Best version of Huck Finn?

Tools    





RIP www.moviejustice.com 2002-2010
Actually is there a good version or definitive version of Twain's The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn? I did see the one with Elijah Wood when I was a kid, but never cared too much for it?

Has anyone seen the 1920 silent version?
__________________
"A candy colored clown!"
Member since Fall 2002
Top 100 Films, clicky below

http://www.movieforums.com/community...ad.php?t=26201



will.15's Avatar
Semper Fooey
None of them are particularly good. Have not seen the silent version, but it isn't well known so I doubt it is a big deal. The 1960 is the best of a mediocre lot. It is fairly close to the book and has the best supporting cast of all the versions.

The best Jim is the 1939 version with the great Rex Ingram, but Mickey Rooney is miscast as Huck.



Bright light. Bright light. Uh oh.
The best thing about the 1960 version is the Jerome Moross score. The 1930s version isn't as good as The Adventures of Tom Sawyer made at almost the same time. I haven't seen any silent versions. It really needs to be redone as accurately as possible, maybe with Soderbergh or Alfonso Cuaron directing.
__________________
It's what you learn after you know it all that counts. - John Wooden
My IMDb page



Those sound like good choices, but I'm not sure either is known for their Twainian "whimsy", which might be something essential to an accurate adaptation.



RIP www.moviejustice.com 2002-2010
Not familiar with Alfonso Cuaron, but Soderbergh would be a great choice. After seeing King of the Hill, I'm certain he could bring out the dark humor in the text, which is absent from the Disney version I saw a long time ago.



will.15's Avatar
Semper Fooey
The 1969 adapatation of William Faulkner's The The Reivers is an excellent film starring Steve McQueen and has some qualities similiar to Huckleberry Finn.



Faulkner and Twain couldn't be farther from each other literarily, but the locale is probably similar sure.



RIP www.moviejustice.com 2002-2010
The best thing about the 1960 version is the Jerome Moross score. The 1930s version isn't as good as The Adventures of Tom Sawyer made at almost the same time. I haven't seen any silent versions. It really needs to be redone as accurately as possible, maybe with Soderbergh or Alfonso Cuaron directing.
Agreed. I'm going to watch the 1960 version here soon, but my impression is that all the films of the story are family oriented, which means they leave out a lot of the cruelty of the novel.

There's many dark scenes in the book; Huck being abused by his father, Jim being dressed up as the Arab, the thieves potential drowning in the steamship, and Huck finding the dead body of a good friend.

It seems like most versions focus on the adventures and the basic anti-slavery race message and leave out the misanthropic tones of Twain when he comments on religion, how fake people can be, fighting, family honor, mob mentality and so on. One of the best scenes from the book is when Sherburn confronts the lynch mob, but is that even in any of the films?



Ooooh, good question / thread idea.



Kenny, don't paint your sister.
It's funny that I googled my question at school the other day, and this MoFo thread actually came up.

Anyway, if I was looking for a movie as close to the book as possible what would be my best bet?
__________________
Faith doesn't make things easy, just possible.
Classicqueen13