Short Film Contest with Barrie Osborne and Peter Jackson

I stumbled across these the other day, some competition where a handful of people got their films made in New Zealand by Weta digital and Barrie Osborne. Peter Jackson chose this one as the winner



I liked the idea but wasn't sure about the effects. I preferred this one, much simpler idea but I thought it conveyed the message well.




What do you guys think?

No love? These guys are who will be directing your future movies! Get the heads up now imo