You know, if you read the paragraph he wrote under the film's name, he explains himself quite clearly.
I certainly tried to. I mean, this is a
subjective list. It's a film I love, for reasons that I made an effort to express. I am certainly open to answering any questions about specific elements, or debating my stance.
No Pixar films is unfortunate. I also dislike the pick of The Assassination of Richard Nixon. That movie has a good performance by Sean Penn, but it carries what is really a weak script in my opinion.
Pixar just doesn't enthrall me like it does with so many other people. In terms of cinema and what it has to offer, I have very limited interest in animated movies about robots and rats. I really enjoy
Monsters, Inc. and
Toy Story, but not to the extent where I can develop any kind of personal attachment. I have yet to see
Wall E and
Ratatouille, but I was very underwhelmed by
Up and
The Incredibles. I suppose they're fine for what they are, but they really don't intrigue me.
As for
The Assassination of Richard Nixon, obviously I disagree. Considering the script is essentially a character portrait, I consider it exceedingly well-written. The protagonist is intriguingly drawn and accessible, and provides Penn with the kind of texture required for a performance of that caliber. His descent is well-structured and believably played out, and I find the dialogue to be convincing and effective. I also think it's gorgeously shot by Emmanuel Lubezki (a great cinematographer), and directed skillfully.
I know I'm in the minority here, when it comes to hardcore film fans, but I think both Jason Reitman films Juno and Thank You For smoking deserve to be on a top 100 lists. I have a hard time figuring out why there isn't more Juno love for these types of lists when it did so well at the box office, amongst the academy and with critics. I love the Darren Aronofsky love though, especially Requiem for a Dream, which I think is one of the most focused, powerful, drug related movies ever.
I like
Juno and
Thank You for Smoking, but I'm not a big enough fan of either film to include them on this list. But I agree with you that they're good movies. I think Ellen Page is an absolutely beautiful and talented woman, but I am more enamored with her work in
The Tracey Fragments than
Juno. That being said, she's excellent in both films.
Always glad to meet other Aronofsky fans. Cheers.