But Chinatown isn't one of those films, because there is not one scene, not one single character, not one piece of dialogue that would make me want to see it again.
Jake Gittes is my favorite Nicholson performance right after Jack Torrence. I really hated Chinatown when I first saw it. The detective/mystery angle of it, is probably the weakest part of it, but what I understood later is that the movie is hardly about Gittes getting to the bottom of the case. Rather a tragic romance and character study.
As far as wit and truthfulness go in a screenplay, there's not many who can contend with Chinatown.
Every time I watch it, the characters and the actors sweep me away. I can get some general idea of who they are, but I'm always puzzled as to what's really going on in their mind. I think that's one of the most enduring qualities of a great film. We understand that Jack Gittes is hurt, inside he's bitter and disillusioned.
[an anonymous caller has telephoned Gittes]
Ida Sessions: Are you alone?
Jake Gittes: Isn't everybody?
And yet, he's wildly charismatic, charming, funny. He still faintly believes he can make a difference. Even after the depressing finale, in a week or two Gittes will be cracking jokes and back to his familiar self on the outside.
__________________