1397599174

[The Rodent]

So what's the minimum amount of votes you think should be needed to get on a list?


We had 35 lists entered for this one... so, what, 20? If that was the case this would be a 6 month build up for a Top 10.

[gandalf26]

To all those who voted for Man of ****;


http://images3.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20081022010108/uncyclopedia/images/5/56/YouSuck.jpg






http://memecrunch.com/meme/79L9/you-suck/image.png


http://images.sodahead.com/polls/002011215/4257592097_you_suck1_xlarge.jpeg


http://www.gifsforum.com/images/gif/you%20suck/grand/you-suck-eccbc87e4b5ce2fe28308fd9f2a7baf3-1248.gif


http://distractedpersons.files.wordpress.com/2012/05/you-suck.jpg


http://www.reactiongifs.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/you-suck.gif


http://troll.me/images/barack-obama/dude-you-suck.jpg


http://fc06.deviantart.net/fs70/i/2012/072/e/8/you_suck_logo_by_urbinator17-d4sld2j.png


http://s3.amazonaws.com/rapgenius/you_suck_at_life.jpg


http://www.peoriadefense.com/photo_host/TheJessicaAlbaExperiment_A970/DavidHasselhoffsaysyousuck.jpg


http://cdn.meme.li/i/jsz2c.jpg


that is all

[Sexy Celebrity]

That was WAY too many graphics just to insult one little movie.

[Sane]

Yes, Man of Steel was bad but lets focus on positives. Whisper of the Heart is a fantastic film. Number 2 on my list :)

[rauldc14]

What were you all expecting Man Of steel to be? An academy award winner?

[Sane]

What were you all expecting Man Of steel to be? An academy award winner?
There's a lot of ground in between what it was and an Academy Award winner. Thor was a good movie, The Avengers was good, The first two Dark Knight films were good, all the Iron Man's were pretty good, etc. That's what I expected but what we got was buildings being knocked over and horribly manipulative scenes involving kids, dogs and, worst of all, Kevin Costner ;)

[rauldc14]

Since nobody likes it I can't nominate it for the 4th MOFO Hall of fame. Darn

[Sane]

Since nobody likes it I can't nominate it for the 4th MOFO Hall of fame. Darn
Well, you can but I don't think it would do too well ...

Seriously, I wouldn't have a problem with watching it again if you wanted to nominate it. I didn't think much of it but it wasn't the worst film of last year. It was better that Oz the Great and Powerful and RIPD :)

[rauldc14]

My last post was pure sarcasm:D

[The Rodent]

I liked Man Of Steel, obviously as I had it on my list.
Hated it to start with but MOS is what a Superman film should be. Super burly battles etc.


Maybe they should have put a musical number in the middle like Donner did in '78.


People forget that Donner's film was an original take... Man Of Steel is the same.
Yet nobody compares Donner's films to the original source, nor to the many, many TV Series's's's and films that came before it, but they compare MOS to Donner's.


Man Of Steel is a case of selective memory, I guess.

[The Rodent]

The other thing with Man Of Steel with comparing it to Donner's films... studios tried to emulate Donner with Superman Returns.
And that really was a pile of poo.


What would people prefer... yet another Superman Returns... or the original take called Man Of Steel?

[wintertriangles]

I'd prefer Superman die off, he's a super boring character

[mark f]

I think the newer Superman films are compared to the '78 one for two reasons. The original had hokey, but charming F/X and the even-more-charming Christopher Reeve. It was also actually fun.The newer ones have CGI to burn, but they're lacking in any charm and seem to take themselves too seriously. I didn't dislike the newer films either but was comparatively underwhelmed.

[JayDee]

Just catching up a bit. So far I've seen 28 of those listed, and so far only 2 from my list - Hellboy II and Batman: Mask of the Phantasm.

I didn't realise Hugo would have been eligible. Great little film although I wouldn't have voted for it as I was sticking pretty much to just superheroes.

