Trainspotting never did much for me. It's interesting on a technical level, but I don't think it really gets at the heart of drug use and yes, I do think it glorifies a certain culture around it. Not that every film needs to have a heavy-handed message, but it's a film more in-line with something like Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas. Both films, aside from my admiration of them on an art level and a storytelling level, do absolutely nothing for me.
Two films that I think are brilliant in their approach are Requiem for a Dream and a much much older film The Man With the Golden Arm. Also a more recent-ish film Heaven Knows What by the Safdie brothers is equally brilliant and amazing and it gives me a gut punch on an emotional level too.
Something like Trainspotting seems very surface level to me as far as the impact it has beyond technical and storytelling achievement. I'll finish a film like Trainspotting and say "Wow, that was really interesting and well done!" and then go back to whatever. If I watch Heaven Knows What, I need to crawl in a dark cave and just feel ill for a couple of hours afterwards and not want to be around anyone as it's able to penetrate my soul just a bit.
Jackie Brown is spectacular and it's Tarantino's first great film in my book and transition film of a maturing storyteller. Up until Death Proof and certainly The Hateful Eight and maybe Inglorious Basterds, it was easily my favorite Tarantino film. In fact, I'm sure if I scoured these here forums, I could find a post from 20 years ago saying as much on how I though Jackie Brown is his best movie. Even so, it didn't make my list.
Two films that I think are brilliant in their approach are Requiem for a Dream and a much much older film The Man With the Golden Arm. Also a more recent-ish film Heaven Knows What by the Safdie brothers is equally brilliant and amazing and it gives me a gut punch on an emotional level too.
Something like Trainspotting seems very surface level to me as far as the impact it has beyond technical and storytelling achievement. I'll finish a film like Trainspotting and say "Wow, that was really interesting and well done!" and then go back to whatever. If I watch Heaven Knows What, I need to crawl in a dark cave and just feel ill for a couple of hours afterwards and not want to be around anyone as it's able to penetrate my soul just a bit.
Jackie Brown is spectacular and it's Tarantino's first great film in my book and transition film of a maturing storyteller. Up until Death Proof and certainly The Hateful Eight and maybe Inglorious Basterds, it was easily my favorite Tarantino film. In fact, I'm sure if I scoured these here forums, I could find a post from 20 years ago saying as much on how I though Jackie Brown is his best movie. Even so, it didn't make my list.
I actually would say that out of all of the good movies about drug addiction (and there are actually a lot of them), Trainspotting probably easily has the least to say about the subject, and is the furthest removed from reality (you mention Fear and Loathing as being similar, which I'm very lukewarm on jgenerally, but I wouldn't even call that a movie about drug addiction, it's really more about American excess, so I don't expect that to even bother with the realities of actual dependency, it wouldn't belong there)
But it's still loads of fun, is so marvellously made and I still find it very funny to this day, so I don't really hold it against the film. I don't need it to tell me why I shouldn't do heroin