When I was tallying the points it was easier to have the number of points next to the song, so I'm going to follow suit with you guys.
16. Vrolok - Within the Master's Chambers
15. Xasthur - Storms of Red Revenge
14. Earth Crisis - Firestorm
13. Lust - Spear of Destiny
12. Sarcofago - Ready to F***
11. Gospel of Horns - Vengeance is Mine
10. The Berzerker - Forever
9. Krisuin - Slaying Steel
8. Kreator - Riot of Violence
7. Jungle Rot - Gore Bag
6. Torture Squad - Pandemonium
5. Suffocation - Pierced from Within
4. Black Tongue - Coma
3. I Ate Everybody - Gather All the Bodies
2. Sepultra - To the Wall
1. Destruction - Bullets from Hell
Honestly the only stuff that got me excited was Vrolok, and Xasthur. Earth Crisis and Lust were really good too. Sarcofago were interesting, but I really hated the subject matter. As much as I love a lot of Satanic Black Metal music, I despise most of it's subject matter. And I recently acquired a taste for Pornogrind, Goregrind, Deathgrind, Raw Black Metal, and I reached the point where I don't think any music is too heavy for me to appreciate and enjoy. But I still find that the vast majority of the most extreme forms of music are 90% complete garbage in terms of it's subject matter (actually I could probably say that about all forms of music, and all forms of art for that matter). At least Satanic music that takes itself seriously has an element that I can respect in it's lyrical content and subject matter, even though it's evil. Because I love God, and fear him, I choose to hate evil. So I try to go into it being very careful about my frame of mind. I get tempted to lust when I see nudity on album covers, so I just look away and try to focus on the music. And when I can understand lyrics that are about sex it's either tempting or/and disgusting (depending on how vulgar and perverted the lyrics are). So all this is to say that I found it challenging to listen to Sarcofago, at least that song. And I had to listen to the song about three times to really feel where to place it. Instrumentally I liked it a lot, and the vocal techniques were very interesting, but the subject matter was a hurdle for me. Even my own nomination, Black Murder, is a band that I love the sound of but don't really listen to often because of how evil their imagery and subject matter is. Personally I don't really think of Satanic stuff as much more evil, or necessarily more Satanic, than other secular things like glorified violence in action movies or sexuality and lust in pop music.
Anyway, I'm just saying this to give you guys some insight into me, not to influence your nominations or anything. Everything from Kreator and under I rate
. I'd rather listen to that over what plays on the radio, but it's not music that I particularly enjoyed listening to. I listened to most of the songs all the way through, and about half of them more than once. A few songs I skimmed a bit because I started getting bored.
That Sepultra song was more interesting than the few Sepultra songs I've heard in the past, but I just don't really find Sepultra very interesting.
I Ate Everybody, Black Tongue, Suffocation, and Torture Squad were pretty generic in their Deathcore/Death Metal elements. I've listened to a fair bit of Deathcore and Death Metal, and it's some pretty muddy water with hundreds of bands that sound just typical and generic. So I don't really get too interested in them. I will drop some more Deathcore nominations myself before this is over so you can see what kind of interesting Deathcore bands I've found over the years (or at least what I consider "interesting").
Jungle Rot, Kreator, Krisuin, and The Berzerker had interesting elements, but overall did not particularly appeal to my taste/niches.
Lust were really interesting. I liked the sloppiness and the eccentric elements.
Earth Crisis are a band that has never particularly appealed to me, but that song was more interesting than probably anything of theirs I've heard before.
Vrolok and Xasthur were fabulous. I listened to a bunch more of their material. Amazing stuff!
As always AboveTheClouds, you never cease to amaze.
I'm sad you didn't submit anything this round, Swan. I guess it's a lot of new territory for you, and maybe you're feeling a bit overwhelmed. I'd suggest trying a couple of approaches during the course of this tournament.
1. Pick 1-3 particular niches that you have so far and do some googling for similar material. When you come across some material that you like throw it at us. Don't worry about listening to a band's whole album, or familiarising yourself with their discography before you decide to pick a song you come across that interests you. Don't bog yourself down too much.
2. Pick 1-3 particular genres/styles that you are not yet familiar with to explore and follow the same pattern as #1.
Anyway, that's just my personal approach to exploring music. It's nice to add whole albums to playlists, or to go through a great band's whole discography, but that can be very time consuming too. Sometimes you just have to sample a whole bunch of random songs to get a scope of what's out there and then when you have time you can pick the most interesting things that you've found to sit down and really absorb. I don't know what you're personal approach to listening to music is, but mine is kind of chaotic. Sometimes I go long stretches without even listening to any music at all, and sometimes I go through stretches of doing practically nothing but listen to music.
Judging from your taste so far I'd suggest sampling some first and second wave Hardcore (and maybe third wave and newer too), some first wave Metalcore, early Grindcore, Grindcore/Powerviolence, Crust, Death Metal, Thrash Metal (newer/heavier stuff than Metallica/Slayer), and some Deathcore too.
I don't know how busy you are with other things in your life right now, so just do whatever you feel like and don't worry about it. Just don't waste time doing things that are meaningless or not particularly interesting. There isn't enough time in life to sample every amazing awesome thing out there to waste time on things that are just mediocre.