***SELF-ADVERTISING ALERT*** Just earlier on tonight I actually posted a review of Hugo for anyone who might be interested. :p

The Wolverine is def the best X film so far... I'd put X3 second, then X2, X1, First Class then have Origins last...

Wow Rodent we're usually quite simpatico but you've got strange taste when it comes to X-Men movies. :D I watched The Wolverine just before submitting my list and I thought it was decent but a little lifeless surprisingly. X-Men 3 I thought was a complete mess. It had two stories that could have made for interesting films (Dark Phoenix and the mutant cure) but by trying to squeeze both of them into the one film neither was dealt with satisfactorily. Oh yeah and Vinne Jones. :facepalm:

For me it would go to X2, First Class, X-Men, The Wolverine, X-Men 3, Origins


Oh yeah and Man of Steel sucks! :p

[Masterman]

yessssssssaa, Man Of Steel makes the list. Hey, Gandalf did you see that, it cracked the top 50.

http://certificationmap.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/08/happy-face-istock-456-300x200.jpg
http://www.teachthought.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/happy-dog-300x200.jpg

[gandalf26]

There is a special place in Hell for you Masterman.

[Masterman]

There is a special place in Hell for you Masterman.

Ouch!!. Ime actually surprised it didn't finish in top 20.

[Zotis]

Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex Solid State Society but no original Ghost in the Shell?

...

Lost interest.

[jiraffejustin]

Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex Solid State Society but no original Ghost in the Shell?

...

Lost interest.

lol that's still to come.

[Zotis]

Okay... I've re-read the first post... my deduction is that it's based off votes from the senders listed. But the results so far are so all over the place with decent films and crappy films all mixed up in seemingly no order...

[Yoda]

Okay... I've re-read the first post... my deduction is that it's based off votes from the senders listed. But the results so far are so all over the place with decent films and crappy films all mixed up in seemingly no order...
There's no mystery about it. :) We make these lists all the time and the process for this one is detailed here:

http://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?t=33164

[teeter_g]

The fact that I completely forgot to put Man of Steel on my list infuriates me.

Here is my list so far:

1. Green Lantern (2011) - - 78
2.
3.
4. Tank Girl (1995) - - 55
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12. Wanted (2008) - - 56
13. Spawn (1997) - - 77
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21. The Punisher (2004) - - 51
22.
23.
24.
25.

[Zotis]

Thanks Yoda, and I would suggest putting that link in the first post of every one of these threads for the future. I mean that is the norm for these types of things so that confusion is avoided for newcomers. :)

[Yoda]

Hmmm, I figured the list of all the "voters" he mentioned in the first post makes this fairly plain, though I guess it wouldn't hurt. Anyway, that'll be the list organizer's call. :)

[Zotis]

Yeah, I should have asked for it from the beginning actually. Or done a search.

[Holden Pike]

Yeah, I should have asked for it from the beginning actually. Or done a search.
http://www.movieforums.com/community/attachment.php?attachmentid=13671&stc=1&d=1397660939

Here ya go, Zotis, you can be part of the MoFo Top 100 of the 1970s (http://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?t=35063) list. Those ballots aren't due until July 15th. :D

Click HERE! (http://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?t=35063)

.

[Zotis]

Why thank you Holden Pike, I'm honored. :D

[The Rodent]

40

Ghost In The Shell

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/GhostInTheShell_zpseffbe6a1.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/GhostInTheShell_zpseffbe6a1.jpg.html)

1995

Points - 88

Voters - 5/35


39

Iron Man 3

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/IronMan3_zpse4b919e2.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/IronMan3_zpse4b919e2.jpg.html)

2013

Points - 102

Voters - 11/35


38

Captain America: The First Avenger

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/CaptainAmerica_zps0ac03829.jpg

2011

Points - 102

Voters - 11/35


37

The Amazing Spider-Man

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/AmazingSpiderMan_zps9a02959e.jpg

2012

Points - 103

Voters - 9/35

[rauldc14]

Why is Captain America ahead of Iron Man 3? Just curious.

