The Master- A PTA Club Discussion

→ in
Tools    












Only two more discussion threads until it is time for The Phantom Thread. So flippin excited. Here is what I wrote about The Master the last time I saw it.

Such a tough film to unpack, but boy is it worth the effort. I can completely understand why PTA seems to be a director that cinephiles either love or don't care for. He really doesn't cut the audience any slack. Rather he grabs them by the neck and makes them decide one way or the other how they feel. His characters are written in a very challenging way, and The Master may just be the greatest example of that. It is not easy to get a hold of either the intentions or motivations of Freddie Quell and Lancaster Dodd. Quell is such an interesting character. Certainly one that is searching, but one that would on the surface seem unlikely to fall prey to the religion being crafted by Dodd. He is a free spirit whose personality would seem to be unwilling to allow itself to be penned up by such a rigid lifestyle. He does allow himself to be penned up though, even if it is only for a time. Does he see Dodd as a father figure? Does he love the feeling of belonging that can come from organized religion? Is he just biding his time until he sees a train that he would rather jump on? Probably a little of all of those at different times. I do think he grows to love Dodd. Much of that probably has to do with the way Dodd feels about him. It usually becomes very easy for us to fall in love with people who are showing us love.

So why does Dodd become so infatuated with Quell? It certainly can't be as simple as his love for his swill. Putting turpentine in your water can't be so addicting. I feel he is enamored with Quell's freedom. Dodd is the master of the cause, but he is also a prisoner to it. We see him become frustrated whenever his thoughts are challenged. We see his wife dictating their next move as if they were involved in chess rather than changing lives. Although he sets the pace, he is a man whose life has been dictated by his own motivations. I believe he wishes to have the freedom that Quell has many times, but he can't go back. Perhaps because he does believe in the cause. It is also a question that is raised of Hubbard. Did he really believe the religion he was putting forth, or was it all for money? We have the same question of Dodd, that largely goes unanswered.

That's The Master. These two characters walking through this part of their life. Searching and trying to reconcile who they are and who they desire to be. Every step forward is followed by two back. Sometimes connecting and sometimes needing to separate. It is a stunning character study. One with all the answers and no answers at all. This is my third time viewing it and it grows with me each time. I love it more and more. In addition to these two amazing characters The Master also has a dynamite score. One of the things PTA does extremely well is allow the score to speak to us when there is no dialogue. In The Master I especially enjoy this aspect through the first part of the film when we are getting to know Quell. The cinematography is also beautiful in this film, as it is in all PTA's films.

The Master is certainly one of the great cinematic achievements of the last ten years, and possibly ever.
__________________
Letterboxd



This viewing really cemented this film as a top ten for me. When watching PTA films I have also gone between Magnolia, Punch Drunk, There Will Be Blood, and The Master as which is my favorite of his. Watching them so close together and in order this time around I don't see The Master budging from that top spot. Often impenetrable films frustrate me but I think what sets PTA apart for me in general and in The Master in particular is that his impenetrable films still have an ease of thematics and great character development. They make them infinitely rewatchable for me and give me a great desire to understand them deeper than I do. I say all that to say that I still don't think I am anywhere near understanding this film, but it stays on my mind and gives me more to think about than just about any film I have ever seen.

I mentioned in my review above that I believe Dodd is so attracted to Quell because he desires the freedom that he has. There is a line in Dodd and Quell's last scene together that struck a strong chord with me this time. Dodd says to Quell, "If you figure a way to live without serving a master, any master, then let the rest of us know, will you? For you'd be the first person in the history of the world." I love how this line drives the theme that resonates with me the most. Everyone believes something, everyone serves a Master. Faith in nothing is still faith. So how do you decide who to serve? The ultimate question. I love it. Put me in mind of a very popular verse. Joshua 24:15



Looking forward to this even though I seem to have lost some momentum on watching these. I recently took The Master out of my top 10 and now I'm wondering if that was the correct decision.
__________________
Letterboxd

Originally Posted by Iroquois
To be fair, you have to have a fairly high IQ to understand MovieForums.com.



this movie sucks!

I havent watched it yet
__________________
Oh my god. They're trying to claim another young victim with the foreign films.



I agree with you, Seanc. The Master is PTA's magnum opus. It's also a top 10 film for me. It's a hypnotic and rich masterpiece. Words can do it no justice.
__________________
Cobpyth's Movie Log ~ 2019



I agree with you, Seanc. The Master is PTA's magnum opus. It's also a top 10 film for me. It's a hypnotic and rich masterpiece. Words can do it no justice.
I think TWBB is his magnum opus, and I see that as a top 10 all time masterpiece in cinema.

The Master is great though, and I view it as PTA's second best film, above Magnolia and Boogie Nights, which are also great.

The Master might be worth a rewatch this month. I've seen it twice thus far.