I've not seen Diner, but surprised it was so low but I guess like Ed just said it's more drama than comedy.
The Personal Recommendation Hall of Fame V: Comedy Edition
4th place
Takoma: 29 Points
Takoma: 29 Points
Brand Upon the Brain 1st - Phoenix
A Nous La Liberte 2nd – Edarsenal
The Extra Girl 3rd - Allaby
Good Morning, Vietnam 3rd – Siddon
Blade of the Immortal 5th – Cricket
Twentieth Century Oz 6th - Ueno
The Bank Dick 7th - Citizen
X
Favorite Movies
I've not seen Diner, but surprised it was so low but I guess like Ed just said it's more drama than comedy.
__________________
What I actually said to win MovieGal's heart:
- I might not be a real King of Kinkiness, but I make good pancakes
What I actually said to win MovieGal's heart:
- I might not be a real King of Kinkiness, but I make good pancakes
~Mr Minio
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
I'm not sure what kind of movie Brand Upon the Brain, the gif is curiously odd. But Phoenix gave it a 1st place and that's what counts.
X
Favorite Movies
Diner would have scored SO MUCH higher for me in a Regular HoF but I voted with the amount of laughter per film for the majority of placements.
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
I've not seen Diner, but surprised it was so low but I guess like Ed just said it's more drama than comedy.
Diner is a terrific movie, Citizen.
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
I think you'd enjoy it CR. It's a solid film, dramatically speaking.
X
Favorite Movies
Dinerm is a terrific movie, Citizen.
X
Favorite Movies
Takoma chose A Nous La Liberte for me?! How awesome!!
X
Favorite Movies
We're just about done now...
Victor Victoria 2nd – Citizen
3rd place
Edarsenal: 30 Points
Edarsenal: 30 Points
Victor Victoria 2nd – Citizen
Harold and Maude 2nd - Ueno
Chicken Run 3rd – Cricket
Swiss Army Man 4th - Phoenix
Death at a Funeral 4th – Siddon
Auntie Mame 5th - Allaby
The Pink Panther Strikes Back 6th - Takoma
X
Favorite Movies
I almost nominated it for you in general personal rec
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
2nd place
Phoenix: 34 Points
Phoenix: 34 Points
Take the Money and Run 1st – Citizen
Quo Vado 1st – Cricket
Boy 3rd – Edarsenal
The Castle 4th – Allaby
A Man Called Ove 4th - Takoma
Schizopolis 4th – Ueno
Used Cars 5th - Siddon
X
Favorite Movies
It's Rigged I tell ya!!!
1st place
Citizen: 35 Points
1st place
Citizen: 35 Points
Hairspray 1st – Ueno
Christmas in Connecticut 2nd – Allaby
Ocean's Eleven 2nd - Cricket
Avanti 2nd - Siddon
The Player 3rd – Phoenix
Holiday 5th - Takoma
Kiss Me, Stupid 6th - Edarsenal
X
Favorite Movies
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
CONGRATS CR!!
Here's how I voted for the noms sent to me:
1# Blithe Spirit (1945)
2# A Nous La Liberte (1931)
3# Boy (2010)
4# Symbol (2009)
5# Alfie (1966)
6# Ready or Not (2019)
7# Kiss Me, Stupid (1964)
8# Diner (1982)
Drop Dead would have been my #1
and Bananas would have come between Symbol and Alfie for me
Here's how I voted for the noms sent to me:
1# Blithe Spirit (1945)
2# A Nous La Liberte (1931)
3# Boy (2010)
4# Symbol (2009)
5# Alfie (1966)
6# Ready or Not (2019)
7# Kiss Me, Stupid (1964)
8# Diner (1982)
Drop Dead would have been my #1
and Bananas would have come between Symbol and Alfie for me
X
Favorite Movies
X