[jiraffejustin]

speak of the devil

[The Rodent]

There were a couple ties on points and votes... those two were one of those ties.


I had to do something to get an order for them... that was what came out of the hat.

[The Rodent]

Late today... been sick again all day and photobucket crashed on me earlier as well so I couldn't get the pics uploaded.

[Sexy Celebrity]

Disappointing! Nothing from my list today.

[jiraffejustin]

I still haven't seen the last two Iron-Man movies. I saw Captain America during a hospital visit, I couldn't get into it. Maybe the circumstances had something to do with it? Or maybe it just isn't very good. The only thing I cared about in The Amazing Spider-Man was looking at Emma Stone.

Ghost in the Shell is the only in the group that I voted for. As far as animated action films, this is probably my favorite.

MY LIST

#1 - Whisper of the Heart (#42)
#4 - Ghost in the Shell (#40)
#5 - Only Yesterday (#63)
#6 - Porco Rosso (#50)
#13 - The Addams Family (#61)
#17 - Hugo (#48)
#20 - Tekkonkinkreet (#64)
#21 - Dick Tracy (#49)
#22 - American Splendor (#45)
#23 - The Lone Wolf and Cub: Sword of Vengeance (#81)

[The Rodent]

Amazing was on my list, had it at 5th.


Seen the others but didn't vote for any of them. Liked them though.

[rauldc14]

The marvel universe is vastly superior to the other things on this list. Some of them aren't great films, but sure are fun to watch.

[The Rodent]

The marvel universe is vastly superior to the other things on this list. Some of them aren't great films, but sure are fun to watch.


I only had a couple Marvel films. ^Amazing Spidey^ was one, and a couple X Men films. X Men 3 has already been revealed as well.


My mainstream comic films were mainly DC.


Kinda gutted Amazing didn't place higher though.

[rauldc14]

I haven't seen Amazing, much because I was one of the few that enjoyed the original trilogy.

[The Rodent]

Amazing is brilliant. Better than Raimi's and Garfield is a better Parker than Maguire.


Looking forward to Amazing 2 if it's as good as the first one.

[cricket]

I love the Iron Man films; I had part 3 at #8, the 7th film from my list.

[The Rodent]

My List...


1 -
2 -
3 -
4 -
5 - The Amazing Spider-Man (2012)
6 -
7 - Superman 2 (1980)
8 -
9 -
10 -
11 -
12 -
13 -
14 -
15 -
16 - Man Of Steel (2013)
17 -
18 - X-Men: The Last Stand (2006)
19 -
20 -
21 -
22 - Cowboys And Aliens (2011)
23 -
24 - The Addams Family (1991)
25 -

[Zotis]

At the risk of sounding stupid for asking an obvious question, I just want to be sure. You're allowed to divulge your answers once the films that you divulge have been revealed?

[The Rodent]

Yes... revealing your lists beforehand just defeats the purpose of having a Countdown as people could potentially put two and two together and get the final results and spoil the surprises.


If you want to ping up a list of your own on here, kind of a "this is what I would have voted if I'd entered a list"... it'd be fine :)

[Camo]

The only one i have watched there is Amazing Spiderman, and i personally couldn't stand it. I'd say i even preferred Spiderman 3. I'll watch Iron Man 3 at some point as i enjoyed the first two.

[Voigan]

TASM is the only one of these four I've seen and I didn't think much of it. It wasn't terrible but it so bloody generic and paint by the numbers that I'd forgotten 90% of the movie half an hour after I saw it.

Nice to GITS made it into the top 50. I meant to watch it before turning my list in but never got around to it due to a huge pile of schoolwork.

[Zotis]

Yes... revealing your lists beforehand just defeats the purpose of having a Countdown as people could potentially put two and two together and get the final results and spoil the surprises.

If you want to ping up a list of your own on here, kind of a "this is what I would have voted if I'd entered a list"... it'd be fine :)

Thanks, I'll do that.

Ghost in the Shell will be very high on my list, but Iron Man 3, Captain America: The First Avenger, and The Amazing Spider-Man will not be appearing, sorry.

