Of those four directors, no, I don't think any one has made a truly great film. As I said, most of their work is watchable, and some are even entertaining, but I wouldn't call any of those directors artists, they're workmen. Nothing 'wrong' with that, but that's just the way I see their movies.
Let's see, director by director...
Taylor Hackford
Against All Odds is probably his best movie, and it pales in comparison to the original, Jacques Tourneur's Noir classic Out of the Past with Mitchum and Douglas. An Officer & a Gentleman was certainly popular in its day and made Richard Gere a movie star, but while it's competent and has some good performances, I don't think it's any masterpiece. Delores Claibourne is interestingly stylized visually, but compare it to Rob Reiner's similar Misery, also based on a Stephen King novel also starring Kathy Bates, and tell me which is the better film. The Devil's Advocate was slick, but hollow and really dumb, with a ridiculous cop-out ending. I watched most of Proof of Life on TV the other night, and it was pretty standard stuff. White Nights is nice to look visually, but really ordinary and dull otherwise. The Idolmaker and Everybody's All-American were pretty average too.
John Badham
WarGames and Blue Thunder are his best two flicks, but while they're good movies and hold up well despite their age, I wouldn't call either a great flick. Saturday Night Fever rightly made Travolta a star and is a decent urban coming-of-age story, but is it a great movie? I don't think so. Who's Life Is It Anyway? is a solid drama with a strong semi-autobiographical performance by Dreyfuss, but not a masterpiece. American Flyers is an OK little drama, but not in the class of a Breaking Away (not by a longshot). He can make good mainstream entertainments, like Stakeout, The Bingo Long Traveling All-Stars & Motor Kings, The Hard Way and Short Circuit, but he's just as likely to make horrible entertainments like Another Stakeout and Bird on a Wire. Even when they're good, they're not great. The Americanized la femme Nikita re-make he did, Point of No Return, was just embarassing compared to the original. Nick of Time had a decent gimmick and a strong cast, but it went nowhere. Drop Zone is junk. The Dracula he did with Frank Langella was extremely disappointing. He's been relegated to mostly made-for-TV stuff in recent years, which is probably where he belongs.
Roger Donaldson
No Way Out is a good thriller, I actually like the re-make of The Getaway, and The Bounty is an interesting take on that material, but none of those is a great movie in my book. Marie has a strong performance by Sissy Spacek, but not much else. Cocktail is a complete piece of trash. Cadillac Man is mildly watchable, but so very disappointing given that cast and that situation. It could have been a dark comedy version of Dog Day Afternoon. It isn't. White Sands is OK as a B-movie genre piece, but doesn't transcend the material. Dante's Peak is a dog. Species made money and has a following, but it's pretty average dumbed-down Sci-Fi, despite the excellent cast. Thirteen Days was ambitious and Donaldson's first attempt at a real, serious, adult, grown-up movie in quite a long time, but I thought it was flat and Costner was COMPLETELY miscast. When the '74 made-for-TV version of this story, "The Missles of October", is more riveting and well-made than what you can do in 2000 with the new effects and a good budget, what does that tell you about the filmmaker?
Peter Hyams
I already went through his filmography in the other post. Running Scared is probably his best film, and it's no Beverly Hills Cop, you know?
All four have made films worth seeing, and all four seem to have a fairly strong visual sense as far as composition and the overall look of a movie (or at least they communicate well with and know how to choose their D.P.s). But none has ever hit a home run...as far as I can see anyway. I own a bunch of those titles: Blue Thunder, Running Scared, Outland, Narrow Margin, White Sands, No Way Out, The Getaway, The Hard Way, Against All Odds and WarGames. I enjoy them for what they are and have seen each one of those flicks multiple times. But I don't think there's a masterpiece in the bunch, even in genre terms.
Feel free to disagree, of course. That's just my take on those four directors. Your mileage may vary.
Last edited by Holden Pike; 01-03-02 at 06:04 AM.