Thanks to these suggestions and reading through IMDB's list of movies that are tagged as "Horror", I already have a watchlist of over 100 movies, with almost 70 of them ready to watch either on DVD or scheduled to record on my DVR over the next two weeks.
I've already started watching too. I'm trying to watch an assortment of horror types, so I started with
Friday the 13th (1980) and
The Amityville Horror (1979) for the "real" horror, and a few comedy horrors including
Saturday the 14th (1981) and
Student Bodies (1981). I even watched the classic horror movie
I Was a Teenage Werewolf (1957), and the horror musical
Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street (2007).
Hopefully by the time I'm done, I'll be able to send in a complete list of 25 horror movies that I actually liked.
Thanks you to everyone for all the help.
I'm very interested in how you feel about these.
I thought
Friday the 13th (1980) was very boring and predictable. It seemed like the counselors didn't do much between the killings, and there weren't many scary moments. The only real scare in the movie was
WARNING: "SPOILERS!!!!" spoilers below
the scene in the boat at the end of the movie.
the scene in the boat at the end of the movie.
The Amityville Horror (1979) was a much more interesting movie, but that might be because I live on Long Island, so I've been hearing the stories about the house all of my life. (FYI, I don't believe the stories, and they seem even more unbelievable after seeing the movie.) I liked the way James Brolin's character changes over the course of the movie. And again, there weren't many scares in the movie, but at least this movie wasn't boring.
Saturday the 14th (1981) was a pretty dumb movie, but at least it's kind of fun. I saw this movie a long time ago, so I pretty much knew what to expect from it, and I wasn't disappointed.
Student Bodies (1981) is basically what a slasher movie should be. It's predictable and stupid, but funny. It's not too graphic, but there's just enough happening on screen to let the viewers know what's going on, without making me want to turn away from the screen. I love the on-screen count and the messages.
I Was a Teenage Werewolf (1957) was probably the most interesting of the movies that I watched so far. It seemed more realistic in the way that the people reacted to what was happening than in most of the other movies. It felt like I was more emotionally invested in this movie than any of the other movies. I thought Michael Landon was very good in it too.
I've seen
Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street (2007) several times before, and I've seen the Broadway show, so I knew this movie very well going into it. I don't think the movie is as good as the Broadway show, but it's still a good movie. But I watch it more for the music than the movie because I love the soundtrack.
I also watched these movies in the past few days:
Cursed (2005) was a pretty stupid werewolf movie, but at least it wasn't too gory and it wasn't scary at all.
I watched
Maximum Overdrive (1986) because Hubby wanted to watch it. The first half of the movie was pretty boring, but it picked up a bit in the second half. The biggest problem that I had with this movie was that I didn't really care about any of the characters, so I wouldn't have cared if the trucks killed them all.
What Lies Beneath (2000) was probably one of the better horror movies that I've watched so far. It has an interesting story with likable characters. However, even though there were believable red herrings, somehow I figured out who the killer was about 10 minutes into the movie. (Hubby thought I was wrong, but we realized about halfway into the movie that I was probably right.)
House (1985) is a horror comedy that I found while reading through IMDB's list of horror-tagged movies. I liked the cast, so I watched the movie. It's not a great movie, but it's one of the better horror comedies that I've watched so far. It was less predictable than most of the other movies, but it has an interesting story that kept my attention throughout the movie.