[mark f]

No need to apologize since none of those films appeared on even a third of the lists. :)

[Zotis]

They're still fairly highly ranked and appeared way more than Ghost in the Shell, or most if not all of the movies I'll list.

[Sane]

I didn't vote for any of those but have seen them all. Watched GitS twice but couldn't really get into it. Not sure why. Saw Iron Man 3 after making my list - may have snuck in at about 25. It was my favourite of that trilogy. I turned Captain America off after 20 minutes and have never wanted to go back. Not sure if it was the film's fault or mine but I will probably give it another go before seeing the new one. I really liked the start of TASM but then it got pretty standard. However, I have new appreciation for it since watching the first two Maguire movies - it's way better than them.

[wintertriangles]

Amazing is brilliant. Better than Raimi's and Garfield is a better Parker than Maguire.


Looking forward to Amazing 2 if it's as good as the first one.Agreed with this although I wouldn't use the word brilliant.

Pretty bummed that these newer Marvel films are so high.

[Zotis]

I would just like to point out that Vampire Hunter D is based on a series of Novels and the manga came out in 2007.


My List
1. Ghost in the Shell (1995)
2. Akira (1988)
3. Lone Wolf and Cub: Baby Cart in Peril (1972)
4. Lone Wolf and Cub: Sword of Vengence (1972)
5. Lone Wolf and Cub: Baby Cart at the River Styx (1972)
6. Lone Wolf and Cub: Baby Cart in the Land of Demons (1973)
7. Lone Wolf and Cub: White Heaven in Hell (1974)
8. Oldboy (2003)
9. Ichi the Killer (2001)
10. Watchmen (2009)
11. Appleseed (1988)
12. Spider-Man (2002)
13. Heavy Metal (1981)
14. Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind (1984)
15. Azumi (2003)
16. Mystery Men (1999)
17. Ghost World (2001)
18. Sin City (2005)
19. V for Vendetta (2005)
20. Kick-Ass 2 (2013)
21. Road to Perdition (2002)
22. Battle Royal (2000)
23. Fist of the North Star (1986)
24. A History of Violence (2005)
25. From Hell (2001)

[The Rodent]

Vampire Hunter D was a novel, yes... light novel... which is a Japanese graphic novel and Manga combined.


Nice list though, Zotis.

[Zotis]

Hmm... in that case I'd knock off From Hell and insert Vampire Hunter D at #18. And thank you for the very nice compliment sir. :)

[The Rodent]

:) No probs, it is a nice list though.


Doing this list has given me a broader knowledge of comics and Mangas, graphic novels and other media that are branches of those circles.


I was surprised how little I knew 6 months ago when I started taking entries. I was expecting the regulars like Superman films and Spider-Man films and so on, maybe a few well known graphic novels as well like 300 or Sin City, but when I started getting stuff like the various Lone Wolf And Cub films, and others like the various Anime films, and I started researching them to check eligibility for the list, it opened my eyes to how many thousands of films would count in this list.

[rauldc14]

This list can certainly not be a check off list. I know I voted for these two, but Cowboys and Aliens and Wanted do not deserve to be on a check off list. It's just I couldn't think of anything to fill in the end of my list.

[The Rodent]

Well, I said before if Yods wants to drop the bottom end and use the top 60, or top 50 or 40 or so I'd be cool with it.

[Zotis]

Well I would say hundreds, not thousands. I was actually surprised by how few mangas were adapted to film. They tend to go to OVA's or Series. Although I am not sure where the line is drawn between OVA and film, but OVA's tend to be shorter. If a semi-graphic novel counts, perhaps an OVA does? If that were the case my list would change drastically.

Dragon's Heaven (1988) for example is only thirty minutes long, but it is based off an manga by the same name.

[Sane]

This list can certainly not be a check off list. I know I voted for these two, but Cowboys and Aliens and Wanted do not deserve to be on a check off list. It's just I couldn't think of anything to fill in the end of my list.
Yeah but they were better than Rocky IV ... much better. So I don't think quality should be the only decider in this regard.

[mark f]

http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lu8n51M0DJ1qkh90vo1_500.gif

[The Gunslinger45]

Iron Man 3 and Captain america makes two from my list.

[Sane]

http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lu8n51M0DJ1qkh90vo1_500.gif
:D


The movie in which not only was Brigitte Nielsen not the worst actor ... she was actually the best :eek:

[Zotis]

I have avoided all of the Rocky and Rambo movies. I've never seen a single one.

[Sane]

I have avoided all of the Rocky and Rambo movies. I've never seen a single one.
You aren't missing much ;)


To be honest the first Rocky is pretty decent and from memory I didn't mind the most recent one - or the most recent Rambo movie. Apart from those the rest are all awful IMO. Not really my type of movies though - others like them.

[Godoggo]

Both Ghost in the Shell and The Amazing Spider-Man are on my list.

[JayDee]

Wow! So from the first 60 films on the list only 2 were from my own personal list. Then from that last set I had 3!!! Captain America, Amazing Spider-Man and Iron Man 3.

[rauldc14]

Most of everyone's films will make the list. 17 sad points was the cut off, meaning everyone's top 9 made it, and probably 90% of everyone's personal lists will make it. No shocker.

[rauldc14]

I have avoided all of the Rocky and Rambo movies. I've never seen a single one.

I hadn't till I saw Rocky last week, and it was good.

[Guaporense]

Rocky is a classic. Even Rocky IV is a classic of cheese.

[Zotis]

The first Rocky is the only one I've heard anything about that makes me consider watching it. But nothing that would give me an extra nudge. For starters, I don't like Salvester Stalone, and secondly I don't like boxing.

[Guaporense]

I would just like to point out that Vampire Hunter D is based on a series of Novels and the manga came out in 2007.
My List
1. Ghost in the Shell (1995)
2. Akira (1988)
3. Lone Wolf and Cub: Baby Cart in Peril (1972)
4. Lone Wolf and Cub: Sword of Vengence (1972)
5. Lone Wolf and Cub: Baby Cart at the River Styx (1972)
6. Lone Wolf and Cub: Baby Cart in the Land of Demons (1973)
7. Lone Wolf and Cub: White Heaven in Hell (1974)
8. Oldboy (2003)
9. Ichi the Killer (2001)
10. Watchmen (2009)
11. Appleseed (1988)
12. Spider-Man (2002)
13. Heavy Metal (1981)
14. Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind (1984)
15. Azumi (2003)
16. Mystery Men (1999)
17. Ghost World (2001)
18. Sin City (2005)
19. V for Vendetta (2005)
20. Kick-Ass 2 (2013)
21. Road to Perdition (2002)
22. Battle Royal (2000)
23. Fist of the North Star (1986)
24. A History of Violence (2005)
25. From Hell (2001)

Interesting that you rank Spider Man so high. I haven't watched the Lone Wolf and Cub films but I have read the manga and it ranks among the best stuff I have ever read. You don't like the non-violent Ghibli films based on graphic novels like Porco Rosso, Whisper of the Heart and Only Yesterday?

[Zotis]

I haven't seen Porco Rosso or Only Yesterday, but Whisper of the Heart I liked, just not as much as the ones I listed.

I actually liked the 2002 Spider-Man a lot. It is a very romantic film. Kirsten Dunst was my third celebrity crush after Kate Beckinsale and Claire Danes. But to be honest I don't like putting prioritization on ordering. I don't like trying to gauge if a film is slightly better than another or if I like it slightly more or less. One day I could "feel" like it's a bit more, another day I could "feel" like it's a bit less. I think it's kind of immature to put so much emphasis on such superficial evaluations that I'm not even qualified to make. Typically I rate my films by tiers. So I have like a top 10 or 15 tier, a top 50 tier, a top 100, etc... but within each tier I place them in no particular order.

I tried to structure this list in order to the best of my abilities, but if you really ask me, I do not value a movie one or two points higher on the list more than a movie one or two points lower. It was easier with this kind of list though because the genre is more exclusive.

[The Rodent]

36

Blue Is The Warmest Colour

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/BlueIsTheWarmestColour_zps60e50deb.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/BlueIsTheWarmestColour_zps60e50deb.jpg.html)

2013

Points - 105

Voters - 6/35


35

Scott Pilgrim Vs The World

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/ScottPilgrim_zps36ed5a8c.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/ScottPilgrim_zps36ed5a8c.jpg.html)

2010

Points - 106

Voters - 9/35


34

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/TMNT_zps1bd1a5a5.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/TMNT_zps1bd1a5a5.jpg.html)

1990

Points - 115

Voters - 9/35


33

Ghost World

http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q552/The-Rodent/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/GhostWorld_zps435db0ef.jpg (http://s1163.photobucket.com/user/The-Rodent/media/MoFo%20Comic%20And%20Graphic%20Headers/GhostWorld_zps435db0ef.jpg.html)

2001

Points - 116

Voters - 8/35

[Masterman]

The Avengers better not get into the top 10.

[The Gunslinger45]

TMNT is another one on my list.

[Swan]

Blue is the Warmest Color was my #1. Fantastic movie.

Scott Pilgrim vs. the World was #6 on my list.

[-KhaN-]

Ok,got some movies in my list.

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.Man of Steel
13.
14.
15.
16.The Wolverine
17.Iron Man 3
18.
19.
20.
21.Captain America
22.
23.
24.
25.Blade II

[Godoggo]

Ghost World was high on my list.

I haven't seen Blue is the Warmest Color yet, but I have read the graphic novel. It's only alright as a graphic novel but I do see potential for a really good movie in there.

[Sexy Celebrity]

That's more like it. Two more from my list!

I'm very disappointed, though, that Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles II won't make it. I think on an earlier version of my list, it would have.

ON MY LIST
Conan the Barbarian -- # 1
Conan the Destroyer -- # 2
Batman & Robin -- # 4
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles -- # 5
Ghost World -- # 6
Spider-Man 3 -- #7
Addams Family Values -- # 8
The Addams Family -- # 9
American Splendor -- # 12
Tank Girl -- # 17
X-Men: The Last Stand -- # 18
X-Men Origins: Wolverine -- # 19
The Mask -- # 20
Howard the Duck -- # 24

[Sexy Celebrity]

I should have 20 films from my list show up by the time this is done.

[Holden Pike]

Scott Pilgrim vs. the World and Ghost World, probably not surprisingly, both on my list. Hoped some of the great non-superhero stuff would be up at the tippy-top...but alas.

I had Pilgrim as my number five (twenty-one points), and Ghost World at number six (twenty points). Eleven of mine, thus far.

http://www.movieforums.com/community/attachment.php?attachmentid=13715&stc=1&d=1397750320

[The Sci-Fi Slob]

Seen 46/68

On my list

Man of Steel - #24
Superman Returns - #16
X-men: The Last Stand - #18
The Incredible Hulk - #11
Spider-man 2 - #17

[Miss Vicky]

If I had participated, Ghost World would've been my number 1. Sad to see it so low, but the only way I could've come up with the requisite 25 films would've been to throw in lots of crappy filler like Man of Steel and I just couldn't bring myself to do that.

I guess I should just be glad Ghost World beat out Teenaged Mutant Ninja Turtles, even though it was only by 1 point. :rolleyes:

[Swan]

Seen 31 so far.

[TheUsualSuspect]

Ummmm Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles is a classic film. Dark, funny, exciting and immensely rewatchable.

The less we talk about the weaponless sequel the better.

[jiraffejustin]

Scott Pilgrim is alright. TMNT is meh. Blue is the Warmest Color is fantastic. Ghost World is really good, but I didn't vote for it.

MY LIST

#1 - Whisper of the Heart (#42)
#2 - Blue is the Warmest Color (#36)
#4 - Ghost in the Shell (#40)
#5 - Only Yesterday (#63)
#6 - Porco Rosso (#50)
#13 - The Addams Family (#61)
#17 - Hugo (#48)
#20 - Tekkonkinkreet (#64)
#21 - Dick Tracy (#49)
#22 - American Splendor (#45)
#23 - The Lone Wolf and Cub: Sword of Vengeance (#81)

[The Sci-Fi Slob]

http://www.racebending.com/v4/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/The-Crow-brandon-lee.jpg

I'll be with you all soon....

[rauldc14]

Here's our sure fire bets

Iron Man
Iron Man 2
Avengers
Thor
Batman Returns
Batman Begins
Dark Knight
Dark Knight Rises
Sin City
V for Vendetta
Spider-Man
Spider-Man 2
Akita
Old boy
A History of Violence
The Crow
Superman Returns
Batman

[Swan]

Don't forget Hellboy, and the first two X-Men movies. Those will definitely make it.

[rauldc14]

I missed quite a bit. Yeah those are shoo ins

[The Sci-Fi Slob]

I like Ghost World. TMNT is a childhood favorite and a classic. Not seen the other two. I wonder if 30 Days of Night will make the list..it's on mine.

[Swan]

I missed quite a bit. Yeah those are shoo ins

Watchmen and Kick-Ass will make it, too.

[The Sci-Fi Slob]

Watchmen and Kick-Ass will make it, too.

Watchmen is in my top 10. Kick Ass not so high up.:)

[mark f]

The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp and Nausicaa are gonna show, and I would think Persepolis too.

[Zotis]

Ummmm Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles is a classic film. Dark, funny, exciting and immensely rewatchable.

Only in the sense that Ghost Busters and Jurassic Park are classic films. Not in the sense that Casablanca is a classic film.

Blue is the Warmest Color is a film I had forgotten existed and really want to see. And The Crow is a film I haven't seen in so long I can barely remember. I need to re-watch it.

[wintertriangles]

The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp and Nausicaa are gonna show, and I would think Persepolis too.Persepolis was really high on mine. I had NO idea those other two were adaptations. :(

[rauldc14]

Alright, so we have 26 confirmed then. We may as well race through this puppy.

[mark f]

Blimp's title comes from a comic strip, although the film is pretty much all original. Of course, Col. Blimp doesn't exist in the film although Wynne-Candy is supposed to be inspired to a degree by him. The movie was approved for the list though. :) Miyazaki himself released a manga of Nausicaa before the movie.

[jiraffejustin]

Dredd will definitely make it as well. Road to Perdition and Barbarella have fair chances too?

[Swan]

Dredd will definitely make it as well. Road to Perdition and Barbarella have fair chances too?

I hope Barbarella makes it, although I'm not so sure it will. :(

[rauldc14]

Well if u and Justin both had it on your lists and it got 18 points, then it's on,

[Swan]

Well if u and Justin both had it on your lists and it got 18 points, then it's on,

Unfortunately I totally forgot about it when I made me list. Makes me sad. It would have been high up too.

[Godoggo]

If I had participated, Ghost World would've been my number 1. Sad to see it so low, but the only way I could've come up with the requisite 25 films would've been to throw in lots of crappy filler like Man of Steel and I just couldn't bring myself to do that.

I guess I should just be glad Ghost World beat out Teenaged Mutant Ninja Turtles, even though it was only by 1 point. :rolleyes:

I just checked and Ghost World had my number one spot. I really did think it would place higher than it did. I figured it for being on a lot more lists than it was, even if people didn't place it very high.

[The Rodent]

I knew you guys couldn't help getting excited and get started on predictions... :D

[Sexy Celebrity]

I knew you guys couldn't help getting excited and get started on predictions... :D

FINAL TWO PREDICTION:

2. Young Guns II
1. Young Guns

[The Rodent]

Better than Priscilla being the number 1 in your 70s list.

[Zotis]

I was going to place Barbarella and Road to Perdition on my list, but unfortunately they got bumped.